Skip to main content

Full text of "De Dionysio Scytobrachione ..."

See other formats


Google 



This is a digital copy of a book that was prcscrvod for gcncrations on library shclvcs bcforc it was carcfully scanncd by Googlc as part of a projcct 

to make the world's books discoverablc onlinc. 

It has survived long enough for the copyright to cxpirc and thc book to cntcr thc public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subjcct 

to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expircd. Whcthcr a book is in thc public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books 

are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, cultuie and knowledge that's often difficult to discovcr. 

Marks, notations and other maiginalia present in the original volume will appear in this flle - a reminder of this book's long journcy from thc 

publishcr to a library and fmally to you. 

Usage guidelines 

Googlc is proud to partncr with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to thc 
public and wc arc mcrcly thcir custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing this resource, we liave taken stcps to 
prcvcnt abusc by commcrcial partics, including placing tcchnical rcstrictions on automatcd qucrying. 
Wc also ask that you: 

+ Make non-commercial use ofthefiles Wc dcsigncd Googlc Book Scarch for usc by individuals, and wc rcqucst that you usc thcsc filcs for 
personal, non-commercial purposes. 

+ Refrainfivm automated querying Do nol send aulomatcd qucrics of any sort to Googlc's systcm: If you arc conducting rcscarch on machinc 
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a laigc amount of tcxt is hclpful, plcasc contact us. Wc cncouragc thc 
use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help. 

+ Maintain attributionTht GoogXt "watermark" you see on each flle is essential for informingpcoplcabout this projcct andhclping thcm lind 
additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it. 

+ Keep it legal Whatcvcr your usc, rcmember that you are lesponsible for ensuring that what you arc doing is lcgal. Do not assumc that just 
bccausc wc bclicvc a book is in thc public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other 
countrics. Whcthcr a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and wc can'l offcr guidancc on whclhcr any speciflc usc of 
any speciflc book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearancc in Googlc Book Scarch mcans it can bc uscd in any manncr 
anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liabili^ can be quite seveie. 

About Google Book Search 

Googlc's mission is to organizc thc world's information and to makc it univcrsally acccssiblc and uscful. Googlc Book Scarch hclps rcadcrs 
discovcr thc world's books whilc hclping authors and publishcrs rcach ncw audicnccs. You can scarch through thc full icxi of ihis book on thc wcb 

at |http : //books . qooqle . com/| 



Gd 40.10 
SCHWARTZ 



DE DIONYSIO SCYTOBRACHIONE 



ru;i".£-i«"»":\';:.'.':- 




G<J V^/^ 



i^attuirb Coliege Itiirarp 




Itmb tiw 

CONSTANTIUS FUND 

BcquMtfaed by 

Evangflinm Apostolides Sophodes 

Ttttor and PkoAMOr ef GtMk 
1842-1883 

vQK vjcccjCy Iiifinj ttid Anbic 







ssJiJjt: 




.!....— .?CM*et:;:!: »■:■*• • • 'v- 
j;^;:::5;::SS;::;n2:qr:.; •;:• 

IHii?iligi;j:n:!'M;ir';^r; 




l3:i#n«?3ir:uj:;.;.;.;:: :::::■• 




;ics;p: --:.:::. :.-.:r::.--. : • 
itJrMSii;"-.:;;;'^!;:::;;; ;:•::::■ 

■:l:iluifil::Bi-n?i::iv^: :;•:[:::; 
f!:i:E^i:sHil;i-li"v:.::;i; ■;:■:! 

liiiHttlS;:::!;;!-:-;:::^; 

••..(•••;*g;; • - • 

ii:t:;«:~::«::i:::;:-:i:rfj=:;:;:. 

:?;:»:?;;t?;n;:;?!?;:::;|::::rh--- 
ii2|a8jiiH>::t;-';:":;'|:!;;:;._; 

fec~l***i :•••;::•.::::::: :":*""*■.. 



«::!:;: ;:S?J.;"Jii5j(;t::::i 



:;ii:i:i;:«"fy« ■?:•!■;■:;■::;:■;::; 
;ii^hl^;.:;ni:;g::>iH|:;:: :;:■ 




H?!' :^' •■•^it?T;:?*;'- ■.'.'•'■*•■* 






f-:ai:J?::sjJ;:j:;-:!:i:;:;;;:-i::s: 
'•"••:i*;^5:' ;:•*"■;::' ::-';:::r 

•■■sliiiiitilii";:::: ■ ■; i::^ 



:;.-;.:;;* «i-'-:' :•;•::::::::: 
::;:j;;;.;:s::;:;;;.^;: • • • 

Bi:Jii=:i|i|;H;:::;i":;i::;":::::- 
HnJ-^i'i:|!i;-:-:"'i.i"':;:;:i:: 



t:^iu-!:;: •:;:;::•;•;:.•;::::; :::;• 
•■*:■•:?;■;::::::■■:*:::;:;:•:"":': 

p:^i?i^: i-^' —'•"■•"••• '•'•■' ■"•■:■ 

iijiiijiui-::'"-:":": ::'";: '2 
H ;;:.;;:.ji;;:;;:;;::;^:::r:::-5; 
F;;::ii;:;:::i;':":>:::::;i^i:i;::^ 



:•:::■ irs::::;;:!;:^ •;::::":;:;•:• 
■•••:;iai;i:2;ni;:i.;i";::*:-r=-: 

■iJ!iii;iHii:ni:i::::'l!:':!!';iJ 
il»iiSi«i=ri"ii:;^;;;::"-:^;l 

3.. ,.•#•-•; »7;, '.;. •,.;;;;,:;:;■....! 

"•••'"•■"tr'":- *-■' ■*;: *; tr'.i"T*! 
















-.-:i;::n::in:i:i?::;i.::ii.i%*i 



f' 





0. 



, t "" ^ 



■^ 



DE DIOrJYSIO SCYTOBRACHIONE 



DISSERTATIO PHILOLOGIOA 



j * 



♦ '■ ■<•■ 



:■.. >• 



->- 



qVAM 



^/ 



;> 



iV. 



Ab SVMMOS JN PHIL080FHIA H0N0RE8 
'AVGTOBITAtE AMPLIS8IMI PHILOSpPHORYM 0BDINI8 



VNIYEBSITATE FBIDEBIGIi QVILELMU BHENANA 

. . ■ ■ ■ • •■ • •■ •■ ,•• , • 

RITE IMPETRAin)OS 

"• ■ , • • • 

.■ '-^ ■ .-•■•■•■■::. 

j ; VNA CVM SENTENTIIS C0NTR0VER8IS 

DiE xiv M. ivLn A. GiaiaccGLXXx HOBA xn 

•••••*•'...••.,. 
i PVBLICE DEFENDET . : 

" ■ . • .■--•• 1 '■■ ; 

80RIPT0B V ; 




■^.yv .... 






♦ '■ 









»«. 



•*,' 



>>' 



** 



EDTARDTS MUWARtZ 

BOLsfffB 









»• 



^'^•i 



v-\ 



^ • 




\\ 



ADVEBSARIORVM PARTES 8VS0IPIENT 

CAROLVS BRANDIS bttd. phil. • v 
• PAVLVS MEIER «tvd. fhil. 
LVDOVICVS SEELBACH sttd. PHit, « 



» >-■ ' 



-r * 1 



•.>^: 



•'« *" , 
• ■*»**.. 



.... . TVfe 



.•■'Tt 



\'i^'^ 



T-"^:!»-.-/ 






•> ■ 

■ « . 

•>■■ ' . 

■ . 4 






10 N 



• ^" ^^ ^^^ • •• v-^^i^-- ; : 



BONNAE V ; 

N * TtPXS OABOLI aBOkoi, THnT. TTPOOB. 

\"'. '.\ . * •.'••' ■. ■• ■ .' 

>. ' • 1880 ' , 



S" S 



l1 

. • I ■" 



- .•,T. 



.v; 4 



f. 



Vi. 




"1 



,.;..> 






■\. * 



i. 









.• . -v 



.^ . '. 



«.' 



M<. y 



* : ■* 



,^*v> 







r 








(ht4X!byyMuf^ 




*% . 






I : 






.. » 






"J • * 

t 



>'^i 



s-.y 



t 
<f^ 



^ 



\ \ 



> * 



i 

i . 



• « « 



^ >'; 



UN!^' '"'■■'■"'' '~^ 
t^'JG 27 \^j'i^ }, 
■ - I 







/ 



f/;</ 



I ^*s 



« 



M 






'N 






.".1 



■4 
ti 



• • 



f • 



\ . ^ 



PRANdSOO BVECHELBR 
HEBMANNO YSENEfi 



i 



i 



V 



» ,• 



■j y 



S. 



I « 






»^ '. • 






\ 



\ 



, r 



L ■ 



V- 



/ 



S' 



s 



I 1 



1 ' : 



y.. \ ■:. 



■--v.::> 



I 



Graeooram historiae fabnlaris cam reliqnias qaae grammatiooram 
▼eteram commentariis compendiieqae haic aetati serratae 8ant| trao- 
tnndaB mihi proposuiBsem at earam origine «Itias repetita aactorita- 
tem fidemqae certiae ezqairerem, neqae qaidqaam antiqaias esae ha- 
bendum mihi yisam est' qaam at dare et adcarate cognosceretar 
qaibuB rationibas asi grnmmatici Alexandrini ingentes latiMiimeqae 
diffasaB historiae poeticae copias conlegiBsent et diBposaiBfient, noqae 
hoc fieri posse nisi ex TetaBtae dootrinae atqae diligontiae rade- 
ribaa hodie per 8choh*a compendiaqae foede dieiectis Tel aniaa 
yeteris mythographi certa memoria erata eseet. Ars critica qaibaa 
non mne eyenta adhiberetary altro obferebantar ca ApoUonii Rhodii 
Argonaaticoram scholia qaibaa fabalaram Tariae formae aliter ab 
aliis fictae et narratae bona atqae larga Teteram poetaram fcrip* 
toramqae noUtia ezhibita fase ezponantur. Neqae spee fefellit. 

Ac primam quidem has copias ab ano eodemqae homine 
congestas esse ideo saspicari licet qaod eadem fere semper adpo- 
sita legantar poetarum toI historiae fabularis soriptoram .Hesiodi 
Sophoclia Pherecydae Hellanici Herodori alioram toBtimonia^), neque 
hoc ApoIIonii commentatoram triadi deberi paaca simili ratione 
eiademqae fere verbis atqae in his Bcholii|i« in Pindari carminis 
P^ii quarti et Earipidia Hedeae commentariiB ezpoeita doeamento 
Bunt Qaod enim Bchol. Pind. Pyth. 101 887 nonnalli auctorei 
trei Tatea in Argonaataram numero recenBaiiBe dieantar HopBam 



1) E. 0. componuntur Hesiodoi et AntimaohaB lohoIL I 1289. 
H 178. 296. 207. IIII 259» HciioduB et SophooleB BchoU. U 178. IH 242. 
nn 284» HeBiodus et Horodoms sohoU. I 46. 1239. H 11*22. Hll 269. 
Herodoro Tel Sophooli adiungitar Naopaotiooram poeta sohoIL HI 242. 
lUI 69. 88. 87; iozta legantor Phereoydes et Herodoras s^lL 1 28. 
4& 1289 eto. eto. . 

;■ ■■. . 1 . 



.•1 



^ 

A 



v/ 



\- 



Idmonein Ampliiaraum, daos iUos priores inde ab ApoUonio omnes 
eommemorant, Amphiaranm a Deilocho scriptore fere prorsne 
ignoto 1) eeteris.additnm esse schbL ApolL 1 189 legitur. Deinde 
Volcanum Aeetae tauiM fabricatum esee ') Tel Enphemum a Tritone 
Enfypylnm rimnlante in Libya famosam illam glaebam ea de iBansa 
qnod nterque Neptnni filius eseet*) aecepisee in utroque commen- 
tario narrator, neqne aliter. in Apollonii et Medeae Bcholiis eadem 
de Phrizei Telleris colore profemntnr^). 

lam qoaeritnr ad qnem auctorem hic conaensus referatur. 

. Primos Tel Argonautae Tel Danaum naTcm oonstmxiBse sbholiis 

_ ApolL 14 et Eur.Ued. 1 *) broTiter adnotatur, neque temere quo-' 

niam nominis Ai^o eadem Tcriloquia in scholio Euripideo ' atque 

' apnd Diodomm [IIII 41, 8] legnntnr, etiam ea quae apud Diodomm 

de ipsa naTC dicuntnr Q. c § 1]: wd nirnmv fih nsQl xh Il^Xtor 

mvmtff4aao9^tu wiqnoq nolv xw 'fteyidH tud t^ Xotitj natamsvg rijy 

«f» mt¥^9ua¥ vftMQfitOJior Aa ti oj(Mm^ nXuv vol^ vou avdQtinovq 

uoi iuxifoii naraiXwQ oiuaioig Gum scholiis illis consooiantur *) atque 



l)Cf. FHG n p.l7 8q. 

2) Cf. sehoL ApolL IU 409 (qaod ad Tersnm 229 sq. pertinet) oom 
sehol. Pind. Pyth. IIII 898. 

8) Cf. sdioL ApoIL IIII 1662 rop Elfpfuiior inoivioi dixofitvop tiip 
fmkov #»* olmtotiftn^ iml IToonJwros tml EvQtantif t^ 7>rM>v. jml Ev^ 
Qonvlof ik ov <l( rry jtw^^ nnQfyivopro^ noonJmvog iot9p viog. Hyitm 
iik «al nttgaUiP^n^ ott iSi^o tt^p pmlov 6 EvipmiostxkTO schoL Pind* 
^ftb. IIII 86 tViltoimSh St^ ttP tdtiap wttJi^o tifp pmXoP 6 Ewptiftos,,, 
ol ^k iiu tiiP ovyyipitta^* iifttpotigoi yoQ ITooiMpos o ti Jovf aml o 
Imftiv. Idem scholiom panlo sliter scriptnm ts. 61 adpositum est nbi 
altenim o^ H delendnm est. . 

4) Cf. sdholl. Apon. nil 177. 1147. Eor. Med. 6. Anctprum nomina 
in seholiis qoippe qnae codieom marginibns sdscribi solerent^ oonfundi 
wiD mram^ esL 

6) Cetomm huins fsbnlae anctor esse ridetnr Philostephanns Cy- 
renensis cL PUn. n. h. YII 297 quon jDonlatis Aocii frsgmentis sp. C*io. 
d. naC deor. n 86, B9 oonioias haeo ez Graeeoram poetis tragicis somp» 
aisseu PMeterea ot Eralosthenem [catssterism. p. 174 ed. Robert]. 
Foeiea Argo primam naTem fnisse saiipe traditnr: praeter Sezt Emp. 
adr* dogm» III 88 p. 896 BekkerJ eti Orph. Arg. 68 sq. inprimis ot 
pootasBomaaos.^CatnlL 64, 11. Orid. amor. I 16, 2L II 11, L met 
YITSL TIIl8fSL(trist in9,7.eKPont ini,l. Senec Med. 2. 801 sq. 
«96 aq. tio sq. ya)or, Flaoo. 1 1. 699 sq. V 472. 611. 8Ut Theb; Y 886 sq. 
X84,' ' 

'i*os oodieaa anetoritate ajoanne Laseari. in: Appllonii 







■••VvX *.:.f-i.i:|. ,.,^ •- - 



•T 



» 



x. 



:•■■...;; 8, ■ 

omnM tres loci ani anctori Tindicaniar. Adoedunt alia. Seholiis 

. Apoll. I 1289/1168 Heroalem Tariis de oansis Tol Argonaniamm 

expeditioni non interfnisse yel in itineroy onm de naTo diaceBaisaeti 

. ^ .. a 800118 in litore relictnm 0880 mnltis auctoribna adbibitis ezpo- 

'. nitnr. £x ii8 8cboI. Pind. Pytb. IIII 803 labulae Heeiodea et An- 

^ • timacbea redennt, atqne ipenm Heeiodi nomen olim ibi eeriptnm 

'^■/•..' ■' 0880 Tidetnr qnia Hercnlem aqniuidi oanaa naTi egreasnm eeso non 

- Pind^me eed Hesiodae narrat et Toterie poetao nomen deest qnod 

viu; vmxiqw; obponatnr. Addas poetam Colopboninm etiam in 

ecboliie Apoll. III 409 et Pind. Pyth. IIII 898« qnae rapra oomme- 

: f ' mbraTi/ einsdem rei (agitar do Aeetae taaria) aaotorem. ferxi 

Atqai fabalam Hesiodeam Diodome paalo poet qaam ex Dionysio 

Mytilenaoo Hercalem Argonaataram' dacem faiaae narraTit'), addit 

' [1. 0. c. 44, 5] : o/io/a»( di ual tbv *H(Kudia np^ noQoMimtaai n^ 

pSQ$iav HEsXdvvitt uaiA n^i^ ^Aolav vni ifSr l^Qyovavwoav iid t^; 

^^ X^oQct^ dnoXeupd^^vm '). Deniqne conferantnr qnae ezhibet IHodoru 

0. 47, 4: SuiTtleikm yag aixiv tpaaiv o! fiiv ini vsAg n(Mnofi^¥ iii 
T^ itgwQa^ ixpvotjg kqiov nal Ti^y *SU^ &vog)OQOvaav inlv^ ynvi^ 
nal iuk To€'io inl lov To//ot; t^g vsp^ htxvnwvoav Ag Ti)y ^viXar 
T»y n^ncofiiy* mw ii ipaai xiX. — seqnitar inepta paedagogi 
»— , Kqiov bietoriola e Dionysio anmpta') -* onm 8ohol. ApoIK 1 256: 

^ ii latoQla xfimcft naQa *Exatalif Sn i nQtbg ildl^asv^ moi M 
ipaaiv avtiy inl xQWTtQtpQov mtdg^ovQ nketkm. ^un^iauig dti jciL^). 



scboliomm editione principe vavv ftaxQav ecriptum ett. Prior sebolii 
pars conmpta ett. ApoUonias enim Teriloqaii mentionem omnino doh 
feoit, sed hftc de caase Phere^qrdes oomparator qood alter Argun 
oonstraotorem Arestoris , alter Pbrixi filiom dixit [of. ApoUod. I % 
16, 6], neque Teriloqaio ab Argo oonstraotore desampto aliad stenuBi 
Argi, sed Toriloqainm eb alio Terbo deriTatom obponendom erat. BioM 
res inier se ex diTersa ratione olim obpositae postea oonfueaa 0080 vf 
dentar. Unde Teriloqaium eb Etymologo [p. 186,81] ot Tsetsa [W 
Lycoph. 888] serTatam flaxerit, mo prorsas neeoire Jngenne IktMr: eos 
feratar si pUoet schol. ^70. 

1) Cf. 0. 41, 8. ApoUodor. 1 9, 19, 4. sobol. ApoU. 1 12188 [FH6 1 
p. 7 fr. 1]. 

2) Qaod et Diodoras et Pindari soboliasia pro Magneem Tha 
saliae Tulgarem fabalam secati Mysiain reposaerant, nihU Talere Tidetsi 

8) Cf. sohoU. ApoU. 1 266. H 1144. mi 119. 177 [FflG Q p. 8 frJ] 

4) Eaedem sententiae atqae altera quidem Palaephati testiacnii 

mnnita apud Eosebium [oan. 684 p. 88 Soh.] inter se obponuniiir, taiMi 

de Palaephato param oonstat ut aliqaid certi ot etoa ttentione ooneb 



'.. r- '. y 



•/-, 



mt ■ Bfc I 



fragnieiit» schollis Apollonianis inseria cam eis qnaelMo- 

donis do Argonaatarnm fabnlie [im ^ 40—56] tradity arte eohae- 

rere oi ad totnm illins enarrationie tenorem optime qnadrare cum 

olim Tiri docti oognoTisseift ^), Diodomm Dionyeio Mytilenaeo 

anetore nram eeee adco firmis argnmentie Welckems probaTit') 

Qt niqne ad Irnnc diem omnee Tiro inoomparabili adBentirentnr ac 

Abnlas Argonanticai qnas ^a ceteris Graecomm fabnlie sepositas 

iino tenore indo a Poliao mandato utqne ad Medeae in Anam reditnm 

Diodorae enarrat, ad nnam omnee e Dionyeio ramptae esse constaret 

Neqne Toro Diodomm qnaa in Argo nominie Teriloqniis ezponendis et 

m Herenlis Phrizi Phinei rebns narrandts fabnlamm discrepantias 

adferi*), cai do rao ingenio toI doctrina adiecisee licet contendere 

qnia eaedom eemel scholiis Apollonianie, bis et Apollonianie et Pin- 

daricb toI Enripiddi inrant Adoedit qnod et qnae de naTc arietii 

eSigiem in roetrii ferente ex ichol. Apoll. I 266 ezicripii et qoac 

Ib lehoL Apoll. IIII 177 cnm ichol. Enr. Med. 5 concinore de* 

■MmitraTi, lllii locii proxime ab ipia Dionyiii mentione alMhnt. 

Ilbi igitnr diierepantiai a Dionyiio qnippe qnem Tetemm poeta- 

mm leriptommqne teitimonia adponere lolitnm eiie Diodomi 

ipee dicat [III 66, 6]: nuQundtlg t& nonjfiuta n0y aQx^tmp vSi¥ n 

tiv9okiymp Moi ii3r inMi^icSr, narrationi iniertai eiie ^) nec minni 

recto Apollonii Pindari Enripidii icholiomm conoentnm a Dionyiii 

ab omnibni encripti anctoritate repeti firmo atqne eerto indicio 

pftNinntio. Qnod Toro apud Diodomm laepe hiat oratio, eadem 

bia Tol iiidem Torbii narrantn^, magnnm de fabula aliqna inter 

seriptorei eiio dinenram complnribni lodi adnotatnr *), haec omnia 

• Dionyiii libromm indole ac natnra a Diodoro ramma neglegentia 

datnr. Ceieram pro ariete naTem arietii effigie omatam lubstituere 
lieebat niii ca fabnla qnae haud raro Ii^gitnr non por aorem, lod per 

ariete Tcctoi ene Phrixam ot Hdlen pro fandamento poiita. Of. 
Sratoithrai .eateit p. 124 qnem leqaitar OTidiut fait III 868, et ipie 
Molor Senecae pVoad* 1044 •q.Thyeit 868 8q.]etValeri Flaoci [1 281 sq.]; 
pimoleisea Hjgin. Hh, UL arg. Apolli Arg. p. 684 Keil. Palaephat 81 
pw S89 iq. Weiterm. qnae, ab Eoiebianiii illii pronni diioreprat 

1) Ct qnoi adfert Welokeri ep, QreL I p.80 n. 99. p. 84. 

S) Ct ep. Prol p. 68 iq. ; I 
' Q Ct qnae rapra exicripii et d. 44| 4. 

4) Conieeti.koo neqne tamw oertii argnmentii oini 0. Sieroka 
bk prognmm^ \ffmntM lifokiani cni inicripiit: Die mythograpbiichen 
Q— Ikm iAr lUodoro 8. n..4 Bnoh mit bnondorer Berfiekiiohtigung dei 
D io ^ iei SlT^lwaeUon. 18TB. p. 9. 

i) Ot 0. 4i, 8. 44»4eq.46, 8. 47,4. 49|7. 6^7.649 8.66»6.68» 1.8. 

• ' • ' 1 l ' i 1 l • 



;1! 



exoerpiorain opUme ezplioantiir. mam enim res Argonaatieu iU 
* enarraaae qnasi expeditionem navalem qualee iprioB aetate geri 
Bolerent, pragmatiee exponendam eibi propoiaiaseti minime reote 
^ ueque ad hano diem viri docti exietimaTere, sed qaamqaam Tetostae 

fabttlas Bive at ail rationes pragmatioas adoommodaret tiYe at res 
antiqaituB traditas impadonter noTando Tolgas deleotareti immu- 

^" ' tabat atqae pervertebati tamen ea ipsa qaae Toteres memorias 

prodiderant, summa diligentia atque dootrina ondique oonrasit et 
oongessit oongestaque narrationi pro dootis sane ornavientis inter- 
posuit ^). Saiie siqais apud Dionysium [Diod. Ull 41, 8. sokoL 
. ApoU. 1 1289. Apollod. 19, 19,4] Argonaatas Heroulem expeditiom 
praeposuisse legerit, mythographum non probasse oonioiat quod 
^ . ApoIIonius heroas loYis filio Tirtute omnibus praeoellenti lasonem 
praeferentes feoit idemque iam oertius illum fabulas traditas aaia 
rationibus sine uUa auotoritate immntasse putet Modeae insidiarum 

^^jjL soelerumqne enarratione oum fabula Euripidea oomparata. Plerom- 

queEuripidis Testigia lognntnr: ntrubique Medeam onin a Greonte 

. ex urbe eioeretur, unum diem ab illo petiTisse quo fugam et eziliom 

praepararety narratnr') et qua Euripides in prologo lasooem et 

Medeam olim ooniunctos fuisse eonoordia memorat '), ea iUio faaini 

^. desoribitur [o. 64, 2] : lotlfiDi^ fih o3r ti^ xx^vov lon^vdir ^o- 



1) Flomisse enm altero a. G. n. saeoab exeunte oonsequiior ex 
V Sueton. d. gramm. 7. ' M. Antonius Oniphc ... in«titatasqae Alezandrisa 

f^- * ■ ■ qaidem nt aliqui tradnnt in oontabemio Dionysii Soytobraohionia qaod 
^ oquidem non iemere orediderim oom teroporam ratio Tix oongruai* of. 

Ilaohtmann, de Dionysio Mit^lenaoo sea Soytobraohione diss. Bona. 186&. 
p, 18. Soytobraohione toI Soyteo oognomine eam asam esse Soidsi 
tradidit; ita tamen omuia oonfudit ut mea quidem sententia omnino 
abioiondus sit. of. Weloker. 1. o. p. 76 sq. XanthiLydi historiaa nb co 

.^ '. ^ ' interpolatas osse legitur apud Athenaeum XII p. 616D... t^ Itftro^ 

Snv!h>s 6 jivdo£ 9 o rfc; %U avtov avaipt^fiivttg icroQiac avyytyQmpmS 
Jiovio9og 6 SxvtopQaxiwv »( *Aif[iiMt$v ip^iAv 6 Xaaav^Qtvc iv rf ni^ 
awaymy^S /UpXitiV of. Weloker, kL Sohriften I p. 481 sq. 

2) Ear. Med. 8iOt /iiav /rif fnTvat f^vd* Itiaov ^fiiifav 

nvX htfAmqavm fpQovti^ j fptv(oifA9Hi 

ol. oam Diod. o. 64, 6: t^v M MiJaav iUlawofAivnv i» tlis jroisMC wd 
fiiav ifiiffav naffii t o0 XQiovrof lafovaav ilc r^V t^q ipvy^ jrnosi^mir.* 

8) Ys. 18 sq.: avtii 6k navra tvfHpiQova^ *[aaovt'' . _ \ : 
' 'V \ \ ^ntQ fityiar^ yiyvttat amtfQia . .^ V.^ 

^ ' > . • itaiv ywii nifif Mq» ^4 i^;toef«r|. 



\ 



MSKocii^a9m neqiie iniiiiu qaae infra l^ntiir: ayananoum dir^ 
fvmuAg nt dsovg fiagmffafiiniQ xoig ininntg fBPo/iirovg m» i^/m¥ 
IbdeMB Thenidii lovii. DianM nnmina teBtantom [of. ?i. 160 sq.] ^ 

fd boi prologi Terrae in memoriem revooant [20 aq.]: 

ATifdba d* 17 iimpfog ^Ufiatffiipri • . ' 

fiof fih iQKOvgf ivaxaXd ds (b$ia( "" 

nlaar fioytanpf xat" dwig fiaQvvQom 

oISbiC iifiotfitjg ^ 'Joooyoc nv^fi^ 

Sed nd eandem Earipidem referenda eet qnae alio looo adnotatur 
dieorepantia' [0. 64, 6]: npig di t&¥ avyyQaqdiap ipad to^ fth vlovg 
w^ M^Uag dwga Wfilaoi ig pififg faQfimtmg MiXQtfii^^ t/^p H 
rkamap^ i^Siafiinpf uul «p ouj^an niQi99fiiv^¥ a^i^ n oiyi^o^ 
«ym e rf r tud lir natiQa fiov^dovna xal rov adfiawg itffdfisvov n* . . 
iMvHjam ^). Aliie toto loois aperte id aotom est nt qaaeoomqae 
m poeta parom apte inetitata eeee neqne beoe inter ee oondnere 
^rideraitari eonrigerentnr et fieverioribne rationibas diiponerentar. 
& jf« qnae illio eo faotaram minatur Hedea [878iq0: 

nfyd' itp^HBP ^fiiQav 

t"^^ t^t i^ 9 IP^C ^y ifiWV ^^dQ&r PSMQOVQ * 

^oitf, noiiQa t$ Kal xiQfpf nioiP t' Ifiop.. . . 

nMig d* ^(ovaa Sapaalftovg avnig HodQ 
ovtt oU*^ inol^ nQ^kop iyj^QWf iptXm, 
novBQOP itptit/nt idifia PVfnptMip nvQl 
f dfpttip Akm fpaayapop A* tptaioQ 
atyjl UpunvQ dgfiStf Ip^^mQonm l^pK* 

oU* fr tl fiot- nQiguPttg* el Xm$iiaofim \ 

HfiOVQ vntQfiaiPovaa muI ux^mfiipvf^ 
^atfovaa ^tjaot ttiilg iftotg ix^QoHg yiXotp. 
MQtiutnu tijp oi9dap ^ nmpiMafiSP 
uofot puiXttnu^ fpaQfiJMotg avvoig Hkdp 
Ue elreoaO' ebMqoitar *). Etiam in hao re apnd Diodoram ikbala ' 



1) Ct786eq.: niftt/m ykQ lAttAg dwQ^ Ijfoimc ip jr<^r* 

tmpniQ htponaa ttiofiop ifupt^j XQ^» 
. l * tiMMmc iX^tm nSc\9^ St Sm ^y^ «o^* 

tottMt XQ^ tpttQfiiuott ittQtiftmt^ 
ot 947'eq. ll^ iq{ Eadem negligentia Saripidee a Diodoro avyyQutptvt 
4ioiftar qoa o. 44^4 Sophoolei fi e foypgyotf. 

1} 0. 64t ,I6;m4 ^iiler ipiiQop nMQu tov XQionot XupovaMP ilt tigp 
o<r ^pMy^ m|iioijn4r tlt ptkv ti fiuaiXtm pvMtit tltiX^Op iXXotmauaup 



«• •» 




^ •- 









t 



melius prooedit quod cnin laso eiSiigiBMt oeqne all» elis fpei «sset 

digoae eum perfidiae poenas datorami Medea immane iUnd iraelu 

committit; denique addas apud Euripidem laaonem cum haud 

4 . pauca exousandi causa protulisaet, a coniuge irata tebemotttiiiime 

- Titnperari quod haec omnia non antequam Oreontis filiam ia ma- 

trimonium duxiBset, secum commnnicaeBet [SSSsq.]: 

-— ' ,. rl wvi* '&¥ sv^tifV evQor evvv^iats^r 

^ naUu y^fiM fiaatXiuig givyaQ ywwQ^ 
^ 'oix 11 ov xi^/^, abv fiiv ix^ulg(a¥ Xixog , ^ , 
. 559 uXX' WQ t6 fiS¥ filytawv^ fAmtdifm xoJUtfg, • • 
5G2 naidttc dS ^^mfi^ ^cag iofim ifiw¥ . 

anslgag r* oiAfpoiig toiaiv ix ai9sp T&ivOig 
slq ravio Mtiv ual l^pva^aag yivog 
sHiUfiovolnv 
586 XQflv o* slnsQ ^adu fiij Muxog^ Ttsiauvtu fts 
^^ yufisXv yufiov tivi*^ iAXa fiij aiyg gJkuv, 

apud Dionyiinm hoc re Tora fieri [c 54, 2] : fistu is tavtu ofi 

. fAaXXov tov xjQOVov vifv fivoutijy simQijmuv uqmQovfiirov Xiyttm tiv 

^luaovu nUcvJCj^ Igaa&ivtu t^g Kgiovtog dvyutgbQ fivtfitsvaai t^v 

nuQdivov, avymtudsfiivov ii tov nutfig wl tdl^vtog ^fiiguv toSi 

^ yufioig 10 fisv ngaitov imfiaXiadm (foiAv uvtbv iul9uv tifv MijiHav 

sxovaiaiq nuQux(OQtfiui t^g avfifiuiasiag' fiovksa&m yuQ ttUafv yofisiv 
ovH Anoioxifiuauvtu t^v nQbg uvtijv ifuXluv^ iXXa toig tixvotg osnv- 
iovtu avyysv^ tbv tov fiuaiXiwg oljcoy noi^aui» ayavuKtoiatfg ii t^ 
yvvaiHog nal dsoig fiuQtVQOfiiviiQ id^c inintug ysvofiivovg t&v OQmv 
^ : fuai Toy 7aoDm xutwpQov^auvtu nav iQmv y^fiui t^v tov fioKhkimg 

' dvyutiQu. •- 

Sane igitur Dionynus Euripidem presse secntuB esae Tidetor, 
paucoB tamen locoe ut melior aptiorque remm ordo et coneziiB 
restitueretury oonrexiBse atque ita quidem conrexiBBO ut cansa et 
ratio conrectnrae apertiBBime elnceret. At nnm in hoo iudieio 



Totg (fKtQfiaxoit niv ctvr^; Stjftv xnX r^y otxittv t!^«^ifi ^fiov n nQOC^* 
aav itfQfifiivov fikv vnb XiQxrig tfjs AisUp^Ct ivmfnv i* i^ov inav 
iSnfp^j ivaxtttAaptarov» ifpvm ik ipXtyofiivttv ri5r paotXtiuv r&y piiv 
Vttffonr xaxim ixntii^tUf r^r ii rittvxtiv mil tbv KQiovta rov nvqii 
ntQixaxalafovtot iiaip^oQVfvtu. Vel in BoholiiB [ad tb 876] adnotatum 
cst poetam in hao re pamm sibi oouBtitiBBe: nmg inayyttlafiiv^ uwsktSv 
tbv *laaava ovx Av&Xt; utju Cetemm onm tota regia arsiieoti MeAem 
infantcB nBcaBie Seneca qooque tradidit [tb. 892 Bq.^ Apud Buripidem 
neque inoendium oritur et poct filiomm caedem Qlaiieam Creont«BiiqM 
Medea oertior fit 



* 






8 

•dqnietem lioeiit^ Tel ee de eeusa duUmn eit quodHeroulem Argo* 
BMiUnuB dacem faieee primne non Uionydua, aed Nioander auoior 
eel*). Imb ooofenuitttr velim Hedeee fahulAO quam oompoeuit 
Neophroi reliquiae [FTO p. 065 Bq.]. Quomodo adoiderit nt in 
aammie aogaetiie Medea Aegeam auxilium ao refngium pollioentem 
ioTenireli ex Enripide prortna non intellegitari Neophro quaei Eu« 
ripidia n^I^entiam eonrig^erety eautius ree ooneotlt [lobol. Med. 
,666]: HMfiyoir di dgK6ifip9o¥ livjilyia 9^ naQoywio^m nghg 
JMf dJFMir hmtn loil awppwd^^rm ait^ tir XWt^^^ ^* aMf^ r^C 
3^Uac pfifffap ojfntfc' 

xal yaQ nr* a^ric ipLvdvp Xiap fia9^v 
ooil* Ilvdtar yif taaav fr ^(fpfrifioi 
dW//otf n(f6fAavu^ avfifiaXur afitfftavw* 
ooi d* etg Xayaig fiokmv / Sr ipljriibr fiad^v. 

Yel ex bao re Wilamowitsium [anaL.Eur. p. 155] reotinime con- 
tendieee adparet qnalee Neophronis reliquiae eisent, talia ante 
Enripidem eeribi non potnisBO neqne nlla relinquetur dubitatio 
mqnia eoliloqniia Medeae ') intpeotis ezaminaTorit qna aetntia nrae 
ille Tonne Enripideoe inflexerit liTe qnae Olio itaeine diountur 
lo^ter adtingene eiTe broTitates elegenter amplifioans. Denique 
m oertieiima deeint doonmentai lasonii raioidium Neophronie fk- 
bnlae proprinm*) etiam apnd Diodornm oeonnit [0. S5, 1]: i¥ 
waoiof ii lip f/Up *ldawa awqt^ivja xixmp nai yvimxhg iSSiM 
namXxtua n§7tor9iym*' Ai nal fi^ ivv&fuvov ivoymv xb fAiys9og 
t^ avfifpoQa^ bt vw (^v iavibv ftmumflai. Ita igitur quomodo 
fMlnm eit nt Dionytii narratione rel ipse toI conreotns Euripides 
ptoponi Tideatnr« ezplicandnm est nt apnd Diodomm Neophronis 
Medeae aignmentnm ex Dionysio exoerptnm extare exietimetnr. 
Celirnm Neopbro eimulatqne Enripides Medeam doonit, nnllo fere 
tenporie epatio intermieso snam fabnlam Athenieneibne propoeuisse 
Tidetor nt qnam fitmam Enripidie obtreotatores disperserant oele- 



•I) Ci Antonin. Liber. XXYL 
Q GC Keophr* fir. S. Ear. Med. 1043 sq. 1049 sq. 
9 SsImL Med. 1887 .... JiMOf^v dk (•nxmtgov ayxovff ipnol 
* f^ yag Mi^ttav nagiytit W^ crvrir «IjrovoMr* 
tCot fpHgti yag aMf «fo/Aity ftogf 

l Hiff^X^h^ ifXO^ intanaaat Hg^ * 
;. y ^/ '• #oifis 01 fMXqa aih ttaamv igymv ftivu 
. ;. .^«ift^ &Uof^ f»aglat€ itp^ifiigoti 
* H jMa imog^i fi^int^ tHgoa^ fgamic 



\. 






o 



9 

berriroam eiuB fabnlaiii Noophi*oni esfo •ubreptanii ea Arislotelii Dioae- 
arohique teniporibue ore<lerotur oreditaque roemoriae traderetar *)• 
Infra quae inter nmltae ao tariai Modeae fabulamm fonnai 
adferuntur [o. 56| 5] : nvi^ d* latofotmv itp^ *Inniiov lOff Kfioi^ 
' iffUTovfiiytiy tvxfXy KglaewgKai nSr iykkiiftdmp inokvdtjnu non aine 
magna vori limilitudino ad Hedeam apod Euripidem ne ab Aegeo 
«T^^ . inimioie in iudioium traderetur tiroentoro referuntur [of« te. 784 iq.]., 

Atqui oerto ad iudioium aliquod ipeotat Coroini Hedeae fragmen- 
tnm ab Ariitotele lervaturo [rhei II 28 p.l400B. FTO p.630]: 
2Uo( idnoQ xh Ik nSy ifiUQir^imp xunffofstp f unoX»yita9m olbr 
ip Tjl KaQHlvov Mvfidff ot fth xtttfiyoQoiw Sn toi^ nuUug Ani* 
HmvsV ov ff)ulvia%hu yov¥ avwoiig* ^uqvb yAq if Mijiuu nsQl rijp 
inoatoki^v jwv nuliot¥* ^ d* aoiokoy^iui on otK ar tov^ nmSa^ 
. aXku xbv *Iuaom &¥ anixmW fotio yifQ ^oqw &¥ §i^ mnifooaB 
tlnsQ iud MuQoy Inobfjsv. In Peliadum fabulae enarratione 
^v ^ [o. 60 — 58] etii Hedeae niaohinationei et artifioia mmmopere 

amplifioata et exornata atque omnino mnlta mirifioe oontorta eiie 
Yidentur, ipium tamen argumentum dignum eit in quod adonratiui 
inquiratur. Qnae enim ibi narrantur Hodeam laoerdetio Dianae li- 
molato Peliae filiai deoepiiie, ea ouro in pariete domui Pompeia- 
€^ nae depiota ene adgnoviiiet Bobertui, e tragoedia deiumpta «ne 

ooniedt '); neque vero Diodorum aut piotorero ab Euripidii fabnla 
pependiiie idero oognovit quoniam illio Aoaitui omnino praeler- 
miiini Aiiiiet. Plura adoedunt. Quo enim dolo uiam eiae Me- 
deam tradnat Pauianiai [VIII 11, 2]: fi; yop d^ iiqfimo ^ Mi^dBu 
^JmM9 ^ *IwXx6Pf aviUu inifiovUva tif IIAUf v5 SQy^ fiip avftnQAaoovaa 

vf Taoon, xm Xiy^ ii an^&aio^tvfi et Ovidiui [met VII 897]: - 
neve doli oeiient, odium oum ooninge falrom 
Phaiiai adiimulat Peliaeque ad limina lupples 
oonfngit, 
. . hnno ex Euripide deiumptum eiie non temere oonolndere mihi 

videor ex fr. 606:. 

alv&* Mafyu if^ A lixvov at fiovXofuu* 
• StttP fiiv ^ TfdiQf fii^jikiop Tuuibg (pi/ojnSiP^ 

iv TWQ^iwoii ii nuQ&ivov tQonov^ ^K^t 

1) Cf. arg. Hed. [lohoL gr. in Ear. ed. Dhidorf. t IIII p. S] oom 
^^ Dindorfii adnotatione* 

8) ArohaeoL Zeit XXXII« 1876 p. 184 iq. Cetemm nt &buU 

quae apud Diodorom extat [o. 61, 1] iavriit ik tAc ^ir r^^^ ivpifisai 

' "f nai xQtaaaur not^am noXtds orta lunt qoae tradit Clem. Al. ilrom. I 

p. 868 P . • Afiffffiii r« 4 •^'4'ov 4 XoX;^ nQtkti pm^wtQixup iMiPOfUtv, 



10 • 

■ Imr 9 in* dpSfh( jjkiaim» tvjftnit niagQ 

0i fr. 607: 

nnatam Termi Hed. 698: 

il xff^lM^ iQaaa^ fQ^ f*^ oatpiatsQow 
m Pdkdilm repotito ') hmio praeoedere: 

aiutH §1^ Yctoopy uiiep i^ ifiov na^¥ 
diUgeiiter ftoimadfertatiir. Yidetar enlm Hedea abi «d Peliam 
oonliigiti hoe ▼enro interrogaia eese qoa de oanaa rizam oom coninge 
eommiaimt, illii ne adroganter ooningia l^timi imperio ao po- 
teatali refragetar admonerL Deniqne fr. 604: 

lUijikut nQhg fiiw Mfiaar TVfarmtuH^ 
mvlto melina ad mnlierem fiigam simnlantem ') qnam ad saoerdo- 
tem divinam Dianae maiestatem prae bo ferentem qnadrat. Videtur 
Igitor hoo qnoque argnmentum non DionyriuB eoo arbitrio inflezfsee, 
aed qoae ipri poetae tragiri Enripidem seonti noTaTorant, dili« 
genter esoerpiiBse. Omnino eum in fabulii tragioiB multum Tor- 
oatum eese Diodori verbie indiiBatnr [o. 56, 1]: xadikov di AA v^v 
tdh iQoyifimw isgawBlap nouUX»! vg wd iuhpogog tatogla nt(fi Msi' 
ittag ifin^^mam neque omittendum eat quod a Dionysio Aeetae 
filio Bomeo fniaie traditnm eet A^ialens [of. Diodor. o. 46, 8j, 
idem ri.Faoorium indidiaee ') atque id quidem e poeta aliquo tra- 
giooqoi pooi Earipidem flomit deeumptom. Neque enim apud 
Sophodem neqoe apud Euripidem illum ita nominatum eeoe oonstat 
• ediolL ApdlL nil 228. Enr. Med. 167. 

Yel liaee euffiriunt opinor nt Dionyrii operam ad hietoriae 
poetioae menioriam aenrandam multum Taluiaoe eluoeat Yt vero 
«oarratio Diodorea qna in nnnm orationie tenorem oontraota et 
ooagmentaifk Hbri Dionjrriani obeonra parumque oerta imago pro- 
pooitor, diioddo eiplioetor et in priotinaa partee diaoerpatnr, quo- 
aiam |praee(o aont oom Eoripidii Pindariqoo oommentarii tum aoholia 
ApoDoniaiiat imprimie, id agendnm eat nt ex eorum Diodorique 



I .o . ■ ♦-• > ^ » 



Wil/- 



'\\\ 



ii 



' 4 r : t 



^»". 



—————— ' ' I ' 

• . I ' 
1) Gt eehoL ad h. va. fragm. 60IL ' 

^ Of. Ofid. L 0.: *Pcliaeqne ad limina aapplex oonfiigit*. Non 
opte Rbbartoalfo^ Ikbalaa diatinzit 

8)'Ct (^,a..nat. d€or. III 19, 48: *quid husua Abqrrto fratri qni 
eat apod FMoriam Acgialeoa*. Yade io loatinQm [XXXXO 8, 1] nomen Y-^ 






11 

ooDBensa quos aaotores Dionysias adhibaerit, . qaam oertistime 
eraatar. HeBiodi Antimachi Deiloohi SimonidiB AoaBilai teBtimo- 
nia qaiboB DionyBium uBum eaae ez Boholioram Diodoriqae con- 

^ BenBU ootiBtat, Boholia ApoUoniana perluBtranti BaepiBdme oocarrnnt 

atquo ea magnam quidem partem oopioeiB illiB fabnlamm oatalogis 
inBerta^) qni Bimillimam Bpeeiem prae ae ferunt et ab uno anetoro 

" :' fere omnee originem dncere Tidentur. Nicandri Bnpra mentionem 

' feci neque qnae praeterea ex eo Hylae et Herculia fabulae adfe* 
runtnr') quin Dionyeii operae debeantnr dnbito. Deinde qoaa 
apud Diodomm de inhoBpitaliboB Ponti adooliB dicontar [c^Oyi]: 
•Av ii riovmv xai* iwlvovq tovq yjQ^vw^ nsQUHKOv^iPOV inh i^wdip 
fioQpdgwy Koi TmviskSiq aiyQUav ifyvov nQogiiyoQ9v$a9at iS/BvoKwvovrtu» 
\ mv iyx^Qlwv xovq xamnUoviag EratostheniB opinioneim refeniDt 
apud Strabonem ApoUodori opera Bcrvatam [YH p. 298]: Srdow 
yaQ^$lvm liu n^y dukaxiuv mva^v xal HaXua%hu ^A^vov dUi li 

^j^ iwfyjtijiSQOv xal v^v aYQiotfim mv nBQioiiitovvmv id^vwv kal fioXunu 

T&v Sitv&ucdiv l^vodvwvvmv xal oaQKOfpfAyivvmv nal lofig XQavktq 
iimdfiaai xQWfiivwv*) et qnae BcholL Apoll. UI 311« IIH 661 de 
Gircae inBula^ceteriBque VliziB erromm locie inde ab Heeiodo in 
Italiae oram tranelatiB ezponuntnri fere UBque ad verba EratoBthenls 

^ Bunt Strabone iterum tOBte [I p. 23] : *EQaioa9iv^ (K *Haiodov /ccr 

cljcix{b mnvafjiivov nsQi t^ X)ivaaiwg TtXdvfiQ Sn xcna SuoiXlav xal 
*IvuXlav yeyiviimif nunsvaavm i^ iohi fi^ fi6vov niv it/f Y>/<i{pov 
Xeyofiivwv ftsfivija&M^); qnin etiam qui ab EratoBthene Tolgmri de 



A^ 1) Huo pertinent BohoH. I 46. H 181. 296. 297. 1122. m 1060. | 

- IIU 259. 284. 82a 892. 1896; I 211. UH 156. 1158; I 961. 966. 974. 989 j 

— ubi postrema yerbis ioxovvrus l^aT«s cTmvi e scholio ys. 996 intmaie i 

confusa sant — 1087. 1089. 1061. 1068. 1065; IIII 814; 992, neque homm | 

auotorum testimonia haud ita raro ooniuncta legi neglegendum eei. | 

2) Cf. Bcholl I 1286. 1800. 1804. Theoor. XUl 7 siquidem ibi i 

^ NixaviQOi ik Kimcof recte conrigitur d. Anton. Lib. L C Quid tamett 

*• hoo loco Bchol. I 1804: £rfiaififlQotot ik on iitttpOQav iaxov nQog Tosr 

^ 'ffQoxXia niQi ruv Mofiivwv itiQwv vno ^fdaovot toTc ogiaTivat Tettta 

ille auctor ThaBiuB Bibi yelit, prorsuB non intellego neqre haeo ad 8te- 

sichori de Peliae ludis fnnebribaB oarmen referre dubito praeBertim eana 

eo ipao looo Apollonins iUomm mentionem feoerit. -— Knm praeier 

Kioandrum Poaidippo poeta Alezandrino [ef. aohoL 1 1289] S^sytobnMshio 

nBUB ait, diiudioari nequit. 

8) Eratoathenia aententia refertnr a Oio. d^ rep. UI 9, 15^ Orid. 
triat nn 4, 56 aq. Lnoian. Tox. 8; praeterea ef. Ykert IH 2p. 151. 
-y , \ 4X Cf. praeterea 8trab0| T p. 282 ^ol ik «nl noliQQiCov dvm nSjp* 

T^fivl^ T^ nsQi T^g XiQMtff awouiisoivw eam 8ehd..ApolL IZI UI 



12 

errorilmi opiniooi obponelmtar «^imsanoj^iSg ille Homericue^), 
apnd Diodonim invenitiir [c. 46, 5] : xam fiiv nmg m¥ ^vd^gdipmif 
^vfHV M tifv S2Kf«riy mti v^ifoy s^wp mwXafiofiivtiif iymvdu 
fuvu iwr avfnpvyovaSw yvmMmv HaMQV^tfvat neque deest alt-er» sen- f • 

teotia: icanv H nrog ic5v iatOQixwv lidinovaav riy Ildnov xaiofx^oiu 
^vq*C *ImUaQ ixgrnijgtop fi fiixQi^ tov rvr an* ixeltTjg Kjlgxaiov iro- 
iittSifitPOK Addae fchol. Enr. Med. 2 nbi etiam Simonides adferiur 
[cf* aapra p. 2, 11]'). A DioDjeio igitnr Eratosthenes exdtati^s eet 
aobolL ApolL II 1247. IIII 131. 1216. 269. 284quiba8cum echoU. 
II 399. IIII 810 arta cohaerent. Quomodo Tero factum sit ut 
^rtheas coi ab Eratocthene Bumroam fidem habitam esse HQUenhoffiiB 
dMBooatraTit'), BchoL ApoIL IIII 761 commemoraretor tcI Si^lacis 
Caryandeneis nomen schoL IIII 1216 Eratostheni praecederet, oerto 
erai neqoit» nec Philostephaoi quom DioDysio praesto fuisse ez iis 
qoae sopra [p. 2 adn. 6] adnotavi, veri non dissimile est,. testi- 
■Moiis Sqrtobrachioois vestigia — si schoL IIII 277 exceperis -— 
oigoificari potaverim. 8ed qoo loco Hesiodi Antimachiqoe de Harpyiis 
fidndao adtolit [scholl. II 296. 297] Scytobrachiot ex hoc verso: 

ird* otf ti^MiiP AXvffnf h/nfiidovn 

opodiHesiodum Boreadas com reverterentor lovem precari non po- 
lerat oonolodero oisi qoae illie secootor: hm yig AIpoq Sqoq t^ 
KktpaUtp^aiQ btovAlr^alov Jilq Uq6v ianv, ov fiWTffiovovH KXkav 
iw HMQlmkf nai T\fioadivtfQ iv xoiq Aifiim>v adiongebat, idemqoe 
adioL n 632 praefecti dassi regis Ptolomad Philadelphi memoriam 
Kvit praeoertim eom qoas aras Argonaotae ad Bysantinm ox- 
ibi dicootori eae a Diodoro quoqoe [c 49,2] commemo- 
reotor^). In eadem illa orbe com laoonio et Hedeae noptias ode- 



<! . 



jr«pl tkv *itmUav flxijaf r 4 XiQMH o^v ogos KigMmov «n* avrijg noXv* 
^pmQfutMov^ pL odioL u 186. 

1) Ct-Strabo. VII p. 299: inmfii Sk mA roTg nigi Xuttliav r^r 
mJcPvr Uyvat «b^ ^fi^v tiv*OivaaitH' <l yig, ai XQn^ yv<^ f*h 
mlaw^ Iss» f9f9v ivm ipAoMHV, tov ik iroi vr^r i^tavtMivm fiv9oloyiat 



2) Qoo odioL ApolL II 817 roibratar: irt^ ri»r Svfinhiyaiw r»n 
inik tmiiomMoS atofioroc liaav Mokin Kvivim iMolovvto itato XQ^f^^f ■ 
i9 tf aQm^ aQiftm prorono iooertom esi 

. 8) HaHe^oil^ dootoohe Alterthuoiskando I p. 818 sq. 

.4^ Bednooo f eoim ooo hoo feeisoe dooot Pdybios [101 89,6]: ti 

Vffqr iff o!f tonoo yool Mirir riyr Ix Xilxttv avmmfuifiv ' XF 

9v9av Mwror. tollp #ioli(. 



9m9 






VA W ■\X .--.-^.v 



' Y I • i 



\ 



bratas esse iradiderit [•chol. IIII 1168]: T^iiuUm Xiywn^ h 
K$^KVQf xovQ yifiWQ Ax9^vat JioviaiOQ i iUULifaio^ Ir imifoi ww 
j^Qyovamxdhf h Bv^nlif qitjalr^ ^Avdfmxoq h Avtjj Iv KiX^^ 
nhfdov Tov nomfioi^ fuy^vat^ enm at Sophoolem et Herodomm 
' [•choll. IIII 269. 284] ArgoDautas eodem itinere quo profeeti erant, 
domnm redenntefl fecisBe oonstat, atqae ita Aarrationem Diodoma 
instituit. Qui cnm omnibus Argonantarum fabulis enarratis ultimo 
loco a nonnuUiB auctoribuBy inprimiB a Timaeo reditum aliter de- 
seriptum esse addiderit [o. 66, 8], loco illo Dionysium •uao 
narrationi Timaeum adpIicasBO consequitur'), neque vero ea Dio- 
dori fides atqne dihgentia eet ut ez eius Terbis otW iUym 
yoQ TiMii^ TB oQxulwv ovyyoaipiwv xal mv fiswysvoavtQOiP mv j<m 
ml Tifioioc^ qMol xotg *jiQyovavwg fisva r^v xov diQOVQ a^m- 
y^v nvdofiivov^ vn* AliJTOV nQOHaniX^(p%hu vaval rh ai6fiu 
fotf nonov nQttlltv imxfXdaaadui naQoiofyiiv x<4 fiv^fifm S^v 
quaecumque 8ecuntar, ea ad unum omnia Timaei eese conaequaiiir 
^ aut ea quam instituere pergit itinerie desoriptiono : ivunksvauvxMu; 
yuQ aixovg Ad xov Tupoiiog noxufiod inl xug nfgyug uul ^nuxA xokov 
xtm x^v yuvv iishtiauvxug xud' ixiQov nuhv noxufiod t^v fvau^ 
sxpvxoQ st^ xb¥ ^SiKsuviv xuxunXsvaui nQi^ x^v MXuxxuv eum ■oholii 

r- Apoll. IIII 284 Terbis composita: i fiiv yuQ StfifivoQ avioti; d^ 

Tumidog nenXsmtivtu Inl x^v fivyuh^v ^JtXuaauv^ ixsidsv H dg t^v 
i^ftexiQuv ^aXuaauv iX^iXv^vui. xai nuQSxfiolsi-&xtu cog Squ Bi96wuQ 
inl T^r ^nstQov o2 *AQyovavxut ini axQtaxiJQtav iKOfttiotKV xifv ^Qyti 
fiiXQiQ ov inl ^Xaaaav nttQsyivovto Dionysium Soymni teetimoiiiiB 

^ vel ipsum tcI ex £ratoethene sumptis usum esse non rede ei 

oerto ooDcIudatur. Cognitam est igitur praeter anetorea sapra 
^ nominatos Eratosthenis Timosthenis Timaei Soymni testimoDia nbi- 

cumque in scholiis Apollouianis ut Argonautarum fabulae iidpliearentiir, 
adhibitA sunti ad Dionysium certo referrL Plura adoedent nbi in 
scholiomm Apollonianorum memoriam atque propaginem diligeiiiiiiB 
^ inquisitum erit. Praeterea nt certnm toti qnaestaoni fundamentnai 
substmatur, diligenter circumspiciendum est nnm quomm gram* 
matieoram opera SiTtobraehionis eopiae in ApoIIonB Piiidari Enri» 
pidis oommentarios penrenerint, emi liceat. . 



1) Praeterea data oooatione Timaeo auetore de rebus Gorojneia 
longins disputayisse ridetur eL soholL IIII 984. 1216. 1217. Ad ottm 
refero etiam sehol. II 899 Tiftwof Si tpfiiu nMov iv^ KiXxoic thmt 



14 



n 



\ 



. ApoUodoram bibliothecae Mriptorein ftb ApoUodoro Stoioo 
AristArchiqae diMipalo prorais eese eecemendum et btbliotbeoam 
nt pro fabulamm oompendio nterentor Indi magistri, primo Tel 
•Iterb p. 0. n.. saeenlo eompoeitam eeseBoberti opera^) nnno con- 
■lai. Idem enm in Argonantamm fabnlis enarrandia quamrie fero 
aewper ApoIIonii Teetigia' preeee eecntum') panca et aliena 

1) C Bobert, di» ApoIIodori bibliotliecai diBt. BeroU 1878. 

S) Calalogo Bobertiano [L c p. 79] hos loooi addo qiiibiw Apol- 
lonii Tennt adgnoeeimtar: 

bibL I 9, 31, 8 Apoll. II 187iq. 

it ttiQttvoS xmStntafitrm tn *' AXln M rifpiw &fppt» nilns Aiauovam 

fik9 nUknim mniQnn^p^ ^UYu .Z^Qnvtm otofinrof /<f^r r* nno ynfopii^ 

4k Sm otf/»fC mrmnlMm mit/- ^V^'^ 

tejrer Stwt fif 6imft9m ^wtxi^H ^^nnf^. iUinno i* nXXmi 

tpoQftns 

oM* SaoFy nUmi rvr^oy, tm Cmmp «xicj^ro* 
Mrl &* inl fiv&nXitfp oir/i^y //oy ov^/ rtf 

irXfi 
fill xnl XtvxnvifiP 6k tpoQiifiivoe . • 
268 nl^ ifl xovQotiQOininoy^o dnttn yi* 

Qovrt 

967 fiif ^ StpnQ . . -. 

nnQotptnoi ritpiinw i^Xfnnu iaatvovro 
MXuyyj fintfitmam i&firvog' ol i* iet&ovris 
^Q^Uf fiitgaiiyvg Avinxov • • • 
978 rnmr i* nv xmrinta^i &vm vbe BoQitto 
tpnttYmi^ intmxofiivoi nQoaam ^iop, • 

549 tX ^ 8r«. iri aMoXioio nooov tnnvtO' 

nov Xxovro 

rfQrixiimg antXmiiaaiv iiQyfiivov ififpori" 

Qm&iv 
666 •;•••. « mQTo ik noXXii 

^fi^if mvmfQmaMam vitpoe mg, nvi «fl 

novrog 

afiiQimXiov nmviti ik niQi fiiymg iflQifHP 

mi^flQ, 

UII m fj fikv yif SniXXfig Xiaali nQoi» . 

^fwUVffo wiiQiif 

f I #* ^oror fommamiv inmfXidavam X«* 

SXXoit ik nXmynrtH fMymX/^ ino nifinn' 

nixQm' 

^4f^foy jufv ni^i^iv inintviv mt&ofiivti 

tpi6t 

iMQtnv im awmiXttv nvQtimXniog i}poi$ 
. .' " . . • nitQrigf 

matv^ #* A4flvo4ff|«f#4( niXtv . 

•'• '■'^ •1:1 



4.*.of ik ntiQi^immv mvr iprQm' 
jr«(RF iiitgfimrttVpZiQnvtm ik 
Hw / yyfC avv fo^ mmrnnrnam 
t^v f^o^r ^QnmCw* ^cntfii- 
pttvoi ik oi BoQiotf nmiiig 
i?jrf( jmI KmUitg • • • • • oir «- 
M/imi tjc |Cpi|^.«IMwor* 

99^9... for itk 9mXimaris 
MiQov mniMXnmv. intpiQtro 
Jl noXXli fikv mn^ mitth 
itfiixh^ noiit ik nmrtiyog* 

■ % 

, » - 



m 

96» % putk ik fkt XiiQ%vmg 
jfr f«iir XmQtifi^g ihHx^^o 

Ml imif iv ^ «oa^ «al 

flKvsAff itMtibtmitiiVOc JMoAraL 

• \\\ r. ' 

hl'f/- ■ 



k • 



f 



•♦' 



M 



-.*/ 






l 



- 16 

. ab illo tradere oognoTit ^). Qaid qaod hao ioia libelli pftrte 
. Apolloniae nneqaam nominatnry ano looo poetqnam ez Hetiodo 
aliisqae de Harpyiie pauca Apollonii ne alla qaidem ratione habita 
X . excerpta sant, haeo addantar [1 9, 21^ 8]: WaioiUitfito^ ilii irioSp 

^Aqyomiim^ Swq SiQwpaiunf vi^oiav iinfAt cividg d^^m* md 
fifjiip nadHv iovaa^ SgHor toi^ 0iviu fitpUn ddttxifoiEir [of. ApoU. 
II 282 sq.]. Haud aliter 21,2 qaae ApoUoniae tradit [II 179 oq.] 
- •• . Phineum propter oracnla paerim et promiecae hominiboa prodita 
a loTO caecatam esee inter ceteras caneas verbie oi fiip additis 
adferantor, neque ubi de Talo eermo eet, Apolloniana allo modo 
dietinguontur*). lam quae ApoUodoruB enarrationi * ApoUonianae 
interpoiait, cum Argonantioomm •choliie conferantnr e. g. 1 9, 17, 1 
aljitjfiytm r^ \4qfQotiniy o&e ^nfioir* ^ ilii avmig ififiaUu iwMh 
filav oum schol. I 615 icSi^ dj SkXiav Unoqovvmv Sn ttati xSXov 
Tijg *AqtQoSlnjg al AfifiHaie^ ivaoafioi lyivovm • . • , 2 nifogaxit^ 
ovv lojs yvvaiKoitQttxovfiivf^ t§ Atjfivw filayovnu ndg /vwM^rr eom 
sohol. I 769 ou ii ifilyrfiav oi ^Aqyovavnu nug A^vUug*H(foiuQog 
lawQ^ iv toig^AQyovavUHoSQ*) • . .| quae de laaoniamatre [16,1], 
deArgoPhrizi filio [16, 6J, doApiyrti oaede [24,1—8] nanmntiir 
eum echoliis I 46. 280. 4. IIII 228. 228. Orayiasimi Tero momeiiti 

_ : est quod ez auctoribueBchoI. I 1289 adhibitis in Ubliotheeae 

loco [9,19] quattuor redeunt. Neque tamen ez hoeloeo ipeoe&gr* 
tobrachionis libroe bibliothecae auotori praeeto fuiflse qui totam 
enarrationem ApoUodoream tcI obiter oum Diodoro oontulerit| eonliget, 
sed quid obstat quominuB Apollodorum cnm ez ApoUonio namtaonlB 

MX^ argumentum atque materiam BumpBiBBot tcI ipeiB TerBiboB in ser- 

monem pedoBtrem conTorBiB, quae In commentario doete et oopioee 
expoeita lcgiBBot haud paudB loeiB orationi interpblaBBO e t a t na t nr? 
An caBU adcidit ut in Tali fabnla Sophoeleae tragoediae ot ab 
Apollodoro [I 9,26,8]^) TOBtigia legerentor et in eehoL ApoD. 



1) Roberi. 1. c p. 80 Bq. . . 

2) Cf. bibliothecao Tcrba [1 9, 26, 8] rovror o/ filr ? or x^^Umo yi^ 
vov£ ilvm Uywfatv et paulo infra 4 l^iriir^M; ik itA MtjiUn^ <^^ 
^nrrtr A^ fikv twot li^ovo$ M ^^fi«Mir. fittvittv ttinf iftpmloaa^t 
oum Apoll. Iin 1641 iq. et 1669 Bq.i 

.... ^Mfiivti ik ttaiihv roor ixMotiotaiV 
ofifiaat }(aXMiioio TiXm ifii/HQiv inuttiCf 
Itvyaliov i* ini ol n(ifiv jt^ior, itt i^ iii^lm . « 
iiimika nQdhdXiv imCmpiiiv uefiouatu 
\ ^ . Z\ Hoo dariB TorbiB apod ApoUonium nuBqaam dioiinr oL 1 857 ot^ 
\ , 4) Of. haeo Torba ol ik ,ini 'HtptUatoti Mivm io^vm eom eehoL 



16 

Iin 1638 tettimoniom adhiberetur Tel qufte de Phineo ab Apollo» 
daro nATnuitar [I 9, 21, 2]: oi di inb Bogiov xal nSy ^ji^mvt&r 
8n nmadwig fitpB^vt^ mig Ulavg itvqikiuMs tfouSag a BohoUo II 178: 
Soqwk^ dli Sn lot^c & Kksonaigag vMq IvvipkuMU TlttQ^inov xal /s 

Xgofifiow maddg iiafioXtug ^lialag t^g avxdlfr fifitjj^Sg Beparari 
omiuiio iioii poetent')? Deinde BiqniB in BoholiiB fabnlam Apollo- 
niaiumi aliiB et diTenriB Baq>e obponi animadverterit'), non iam \^ 

mirabitar qnod loco illo bibliotheeae inepta ApoOonii mentio fit 
'•ni alienbi einB faboia inter eae qnae ab ipBo diBcrepare dioit 
^poIlodoruB, recenBetnr, praeBertim com ipBiB iUiB looiB in BcholiiB ^ 

Ai^nantica tommemorentnr: cf. Bchol. II 296 xaiA H *Halo6o¥ 
mal *jirdfte^p xai \4nfAXiiH0w ov Htslromu et Bchol* U IIS i H 
^nMiinog fpfn n^Qiad^ijna aMv xal Tighg twp ^Agnuwp xantSg 
mkj^p tu ipiSfp nS» xal (iMi^^A^y Ifiavtsfieto, q,fiai yoQ *ovt* 
Saov iniSno nal Jibg amoff. Qooniam vel ez hao neglegentia 
Bilqne inenria non enm IniBBe biUiothecae anctorem adparet, qni 
praeter Apollonii Argonantica commentariiB instracta etiam alioB 
iit falralaB conligeret BcriptoreB perqnireret, qvaecnmqne ab eo de 
Ai^nantamm ezpedttione memoriae tradantar neqne nb Apollonii. 
cannine pendeant, ad Argonantioomm commentarinm portinere 
«tatuo atqne enm qmdem qao etiam BcholiaBta codiciB Laarentiani 



in Plat rem pabl.Ip.887 [VI p. 888 ed. Horm.] neo dabito quin iiteir- 
iguo loeoB ad Daedkli fabalam pertineat; cf. FTO p. 188. 

1) Yereor ne Bub iia qooqoe bibliothecae Terbis qaae praecednnt: 
vofiroy ol fikv jiyivoQOf tlnn Ifyovotp^ oi ifl noaHdSvoc vtov eadem atqoe 
quae BchoL II 178: jiyimQot yiiQ nats iattv tis *ElXanMO£* tis 6k 'liaio* 
Sis f^^atVf 4»oinitof «ri. traditur diBcrepantia lateat. Neptuni enim 
filium Phineum nnqoam diotum ette omni caret probabilitato et hoc 
Bomen ex verbiB qoae infra leguntur t';ro Iloaitd^vog intmsum eiBe 
Tori Bimillimttm CBt. 

2) CL tcholL I i. 46. 67. 211. *668. 628. 967. 996. 1037. 10G8. 
tSm. 1286. 1289. 1804. 11 98. 178. 296. 297. 866. 929. 1210. 1281. 
m 2ft. 811. 667. 1179. 118a 1872. nU 86. 87. 166. 177. 228. 22a 269. 
S84. 808. 898. 1217. 1760. 

8) DiBcrepant&B qoae inter bibliotheoam et Boholia Bane Jnteroe- 
dnnt enm nimie inhaereret [cf.p. 86. 69] Robert paulo timidior hoo 
indidam talit[p.M! ' Apollodomm aot ipaum Sophoolia eommentarium 
nnt aUo^ ]ibruiii| neacio qoem cognofiBae^ coinB aactor Sopboolia aorinia 
«ompilaveral; qoo. atatato omnea doBmodi adnotationea qoae quidem 
«iveditioni .ArgoiMMitftram inaertae aant| ad eondem fontem referri 

ik! Si: illiB enim diaerepantiiB nihil alind oonaeqaitttr 

. •* . . • i . I I 1 1 • •• 



^ 



•>" 



l 

1 



17 

Qua ro oogniU ooDoenioi illiut quom iotor Pindaii ApoUonii- 
que foholia iQtoroedero supra proba^i noTum ot praoolamm ezsiatit 
oxemplum. Et apud ApoUodorum ot in soholiii Pindarioie nbi la- 
BoniB lAWWQi/jimiai fabida enarratur, Phorooydoa exhiberi olim oo- 
gnitum eet '), atque ipeum mythographum ab Apollodoro ezieriptom 
0880 putes, niei hio laeonom eum ut flnmen nudis pedibua trmne- 
grederetur soloae ezuiseot, alteram reliquieoOi ille ApoUonium *) ae- 
outus ti fluminie alteram ereptam oBeo narratorit. Haeo . igitur. 
Phereoydao narrationi insorta eeee quomodo aliter oxplioetari iiiii 
ApoUodorum ox ApoUonii oommentario Phereoydea oumpeiBao sta^ 
tuatur, non fideo. QnodBi oommentariiB Pindarico et ApoUoniano 
Phereoydea illa oommunia olim fuerunt| cortum hoo extat Dionytti 
▼OBtigiQm unde eum et de ile quae ante ipaam Argonantamm ex- 
peditioDom gesta Bunt, fuBiuB ^giBBO et Phereoydae UbriB oti aoU- 
tum OBBO cognoBoatur. Quem otei poBteriB quoquo temporibuB aommo- 
pere obbo lectitatum negari non Uoet et eiquando oommemoraiur, 
Bumma oput oet eautela nequid temere conolndatur, boo tamen 
meo iure Bumere mihi ndeor ut quotieoB in BehoUie ApoUonianif 
eiuB toBtimonia iuxta HoBiodnm Antlmachnm .eiuBmodi aoetorei 
poBita et ad Argonautamm fabulaB inluBtraiKlaB adhibita aiint, 
haec omnia DionjBii operae ▼indicem '). 

Haeo tamen omnia oonrannt ei reote LehrBinB Bobertum oppu* 
gnatit^). Doleo eane me in hie atudiomm primitiiB- Tenerabilon 
▼iri memoriam non ita colere potuiBBO nt Bopremnm ingenii docn- 
mentnm ot omni ratione probarem probatumque noTie atqoo bonii 
argnmentiB defenderem. Quod cum a me impetrare non potoiBaeaiy 
hoe oerte iUiuB manibuB tribuendum obbo duxi nt eiuB argnmontoram 



quam alio commentBrii exemplari uBum bbbo ApoUodoram, tlio aoho* 
Uastam neque obUviscendum ett Bcholia a oonfoBioniB pertubationijqM 
labe immonia obbo omnino non poBso. De Sophode infra loqoar. 

l) Cf. fl^e obBerr. td ApoU. p, 69. Robert L o. p^ 07. FH6 
I p.87. fr. 60. 

3) Ct I 9: jifCt/ifpAMo ^/e^ miw iw no^^v kpmiffov 

aXlo fikr iiioimotr M iHoff illo i^ Wi^w 
fMiluiiv mf9i ni^ilov iMxofiivoii^ nffoxojmr 
onm bibl. 1 9, 16, 8: Sm^vwpSk norafiiv "knni^ it^l^ fmoampimlos 
ri hiQO¥ inolioof ir r^ i^^^W ^i^*^^* 

8) Hio OBt loooram index: BohoU. I i6»980. 218. 45. 10&; 189. 14& 
159. 911. n 181. 178. 971. 999. I 1989. m 467. U 1149. III '4)K 88a 
I. qU 156. 998. 998. U 498. UII 1896. / v. .^ ^' ^ 

4) WiBB^tohafU. MonatBbL 1878 ar.8 p.ll58q. !.0 

a. - ■. . 



0- 



18 

vit «Iqiie graTitM de iotegro qnam diligentieame ezamiiiaretiir. 

Ae primnm mnltii quidem bibliothecae iocia versne ApoUonianot 

adgnoed Lehrsina Boberto eonoedity tamen hie iprii locii plurima 

iaeeee eonteodit qnae ab Apollonio diTenissima esie nonneglegen« ^ 

dnni lit. Adferantnr igitnr omnei lod qnibns ApoUodonie aperte 

ab ApoUomo dteoedit: 

4 9, 17| 1 17 d8 ainuQ IfifiaXX» iwnqdav — omnfimL^ovto 

wAwbSqi baee reperinntnr ■ehol. I 615^). 

2 nj p epBg^rfymc oSv — vuSq yvvat^¥\ reperinntor eohol. I 769. 

*YyMivk»i • . • • Y$¥v^ naSiaq ECvfpv mi N6fi(fwp6roK Eunei 
nooien H 468 eommemoratum saepe inTonitnr et plemmqne duoe 
fniM filioe nerratar')| Nebrophonne tamen alibi non occnrrit. ' 
Apnd Hjginnm baeo legnntnr [fab. XT]: iHypaipyle ez laione 
proereaTit Enoenm et Deipbilum.* 

19,1 ^nacyop i emMftakwg fdr Kdl^ 'HQokkkvg ii ^pcft- 
fifvag • • • • vni wfiipAv iJQndy9i. Hylam Hercnlie amasium foiaae 
«I a eomplnribne nymphis ablatnm Lehrsins n^at apnd Appllo- 
niom log^ [L e. p« 122]: l^ntnr et nnnm et altemm icho]]. I 
ISl. 1286. 

. 8. 4 ^HgoAaQog di • • • . nSr ^AQyovavtiSv ysviaSmi redeunt 
•dMlL I 1168. 1289. 

20| 2 id^fSac iun& TO& iyKwvog anixmvf: haeo conmpta snnt * - 
n^ iam eoniectnram wnA j6v iydiva Robertns [cf. !• e. p. 79 
B. 19] defendat Palmeri! emendatione nene eorib! ▼clim jcoiA fo9 
mSiglvoQ qnod eaue dieorepat ab ApolloniOy sed redit apod Valeriom 
FlaMrai [mi 807 eq.]^ 

* 21| 1 mmwSiaiv dg Ttjv 9g4x^ Sakfivd^aa6v: echoll. II 177. - 
178. 532 PUneom Tbraeiae Salmydessom halntasse fose demon- 
stmtnr; in Asia enm regnum obtinuisse Phereoydes [sohoL II 181] 
tndidit*). 

loSkov et fih *Ayifvofog — nXovv tfiifwoivi haeo ad soholL 
n 178. 181 pertinere snpra demonstrasse mihi tideor. Qnae oltimo . 
looo adfertn^ labda: ni^ di inh Hoa^imoQ So fo7( OgilSiav natat 

. • 

f 

1) SehoL 1 009 ea ide eaosa non tdtoli qoodspeoiem historiolae 
leeenlinre tempore a grammatioo sliqeo oompbsitae prae se fert 

2) Ot aig. Piad. Nem* p»424 BoeoUu Otid. ep. YI 121. Stat 
neb. Y468. 71842. epigr. €78« 10. 

^ 8) yerbii ^boL n 178 ivtot ik oMv iv tfj ntaplayovfq faaf 
jUSm letBfo g e>y jrivc l«rl ? ipr jiaikt felso sddita esse tidentor Ae ff^v 
lUMmmm qoae; ad seqoeatia psrtlnei«. doeet soholiom quod praeoedit 



* '• 



■■Mi 






-y\ j:l 



\ 



1« 



v&r ^x K6Xy(wv A^ riiv *EXku6a nkovv ifijjwaev utnim in 
omnioo non extet an schol. II 181 Terbie Sn ^P^/j^ in m totg 
Op^^ oonreotiB infercnda sitt eom Boberto [ef. p. 62] nago dit* 
eemt poBse. 

4 fiovXoftivotg ie zoig ^AgyominuQ — ia¥ imdlaffMn repe- 
riuntar apncl Hyginum [fab. XVIIII] et Bobol. fi 70. 

6 — 8 ifi^ is ToS^ j^QnviaiQ XQ^^ "^ ^ <Pm'a ^ipevtt iAxifaawi 
haee alibi non leguntnr, eed animadTertae Heeiodnm et hie eaae 
ezoitatnm et in ooroplnribns scboliiB [II 296. 297] qnae md Har- 
pyiarum fabnlam pertinent: praeterea ef. quae supra fp. 16. 16] 
deApoUonii mentione disputari. 

22, 2 ifoar di ineQftayiduQ avnu^ avpcQovifisvm diT ikX/^hu^ 
inh T^g tmv nnvfiumv filag: Tentorum vi oanteB oonliBas eBse tradont 
etiam quae feruntur Orphei Argonautica [tb. C88Bq.]^); ad magni- 
tndinem rnpinm cf. Yaler. Flace. IIH 642. 

^v di aivvavov xai mq nomvolig &* aimiv tkMv: ef. Yaler. 
lUI 569 Bq.: 

qnippe per altum 

tenditiB nnde prooul f ^nti, procul nnde folncree. 
Habet praeterea Ammian. Mare. XXH 8|14. 

6 avlXafiofiivrjQ TlgaQ iii^Xdov: hano diBoi*epantiam falBO Ro- 
bertuB libranomm tcI Apollodori errori adtribnit [p. 80]; ez me- 
moria verBUB ^c 72 orta eet: 

dU* "Hp^ nfifinifiy/$v^ insl gJXog ^y 7^own 

28, 1 1 avvilnm ii avx^ — ngogtjyiiffvao T6fi0VQ: ef. PhereejdeB 
BohoU. III I 228. 228 inserta. 

/ 26« 1 ^AnikXtav iK . . . . loSsttxcc m) fiiXn dg tijv ^«Attooov 
wnti^a^fatf^v: eadem fere exhibent Orph. Argon. 1864 eq.: 
..... Tlaiiv d* dp* btfifiikog A/x6^ ^^^ 
Ji^Xpv Sno HQava^ ^wr fiiXog 

8 Tovror oi (xiv <— A«p^p«i(nD xahmiig et ^nanftsiq di ^ 
xAMvx^aag Xiyovai : cf. qnae de Apollonio adhibito et Sophode oomme- 
mdrato Bupra dixi [p. 16]; oetemm haec alibi non inteniantnr. 

6 iilav a ivxaddu vixxa fiolvuvxsg ...,•• fir ndrxa nXovr 
iv xsaauQd lAfpA xAsaaaavxsq: haee unuB praebet ApoUodorua. 

SepticB ooncinuut Bcholia; quinquioB HyginuB ValeriuB OrpbeuB, 
de quibuB Btatim diBpntabitur; reetant quattuor loei, atqua t«1 ei 
ilB duo arta quadam neocBBitadine enm BcboliiB edbaerere Tideiitur. 
Oatalogum ei ut par eet BopoBueriBi eetera quae ab ApoUoBio 



1) Norit ProperliuB qnoque: UI96| 80« 






flO 

I 

aBfloa esse Lehrriiu ooniendiiy reote «dfeni nego. Qaot p. 79 altero 

looo bibliotheeae et earmiDis looos Robertns oonianxit, eos separari 

|ironiis noD posse non miniiB fadle quionnique illos legity intellegit 

qnam qose in bibliotheea [I 9, 26, 2] de Hedeae andnis viros oavil- 7' 

lantibtts narrantar, ab Apollonio [IIII 1719 sq.] pendere. Qnodsi 

Poljphemiim non modo ne a latronihus sed etiam ne a bestiis Hjlae 

perienla adferrentur, timuisse vel andllas propter epularum inopiam 

Tiris inlusisse omint Apollodorus, quid tandem obstat quominus 

^hoe vd brefitatis • oausa vel propter neglegentiam f&ctnm esse 

atatuatar? Neque adeo claris verbis ApoUonius ezposuit quae post- 

qnam Hylae aliquid adddisse Herculem oertiorem fedt, gesserit 

Poljpbemnsy ut ApoUodoro illum seouto Hereulem et Polyphemum 

poemm quaesirisse noo liouerit narrare. Qiiae vero de Hjla aqnatum 

nisso habet ApoIIodomS| ea ez ApoIIonio breviter contracta sump- 

sisso probabillus putatur mea quidem sententia quam ab alio nesdo 

quo anctore. Venique ex . illis quae cum ApoUonii- etiaro verbis 

coodnere Bobertus [p. 79] et ego [p. 14 n. 2] probavimusy .ple- ' 

rumque ea esse animadvertatur quae a poetis narrationi nt vividior 

fiat, adspergi soleant neque ex vetustioribus fabuUs desumpta esse 

videantnr. Quis vero putet ApoUodornm philosophum Stoicum 

Aiistarehi disdpulum grammaticum doctisdmum ut Argonautamm . 

ftbnlae eip6neret| earmen a poeta Alexandrino ante centum annos 

com p o dt nm in sermonem pedestrem vertuse pauds doote adnotatis? 

Alqne adeo primum locum per totam hanc partem ApoUoniana 

obtioei jiarratio ut hoo fundamentum epitomatori deberi contendi 

aoo lieeat. Ynde tandem illa doctrinae frastula narrationi Apollo- 

aiaaao intorpolata atque ita quidem saepe interpolata nt cnm ipsa 

aarratioiie prorsus non oohaereant? Yideatur nnm apte in Phinei 

hhaU oomplnribus diserepantiis enumeratis pergatur [I 9,21,8] 

imt§t^lm9 a avnuf xal n^ jiomdag o! dwli vd non in enarrationis ' 

ioitio eed iUo. demum looo quo de Hyla agitury Herculem ozpedi- , 

tioni oomiao non interfnisse Herodoro auctore tradatur. Vnde in 

tribosL ^illis looiB ApoUonii fabulae ^ inter discrepantias inepte re- 
I? Ddndo qualis' libri epitomam bibUothecam esse Lehrsius - 



fimdt? Saao Eratosthenes eatasterismoram Ubro varias veteram 
iiilNiIaa aliter ab aUis narratas doete composuit, sed is quippe qui 



philologBa esset ipeeque oarmina faceret, in ipsis fabuUs eonltgendis 
adqneae^Mi Ap^llodomm iis qoae Graed de diis antiquitus tradi« 
prenos divereae Stoieae phOoeophiae rationes adhibuisse 
oet» ;'|I)e|iiqiio alind is egit. qui ut unum artisque finibas 




''mb 









r 



'•' 



a3 



31 

ciroamMripiam argamentam ornate oxplioaret et inloatraret, moJtoi 
et Tetaetoe libroe •omma indaetria perqairifit et remotai dootrinat 
eopiai nndiqae oongeaeiti aUnd qni ingenti hiatoriao poeticao mole 
4 in angnstam gyram ooartata fabolas pleramqne in triYiis ot eom* 

pitie deoantatai stemmatnm filia dednxit broviqae et exili nnrrationi 
panoa dootrinae vetoatae mdera adglntinarit Hlmm tane erti 

"^; eiaimodi libri si ab ApoUodoro vel ApoUodori tempore eompodtu 

esset, memoriam prorsas interiisse» atqno omnino Tostigia satis ao- 
taqoa bibliotheoae extare olim Robertas reote negOTii [p. 81]. Qaod 
soholiis Soph. Ant. 980. Pind. Nem. X 114 'similia in bibUothoci 
l^gi* breyiter adnotatnr, non magis Talet qnam qaod ApoUodori 
nomen maltis soBoUis Homeriois sobsoriptam legitar, qaonun aab- 
soriptiones ad nnam omnes a Ubrariis Bysantinis additaa oeM st 
. oertioribus argamentis demonstrem, spero aUqaando miU OTontiimm, 
qnam qni nnper has res adtigit JnL Sohwars in dissertatione Trt- 

y>y^ tislaTionsi do sohoUis in Iliadem mjthologiois. 

Qnoniam igitar ex ano atqae oerto exemplo a oompendiorum 
fabalariam aaotoribus oomroentarium iUnm ApoIIonianam oompi- 
latum esse cognitum est, nnm eias memoria latius propagata lit 
dircamBpicienti quae Hygini femntnr fabulae oooarrant. Qno Ubra 

r- quisquis oxpeditionis Argonantaram narrationem [fab. XII — ^XXIII] 

composnit, enm ApoIIomi oarmine pro fnndamento ao noraa asan 
' esse multis lods ') adparet, neqne ita raro ipsa poetae Torba qno- 
dammodo serTata sunt. ' Haeo praesto snnt exempla: 

fab.XV. ApoU. 1611. 

in insula Lemno mulie- i^ yAq wvgMag iiiv ampn^varm yvtwxa; 

res Yeneri 'sacra aUqnot ayiQt^ ^^p«f^t hP^ ^ ^^^ hfftJbSsaoM 

annosnonfecerant, onius vpfl^y ^^i % ainA iyiv&pv imne^^f 

ira Tiri earamThressas Q^xbiv inavviBgt imixoXog atvig ttmJ^ 

uxores duxerant etpri- JCtmfuloC oSvsxd fi$v YSQatav iid Ag^ 
oressproTorant. atLem- [onoottsr . .. 

niades einsdem Yeneris 611 tditoJovapvtgaiviat^SifQmaaw&udmi 

impnlsu ooniuratae ge- ofup* Bvvg^ nav & iQOBv ifiov yivoQ • • . 

1) Gf. fab. Xn oum Apoll. I 6—17; Ikb. XV oam I 809—891 
868-898. 881— 874; /ab. XVI oom 1 981-988. 1012— 1088. 1088— -1060; 
fab. XVII oum H l-2i. 87-97; fab. XVm oom U 762—758. 815- 
827. 886 sq. 854—857. 894 sq.; fab. XVHU oum U 178— 189. 828— 840; 
fab.XX oum U 1080-1088« 1089—1072. 1079—1082; &b. XXEL XHI 
L oum m 404— 4ld. 88-74. 88-^89. 142-144. 280-284. 18S0— ISSS. 

-ir . ■ 1854-^1857. 1888—1874. UU 158-188; hh. XXm onm nn SlStq. 

808 sq. 1008—1010. 1108—1108. 1184. 1901—1205. 



• > 



2^ 



mui Tiroram omiM qaod 
Ibi 9ni intorfeoenmt 

Xn • . • qni euD ab eo 1015 f (T s9m XahpBaai noy^/ifi^* ov 
diitmmiiitnt toiunqiio (/lir fevo^ 

diem iwTigeeMnii mwto ytwnoc m ^n^ fiirsv ^ntdov^ iXka &iMiu 
tempeeUle orU ad een- dnUu iffndy^p bnlata ipiQO¥ tifQ* inikwfaav 
dem s— "*^-* igimri de* • avng /i^roioi Mdom¥ 
lali emt 



1021 oiU n^ aixi^p njfoor inupQaiiaiQ 

[ipi9ia§¥ 
BfifiSPm • • • 

XYnn •. •Phineo ApoUo II 180 . . . ftaruHfiptiQ nfr o» miQOQ iyyvd* 

AijpMtf; ottT oooor hnOjm tak Jthq avwv 



Migiiriomdioiiordedieee. 
hio deomm eoDeilia enm 



eonntieret, ab lofe eet X9^^ itifmtiiaQ UQhr voo¥ aw^QiimMUf. 



in d* IW tg>&aXfm9 yXvxt^ ifioQ • • 
Barpjiae qnaelorie ea- 289 \dQnvlaq fioytiXou^ Jihg twvag •.• • 
nee eeee dicnntnr.^^. 
XXn • . . Aeetft laaoni III 40^ ioui /lo» nsHov lAjiQ^wv ofupivi' 

IfiOVUU 

utvQU xuXxhnoiB oni/iao fXiya (pvaihiansQ 
418 . . . . av i^ d uUs nia uXiiHmg, 
avt^aQ xiis nik^ anolam d^ fiiUHX^oQ 
1284 . • • . l^uyA xiXxtu ntvQiav 



hmac mmnltatem ooneti« 
tnil ai vellet pellem an- 
ratam anferre» tanroe 
neripedee qni flammaa 
naribna epirabant, inn- 



• • • 



«t araret 
«... Inno autem laao- 
nem ob id aemper voliiit 
eerfatnm qnod enm ad 



gevet adamanteo ingo ixMyvip ^ ini wIq anfiaQoii iidfiavufQ 

{Sqotqov 
m67 HSie inl uQifxagatr SXiQ nJ^J^ 

[VOQ *jivavQOV 
iviQWv evro/i/inc nsiQiOfiivg amfiihfiiv .. 
flameo Teniaeet rolene ' 72 yof ii /i* daaiUnpf • . . • 
hoaniiom mentee tentare, 
oimm ee ' eimoIaTit • • . . 
c£ fri».XnL 

- .Neqoe eonuneotarti veBtigia • desnnt. Onm enim qnae fab^ 
XVntt iaitio enarratioiii pronna abmpte ineemntnr: 'Phinena Age- 
Thras ex Oloopatra* habnit filioa dnoe^ hi a patre 
eiimine ereaecati enntV 'onm iie qnae enpro \f. 16] ex 
oAetniApoIIoiiiaaia et bibliotheoa ei a o rip ei, oompooantor oportet, 
tom ox /00 qtio^ paolo infra prorana eadem atqne in biUiotheoa 
de PUnei Argmiantaramqoe paoto narrantnr^), oommentator ab 

' i) 01 Mjfini wbai *Hae eom Argooaotae defeniiic»t et eom 



M'''^' 






■■■■'y\\ W 



f 



V 



n 



Li 






■*»•, 



ntroqae ezscriptus ptx>ditur. Addas fab. XVI Cynci filiis regniiiD 
ab lasone datum eeae narrari neqne Gynco progeniem luiase niai 
eohol. 1 1063 memoriae tradi. Quodsi in hie fabolia noimalla minos 
4 apte diota vel expoeita inveninntar, Terba fab. XII: *nt NeptoiK) 

sacrum faoeret* Tel fab. XXII *et ee mutuo interfioeret* fa!w> looo 
* interpolata 8unt| fab. XVI Cymoue Eusori filiui, non nepoe [d 

^ Apoll. I 049] dioitur, nomen insulae Diae e fabula XXI a eeierii 

prorsne aliena in Stymphalidum fabulam f XX] tranafertnr, fab. XVIII 
in Gysici inenla Propontidie [cf. fab. XVI] Lyenm quoque r^uin 
obtinuisse narratur neque reote tota fabula ante Phinei res [&b. XVUII] 
ponitur — haeo omnia eoropilatoris n^Iegentiae sine ullo scrupulo 
adtribuas neque illum Guretum moris meminisse vel Innonem ho- 
minum mentes temptantem fusiore narratione deseripsisse ^) aegrini 
quam par est ferendum. Sunt tamen in quae haeo ratao viz ca- 
dere videatur. Neque enim fab. XXIII mirum illud Aretae et 

■,i(,jr Alcinoi eonloquium vel duae Golohomm ezpeditiones ilndem m 

unam oonAisae dootum aliquem eommentatorem olent quippe quse 

a carminis argumento parum disorepent neque ad ipsam fabulam 

. variandam aliquid valeant, neque ea sunt quae quis ApoUonn 

earmine quamvis negligenter lecto rel indiligenter in iabularuii 

t^ ' argnmenta converso scripsisse probabiliter pntari possit. Quodii 

fab. XXIII haeo verba ab ApoIIonio qnidem [cf. ITTI 1008 sq.] 
aliena: *quem iudicem sumpsemnt qui eos in posterum distulit* quaiti 
libri Argonauticomm argumentum [cf. p. 484 KeiL: i ds AiKSip^- 
fisvog bI^ Ti}y avQiov] iita amplificant ut Alcinous quippe qui ab 

^ utraque parte arbiter eonstitutus esset, litem in poetenuD dista- 

^v lisse dicatnr, vel eis quae in fine oodicis Laurentiani argnmento 

Argonauticorum [p. 683 Keil] leguntur lasonem eo ipso temporB 

. altemm oaloeamentum perdidisse quo lunonem per flumen Anau- 

^ mm transportaret '), ab Hygino fab. XIII lunonem hoe in consilio 



i.- 



iier ut demonotrarety rogarenty dizit se demonstratoram si eum poent 
liberarent' oum bibl. I 9, 81, 4: fimflofiipoif 6k rotip jtffYonmm^ r« mt^ 
foS nXmf iia^itv. ino^fflio^ thw nlovr l^if rw ^Agnvtmr iceror ih 
inaXXaSwrtv, . '■ 

1) Cf. fah. XX: 'exque more Curetom sonitu ess fuganint* oi 
fsb. XXn: 'luno — volens hominnm mentes temptare annm se siau* 
lavit et rogavit ut oe trantferrent; edm ceteri qni transierant dmptadh 
sent| ille trsnttulit eam\ 

\ ^9) Cf. haeo: yivoftirot ^i iy r^ jtpavQ^ tf siorw^fi* im* ik 
ovtof €iiaottlittg' xoH-.fovlofiiPos noQil^^ . idpioxu inl vis ojf^i|C tlpf 

m 

*■ ^ • * ■ . . ■ ' . - ', - -•;: 



s 



24 



hakwiwrtr addiiiir, Teri mnlto 1111111108 Tidetar. fabolamm qoae Hy- 
gim ferontor aoetorem non ot ApoUodoromi ipsam earmeD maDiboe 
triviflBO, aed argomenta oom ' eoboliis commizta compilasse, paooa 
qfomaS, narrationis lomina atqoe omamenta de boo ipsios ingenio 
adfluaeiiim, In oommentario igitor iHo reetitoendo ot bamm fa- 
balanm teetimonia minime aperaenda eont, ita ne nimia eis tri* 
ImsKtar aoetoritas, oaTebitor. 

Oarmen qoo Orpbeds res in expeditione gestas narrans pro- 
poolCar, qoo tempore antiqoae doetrinae memoria magis magis- 
qiw efanesoeret omnisqoe laberetor literarom soientia, ab bomine 
indoelo compositom esse bodie apod omnes oonstat ^). Qood Orpbei 
arti «i aapentiae qoaeoomqoe Aigonaotis felioiter atqoe gloriose 
«flflMnmti Tindioantor, saorifioia ab eo institota longissime desori- 
Imntar, res alionde notae — Lemniaram soelos, lasonis fortonae, 
Medeae ibga et faoinora ') — obiter oommeroorantori baeo de soo 
iij^gienio aoolw. inTonity oetera Apollonio debet pleraqoe. Paooa 
ipla essoripsisse aatis babeo: 



Orpb. Arg. 283 sq. 

ov yoQ ifiOiya 
mtMm h ngunUmmp d^scoitf- 

goufir Amamv. 
i§uSBs f Smm oi xgadt^ 9vfi6g 

U fiSPOlvf^ 

Jg/^im onjottirAv xa{ w nigi 

nana fuX^OH 
aqfimttw i n 61 fi^ inog ^H 

xal igyoPf 
wiwnp imidiiovatv at^ify^ipmq i 

hA yalaw 
dm mt ig KtiixovQ ^ Ig dUoAx- 
-/> moiiQ i¥9giinovg. 



ApoU. I 88& 
loi^ma pvw lAr Sqiamp aqMiif^ 

aanog Sm^o 
tgxafiOP ^fiolm ^ nspra Sxaom 

fiikoijo 
nhua owdmia^ n fitm Ss^moi 

fi€Aia9ai ... 



^gtaf ygt^ ifimmHtaw /hulofiip^p fikp ^mniftAom^ ^/kwfiiprip ^k iratl 
iowmoip 9»vO!rv ik ygovp, tho rovro yl^ 6 *ioomp Inpmp in\ tmp ifimp 
ii oo ^fi a Moto fiioop fov nontfMO to tp niJtlop Motolinmp inl tov ir^lov 
et fl^m Torba^ *ea aotem iiata PeKae qaod sibi ssoram intermiserat 
hto&ro, ottoM o|Iason nnalB Orspidam in limo relinqneret* 

1)/Piraet«r) dispotationem Bermaani of. qooe adtolit 0. Mdller, 

p.»H '■ ».'•'••/ . 
iOOb4Tfsq.861sq. 




II 



ir-:-. 



•sX 



► ^» 






• T 



« nal fiiQ S^ fiovpop aifw ififA no^ 886 iXkii fHoi* ^vig ydg Ig *£!• 

XisQ Ts nai iadkol XaA» poawog inlaaoB^ 

292 IjinAr AniQolyMia&o n6vo9 IfVf^ f ififn niXonm Ig Alijvuo 

uUog i(pQ* &p S^fia&s. MilsvSm 

609 ' 1117 

^ ^Aqyog (T aSy itavo XmAw ovbqi' ftm di n aafiagip artnog c^- 

fia r^a nAoa sp^fwpop tSlg 

OQ^tapvffikolifikJmj^ 



^itig giop Ctpga niXoiw > 

ifinAov addl^ i$^ iir^xe^* AxiJ^oi^ ovgdtf; IsQip fioinQ* 

{Am i* imamfiipotg figsxag Isgip svxoafiwg. • • • 

Idfioavijiaip ■ ' : ■ ^ \ 

615 1128 

ip i* Sg^ instyifiSPOi Mtpvai, fiotfiip i^ av j^iQ^iog naQsy^rsoit,- 

fiiya i* fi^c^ navmw ofifl ili ^-vUoi^ 

AlaorldriQhdaxsaair aQilQom fio§» ats^fafisifm iQvlroi» ^*iyml«|yg 

/i^r mvSar iiiOuovwo 

w hn mvQodvvovg Xotfiag ijd* JUtpiga Jwtvfibpf noXvnitmsw 

IsQoi xaX& iyxaliopssg 

ii^oLP AQun^sq* anorigai dS i^ 

ittio TW^ 
690 n 666 

iovnog d^Sfinikayig is ital oiQot^ ^ • • • • ^'^'^ ^ noUi) 

viw svQVP Uavsv 
ftffwvfiipoio kXviuivog iQivofiivtiQ 8Xfi$i &ifafiQaa9Afa viffOQ iSg, otSs 
/ xs &aXdaafig Si irdnog . 

xvfiati nwfhi(pvu* nsQifigifiS S* afiSQiaXiov*' nanq di nsQi fiiysts 

Sanstog SXfiti . sfiQSfisv oUh^^ 

711 604 

iA)! its ii^ noQdfioio xav» oid^a irdi^ i^ Ag tva xOqov im^ijgBiip 

tui ii& nitQag £Uf|Agokar 

KvaviaQ ijf/Mi^ XdXog ijpoiuc ai* voAsfiiQ ifflf^o9sV 

tbf Sq* afys 
fivaai^ov i^Sovvto xal tfino- 

iov.aliv $fufivov. 
760 1260 

2x10 i* ini nvouug Svifiov n^ twijfm f. ^AQfOiO isaifioaiifgauf 



alanog jiQyA 
^Q^QUtg^iQKOfiivtfg ^ovq in^ imlr 
'.": , \ Qova xiafiov 


. tunroo 
Oadv ^ oioi ^iona xoi Ssga 

nolQom Mavooiam 




, f " 

1 • ' • • * * 

.•■••■. • •• 



ig^^nifmf U^^iw 0amv tcavSt 

miMm^ imi mamfioiB ii& aiifia 

mQHfif ^noQ 
hoftgy, mMi^,SQa OEApavaQMtd 

nitxK iffvfiphp 
jA^am mmdfmim noX Shma niZp 

. in umaq 
j fj Hm a& m f jiiinn xo^M^alji iid 

\tfmmibQ f Jfmyo maQaififUvog 

inkaoiv 
Xmlfom u mHXup Moi inlnQiov 

ai9i xakwnm 
l0«tr ^bml/iwringi in* otffiol^ 

Si pioodat. 



1264 . • • . Ata i* c^njuoK 

« 

olgOMap nowftoio fiiyaw ^op* 

avfAg S mivr^ 
Mo^ladav iniaxsp. fyjov (T in* 

igiaaQii x.hq(Sv 
Kttvnaaow aXnfiona Kvtoilid ic 

ToiUy jittiQ' 
8p9op iT ai noUov -A jiQiiww 

IBQd ^ Bkofi 
lolo 9ooi t6di ittSag iqm^ bXqvio 

ioKOvwv 
nsntafiOPOP Xaoiounw inl iQvig 

aKQOfiovoaoiv. 
1262 
aiiUa <r larla fiiv ntd intxQtov 

Sviodi HoiXfjQ 

UnoiixiiQ atslXavng ixoofisoir iv 

ii md aiiov 

tativ SKpaQ xaldaavTO naQOMkiiiv. 
lom scriptorem hano id egisse adparot ot mAoifeBtam Apol* 
Idiii tmitatioiiem Yenilme panlnm mnt-atis Tel rebne iranspositis 
celarei. Gniiia rataonis egregia ezempla •nnt qnae initio oarminie 
[ym. 232 — 804] de Argonaatamm conviTio, navi in aqnam dedoota, 
dnM ereato Apolloniano ordine [of. 1458 — 457. 875—892. 886— 
340 aq.] inTorso proponnntnr toI qnae itinera Tereibns 365—872. 460 
—474.486—496 desoriptaApollonii Tersne 1 519 eq. 581. 568. 582 
—586. 594—601. 915—918. 608. 927—985. 940. 955—960 prave 
«qprimant; praeterea ti. 715— 717. 786—747. 751—759. 719—785 
enmApoll. 11 845—396. 815 iq. 854 sq. 898 oonferantnr. Vel ree 
qpeaa ille panlalam oommataYit et contorrit: illie laao ipae at Her- 
cnkm diibem eligerent, Argonaatii proponit [cf. tb. 298 sq. cnm 
ApoIL I 841]« fons GUta non ez pympbaram sed ex ipsiaa Qyxici 
«xorii laesrimb oritar [ef. 600aq.'cdm ApoU. 1 1065 sq.], Hercalee 
▼eoandi eania in Myfia de naye ^greditar [of. 642 aq. cam Apoll. 
I 1187 aq.], Oiroe laeonem et Mideam non domo ezpellit sed in- 
trare omniao Totat [of. 1240 sq. ram Apoll. nil 745 iq.], Aldnoufl 
faidMnai iUodAon enm.axore oommanicayit» Md ab ea propocitaqi' 
MeepiiCef. iikSsq. eam Apoll. nil I096sq.] alia plura. 

• . HoHm ili ' iiiQertb morari neqae argeo in Orphei oatalogo 
[m isSa^itilSaq;] ex iia qnae ApoDoniaB de tribaa Merearii 




n;i' 



ii 

11: 

1! 



I 



V. 



V 



..""' 



^ .. 



r 



II 



it 



27 



• filtis Eryto Eohione AethsHde trftdit [I51tq.], Anphryd flameii 

et.Antisiii}raiD ad Idmonia rei transferri, quo loco illoram gentii 

exponitar, LsothoMn qaam Idmonie mstrem faisse Phere^dbi anetore 

A in eommentario legitnr [schol. 1 130], oommemorari aro Meneto ex 

- ApoUonio [1 66] aampto; Tel eadem fere oonfatione qua apod Hyginom 

[fab. Xnil] Demonama mater PhilooteUe [fab. LXXXXYII et CIl] 

h~ EnrTdamanti adscribitnr, ab Orpheo [ts. 1 07 sq.] Meliboeam Philoetetao 

I^triam Enrydamanti Tindioari. GraTioris momenta eet qnao npad 
Diodornm [o. 56, 8] de Argonantarnm reditn dieaotor: imi H 
# ' tiSr Sffntmp ini t^p MiHP uofuad^im jtjv y^w ^oyw^ ti §imvifiW9 

• nal nhfilo¥ yevofiiwovq rai&^uw $Iq * n^v Jca%P ij^Sg ABiamcr A^ 
nktvOM apte eam his Orphei personati Tertibae oonaooiari [1067 sqj: 
oimia <K Ttgogfvydv UoMvofUw tdnvw Skt&fOP^ . ? 

il fi^ Sq* OQftaliwaay ini HQonff^ fihf^ 
yqfa ftohZp t9vv* bd dt^iy oiffiakoSo 
Z/^ 'jiyxmoQ j 

1172 sl fiil yoQ /1* lsQ^¥ imyydfiyMiVttQ HxQjpnp 
9tokno¥ &M yalffQ ts^Kol dtQvyinHO 9aXaaatfg 
t^Bod^f aii niXayoQ x$y jiAapmciw iioiQEaafim. - 

1209 &vaQQiimv ^ avixQetfm 

^ axrnbv inayxklraQ olijiOF* h iT Sq' instxsw ": . 

fiij n 9ta^ Idif nsQ&v^ inl (b^c^ ^ sToyo ^ovoav^ 
^ > 1247 Xttt idn Xvadfisvot nslvijQ Sno nslofiata rijoov 

xvfia imnQijaaovTSQ dv& aiifia Ta^gnfiasXo 
InofiS^^ aviXy» f iuiXaaftsv *HQaMX^og. 
Vig^ . _ SnQaiQ (T ofigi^ i^fS^ ^twvvaoio SvaxtOQ 

> filfivofisv ianiQiOi' iai^ U ot tsno ^fiOQ, :' *-- 

^fiOQ (T avtoXlffUv iyslQSio ffOHHpoQOQ afyXfi^ : . 
iQdQioi dQsaUuQ yXavxt^v ix^aQoaaoftsv SXfiipff 
SoQitfov d* tx6ftsa9a fivdiv xiXnovg ic jiadvotv. • 
Praeterea Boreadae oapite pedibnsqae pinnatia et eaatee 0|yaiMae 
^ , yentornm li oonlisae apnd Hyginam ApoUodoramqae redeniit ')• 
Deniqae de Phineo looae inaignis est [vi. 670 aq.]: 
|y9o S* itpoQfi^vtsQ in^ slQsalg xs xafiivoQ 
Bi9vv&v fiiya Satv fiadslg xHXiiafiSv iaa^ 
ansvdovtSQ nQoxoatQ ^S^ dvi nfXiQyi»v SksuQ 
SansQOi aiXtadivtsQ ItfonXlaaiu fUya SiQnov. 



f \ 



I * 



1) Cf. Orph. 223. 668 aq. [quamTit oorroptam ferbam imrifeir/i^- 
i^ titf tamen de aenta dubitari neqoit] eam Hygin* fifio. JJSEL Apol- 
lOd. I9,22|2. [ef. eapra p.l9]. .r^v/; . ,^. » ^ 



/' 



Sp%hi niri alpiyafiOQ Omiig i7t$Qifvogi dvfujf 

• 676 ioufig il§akmiHK y6yovg nfofiX^ai n nitgaig 

^tjffoir SiwQ ngovd^ yvmloiy dv&ta tplXxQWv, 
woig ds nai amaiduQ nal 6/iwnitag oJih^ SnvlSiup 
muis nhnov Bogiw^ 0inS U oi oHnaaav Sr^v 
ifyalioio xoiov, ipanhg <r in§v6(Kpiaav avyag* 
WO' miivaQ ol tJafiBvi^ BogitiQ oiQtHpdieamv aiXkatg 
ignafyMg htvhvio iii ifvfii nvxrn tud vkag 
BionvbiQ [va x^(f* tkoi^v nai n6xfiov inlang. . 
His ▼eraibiu fabalam inesse Sopbooleaoi e eobolio Apolloniano 
[II 178]: SogioKX^g H ou wvg ix Kk&majQag vlovg irvqXom nnQ- 
Alnor ml KQOftfiov nsioMg Aafiokaig *Jialag t^ aittSv fnjtgvi&g 
cnm bibliotbeeae looo [I 9, 21, 2] oompotito: xai m^d^val fpaaw 
mSwiiv • • • o{ itl vnh BoqIov Hoi luiv ^Aoyovavnav Sn nsusMg fiff' 
ipufl lot^ lHovg IvvfpXmaa naliag '} elnoet, Neqne enim a sdio- 
liMta non poetam tragionm, sed grammationm cnins nomen 
•choliis Argonantiooram enbBoriptum essetY adpellari Bergkins *) mihi 
probaTii. Qni qna ratione e soboL -Sopb, Ant 980 nbi altera 
Phinei nxor ab ipso Sopboole in TyoipaniBtis commemorata eBse 
dicitart haeo elionerit: Mam qnaein Pbineo de hifl SophocleB tradi- 
deriti ea es dooto flcholiaBta ad Antigonam cognotoimnB ad tb. 980 

• •.••• Dootnm BoboliaBtam qni qnid SopbocloB in TympanistiB 
de ea re memorarit noTorit, nomina qnoqne Pbinidarnm ez Sopbo- 
diB PUneo rettnliBBO oonBontanenm eet* prorenB non intellego. Qnae 
mco Pbinidanun nomina a Sopbocle aliena OBBe oognoTiti eie nt 
tola ftbnla ab eo abindioetnr, non magia nti licet qnam eis qnae 
nehoL Pind. letbm. HI 104 HercoliB filiiB EuripidcB indidiBBO di- 
cUart nt Heroulem fnrentem respici negetnr, praeBortim cum 
poetae tragicoe eiuBmodi nomina omnino omiBiBse, gramma- 
tieoi poBtea argumentiB interpolattc poBt Hillerum*) Wilamo- 

^) demoiSBtraTerit. Neque ullum SopbocliB grammatici teeti- 
tatalogie illie &bnlarum qui in BcboliiB ApollonianiB eztant, 
lnB O i i um legitnr» hand panca ta^en poetae [of. Bcbol. I 769. IIII 
(si III 242). in 104a 187^. mi 284]. Vnde talia in Tilem 
poetam penrenere ne linguae quidem Graecae Batb peritum 
•t oerta hiBtoriae fiftbularie nbtiflia adeo earentem nt Peleum ei 



1) Gt mra p. 16. 22. 

2) Utts^ Bhen. I p. 861 Bq. of. Boberi L o. p. 81. 
8)BemieB Yin442iq. 
4)AnJiL|Boripi4p.l84Bq. 



1 • • 



:;1 




'Vv\ 



•II 



II 



u 



39 . 

Telamonem A^nae filioe diceret [cf. Tg. 18 K 186 iq.]? Videas pnw 
ierea quam non aptOf qnam sine arto ooneza illae Phinei fabnki* 
mm reliqniae narraUoni eziliBsimae insertae rint: . Terine nmitios 
est hominem ietam docto aUqno Tetemm fabalaram thesaaro uaam 
eese an 'non solam Argonaaticomm carmen eed oommentariam 
qaoqoe oompilasse? Goncedendam est non omnei difiBcaltatea hae 
ratione lolvi, praecipoe mira illa et nova qaae de Argonaataram 
redita proferantar, non extricariy^ led limplidorem rationem noa 
Yideo ')• 

Geteram fabalae Sophocleae merooriam a Dionyiio fcnratam 
esae Diodoras testis est [1. c e. 44, 4]: ovx Ay¥oci H A6n wig 
nSy fiV^Qdi/xoy iwpkutdijml ^oci lo^ 0i¥tliag ini to9 mipoc 
Httl viy 0ivia T^c o^uolag tv/jBiw &vfHfogiiQ vnb BoQiov^). Etiam 
Orphei adalescentes in rupibas ac siWis ezpositos posteaqae oeolia 
restitatis sanatos ex Sophoclis tragoedia originem dacere aiqiiia 
aasit stataere, testimonia praesto sont Aristotelis [poetie. 16]: ical 
^ tv JoiQ Oivsliat^* Uoikm yag lip tono¥ ovvAoylaano vi^ s^o^ 
fiiyiir in iv mrtia Bffiagw Ano&avuv ainug' nai yoQ tfinid^fmp 
ivravda, quao Yerba Welckeras *) probabiliter explioaYit, et Arisl<K 
phanis [Plut 638] ^): jiank^moH nmdivoQ tv^svodg tvxwp. Onmino 
Dionysias fabalam Sophocleam suis at solet rationibos ooniorsiaao 
Tidetari quin etiam conlatis AristoteJis Ycrbis et epigrammato 
Oysiceno [anth. III 4] : 

fifltQViitv KXvrlog xal nkvmvoog nokvfn^dtjQ 

ntslvovai Ogvylfiv fjiatQhg vnsg otpniQaQ* 
JOiHondiQ^ (T inl toUn» &Y£kXstm ^ nglv haiiev 

xav dhvitac faftstikv dafivafiivtiv MwQf 

saspicio est no qaae de noyercae poenis poeta narraTit, ita fllo in 
fabalationes saas transtolerit at more solito Hercalem omnl hmiMi- 
nitate et dementia oraaret, praeterea yel hoo looo Scythas imini- 



1) Praeterea ea de eauia parum liqoere non neglegendnm aat 
quo itinere in Oceanum Argonantas penrenisse Orpheos personatos aibl 
finxerit, qnod locus graTiMimus nonnnllis versibos post 1069 keuiia ia* 
teroeptit perierit. 

21) Qnae schol 8oph. Ani 980 docto oompidnantar, a IKonyaio 
aliena esie Tidentur. Ccteram tragoediae argnmentum in Ikbakniim 
oompendiis looum obtinuit of. Apollodor. III IS, 9 neqoe omitti ▼elim 
Ovid. a. a. 1 889. rem. 464. Ib. 269. \ 

\ 8) Trag. graeo. III p.l906. ^- 

V 4) Cf . PTG p. 997. • ^ ^ . j 



i 

( 



80 • 

[of. Diodor. 1. o. o. 48« 44], 8od Iimo haotoniis. Qaam 
pomMi A Boroa Phlnoo InflloUm Pioadoorphoaa adieoit, ut Diony- 
tiuM nomoriM tradidiiso Tidotor, it-a noioio an adtingant qnao ox 
Haaiodo Ephomt apad Strabonom adtnlisao didtnr [VII p. 802]: }- 

'flb/odbr i^ iv tfl naXovfiirg /^ n^oitp lir 0ivia ini nh ^Aq- 

rimnofdywp dg ymav inijpatg ohtt fxiwap ^). 
OeDiqno qnoniam hoo nno looo Dionysio Sophoolis momoriam deberi 
earlo eiploratnm oit, cotorii qnoqne qaae huo pertineut icholiis 
IKoiiyrinm os Sophoclis teitimonio adlato adgnosoi hand temere . 
mnelnditari praesertim cnm Sophoclis fabulae indo a primo a. C. 
■• aaecnlo magis magisqne obliTiono obmtae rarissime historiae 
poe ft icae adhiberentar '}. 

Oonstat igitnr fabulas Argonaaticas doote et copiose commen- ^ 
aeotario quodam traotatas esso ApoUonii Rhodii Argonauticornm 
salis eelobri quem Orpheus personatus bibliotheoae auctor ApoUonii 
ncholiasta, aliquo modo Hyginus compilaTerint. Nequis tam^n hoo 
adidlioram ApoUonianomm oorpus soriptoribus illis in manibus 
ftiisM ezistimot. Neqao enim eo iempore grammatici eiusmodi 
trilogias qnalo ichoUomm codicis Lanrentiani fundamentum est» . . 
oonponere sdUta esse ridentnr etobstat Stephani Byzantii auctori- 
tfts aolis Sophoolis oommentariis uri *). Dionysii yero copiae nnde in 
odiolia ponrenerini, onm e schol. I 1089 /ur^oioii» J^Xoxog mv 
m9m(f§9irMP Hg ffjM SwffoAflg — Deiloohi testimonUs Scytobrachio- 
Dem nsum esso oonoenin sohol. ApoIL I 189 et Plnd. Pyth. IIII 
387 anpra [p. 2.] probari — adpareat neque res fabulares a Sophoclo 
n^leetas esse schoL I 982 nbi eum latere Steph. Bys. p. 4, 16 
doeeli ezemplo mt| Sophoclem de quibus modo dispntari commen* 
toiioi eompoiniMO non tomere conioero mihi rideor. 

Tel inde qnae lohoUa Theocritea et Apolloniana oonoinunt 
fcaad paoea ^)« non ad Thoonem et Theocriti et ApoUonU interpro- 



i4-^ 



1) Qoae de hoo Utnlo *rjfc nt^o^o^' riri dooti [of. MarkiobeffeL ; 
pwlSTtGoottUng. p.LI*]iQdicaTere, oinnia roinime placent Mea qnidem 
oeateatia pan Oatalogi/rel Eoeamm maltli terrii gentibnsqae enume- 
mlii imignii 1% jti^Mor dloebatnr ut in Homericii oirmlnibni Mori* - 
h^ft nwr talia. . \ A , ' > 

2) Soiiolia nnt I 769. U lta'm 242. im 228. m 1040. 1872. . ' 
84. v.L 

8) Ot >:4, 18. 9» 8. 202, 14. 858, 8. ). 
4) Ot adMlL Theoorit m 18. 48. 49. Yil 77. Xm 1.7. 48 eum r- 

Apoii^ n 477; 1 121. im 57. 11 i24a m 28. 1 1207. 1288. 







81 



i 



t 



tem referenda eeae ndparet. Meqae omnino in hnne eoneeniuui 
eedem qnam •oholiii Pindarioie Euripideisqoe adhiberi par est| ratid 
oaditi qooniam qnae •choliia Theooriteie et Apollonianii oommnni» 
inannt, ad nimie diversa genora pertinent qnam nt ex ono eodem* 
qne anotore ab ntroqne oommentatore ezeerpta eeee Tideantar, 
eed eoholia Theooritea mnlto breyiora atqne esdlliora ^) eam apeeiein 
prae le fomnt nt eomm auctorem Sophoclis oopiis ninm eseo veri 
simillimnm sit. Neque hoo reoentissimo iempore a GalUergo 
editore pi^indpe faotum est qnia panoa soholia ApoUonianis plara 
oontinent e. g. ad vs. XIII 1.7| alia Yetnsto codioi Ambroeiaiio 
insunt; cf. scholL III 43. 49. Improbanda igitur sunt quaedohae 
re dispntavit Ahrens [BucoL Graee. reliqu. t. II p. LXIIIl]. 

E iHonysio Scytobrachione pleraque »b Apollonii oomnieii* 
tatore desumpta esse satis opinor adpamit. Demonstratnm eei 
quaeoumque ut fabulae Argonanticae ezpilicarenturi ez Hesiodo 8i- 
monide Sophoele Antimacho Nicandro Deilocho Pherec^da Aeonleo 
Soymno Eraiosthene Timaeo in soholiis ApoUonianis ezoerpt» annty 
Dionysi opera esse c6nlecta. Neque temere qni illis anotoribQo 
saepe adiunguotur Nanpactioorum poeta Eumelus Bpimenidee Hel- 
lanious Ascleptados ')> eoram a Dionysio testimonia adlate eaBo 
vel etiam Ephori Istri Antiolidae soriptoram pragmatieonim 
libros *) adhibitos osse statuitnr. Denique nulla fere dnbitatio eai 
de Aoschylo Hecataeo Herodoro. Neqne enim magis simile eei ^eri 



^, 



1) Gf. Endymionis historias lohoL Theocr. IH 49 insertes oani 
docirinae molo aclioL Apoll. IIII 67 oongesta vel haeo . verbe eohoL 
Theocr. XIII 48 ovfitpttvtT dk r^ ngnnyj Mot jinolltiptn^ 6 'MidSroc JMtl 
Nhav^Qoc e ichoL ApolL I 1236 xal JNfxavJgoc h tf ^twigp rmp 'JSTrs- 
Qoiovfiivwy vno naawv fi.tiai¥ nvrov «Qnnyijivm rvfiipmv, 6 ^k *AMolXm 
vio£ vno fii&f prave deaoripta. 

2) Adiunguntar Naupactica Phereoydae schol. II 290, ipsi Dionysio 
Sophooli Hesiodo Bobol. lU 242 nbi Epimenides qnoqae oommemomiar. 
Herodoro schoL lUI 80. 87; Eumelus Pberecydao scM. 1146» Sopboeli 
UI 1872; Epimenides Herodoro Aousilao Hesiodo schol. U 1122; H^ 
lanious Dionysio et Herodoro schol. U 1144; deniqoe Asdepiadea He* 
rodoro schoL I 28, Antimacho et Pherwqrdae sohoL U 178.. Praeierea 
of. sohoIL m 621. 628. 1 181 [«t 11207] 146. lU 266. 886. 1086. 1086. 
1087. 1 162. U 828 [— II 662]. 

8) Cf. scboIL I 974. 1087. 1168. 1289. U 207. Onasos AnMUKmi^ 
ooram aaotor [sohoIL I 1207. 1286. Theoorii XUI 48] densa . caligiiM 
obratos .est neqne Heokeri et Maileri oonieotora \^orvotec probari 
potest. Nomen ooonrrit CIAI p.24 n. 88. . « \ v •' i :; . 



s1 



82 , ^ ;:.;v-;.-: 

6I1III «octoreni a Dionyiio Deglectam esse qai satiB antiqao tem- 
pore magnam historiae fabularis pari^em pragmatieis lationibus. ' > > . : 
adbihitia oopiose enarraTerit, quam in his fabularnm oatalogis alii V^ 
deberi Aeiebyli alii SophocliB memoriam. Eadem Tero' quae in \ >" |^ 
Herodoroi ^alet in Hecataeo ratio praesertim enm eius mentao iis 
qnaa aehol. I 256 insunt Dionysianis arte eoninngatur. Tamen 
CMitio est ne huio fundainento nimis altum et sublime aedificium 
Wip e fsirn atnr. In ipso iUo magno seholio [IIII 259] qno maximam 
paitem Dionysii oopias oongestas esse oertnm est* occurrit Arte- 
■udomB Ephesius qaem post Scytobrachionis aetatem floruisse con- 
■let ^), neque hoc multi momenti est» qooniam oL schol. III 859 : 
ntgi t^ Kaaniug dtAaoaijQ tatoQ» ^AQZSfilSiagog iv t^ imioft^ mv 
rattyompoi^iimvp quae ez Artemidoro adferuntur [scholl. II 946. 968], 
eK Mardani epitoma') a Bysantinis, quippe qui etiam Strabonis 
etLjcophroms mentionem iniecerint [schoU. II 942. IIII 1515], in- 
terpolata esse Tidentur* Sed eiusmodi ratio non yalet in Ascle- 
piade HTrleano quem praeter soholL .II 722. 789 ez schoL I 623: 
OBs ds hMis Biag iaddfif xal KXitap o Kovguvg tamgel xail^axX^ 
maAjg l MvQlBavhg iaxrig oa nagA KXiofvog -t& ndna fjtenjrsyxsp 
WjnUflfffOC etiam scholl. 177. 587 adhibitum esse odpareti neque V 
■QO an ad enm at in reliquiis libri de poculo Nestoreo apud Athe- 
Bneani [XI p. 489 B] serratis Ita in scholl. I 1126. II 815. 845. 
911. 929 PSromathidae Heradeotae mentio referenda sit *). Quid- \ 

qvid id est, ne hnno quidem soriptorem qnippe cuius aetas inter 
Dioajsiam Thraeem et Asclepiadem intercesserit^), Dionysio praesto 
eoostat» neque est cur Demetrii Scepsii vel Apollodori Athe- 
lifaros ab ipso commentatore exoerptos foisse negetnr*). « 



1) Cf. Maroian.; per. Menipp. [Geogr. gr. min. ed. MfiUer I p. 566]: ;. 
'jtQwtfiiinfgos ik 6 *Btpiaiog ytwyQMg>oc xoTa rify ixofoortiP itaxoariip • 
irmnip olofinMa ytyop^. 

2) iX Mare. peripL mar. ezt prooem. [Geogr. Gr. ed. M&Iler 
I p.516]. Ihidem p.574 sq. firagnienta pleruroque a Stephano servata 
eeoketa sunt. 

8) Gf. FHG m p. 201 sq. . 
^)Ct Athen«Xlp.489B. ; ; 

9) Gt sehoIL I 280. 288. llSiS. 1165. III 1B4. I 1116. 1124. m 

549. 1090 [tmkm naffxti^ittti * AnokXodaHpn iv wwp jncralo)^]. Alteri . . .^ 
otri qoae de^jldaeis D^iotylis scboL 11129 eiponuntar, debentur of. 
Strabo^^Z plira. Veanthae Cysioeni tesUmonia [sehoU. 1 1068. 1065] 
e DeBMlrii Khris desaiiipta esse ez Stffaboois Terbis p p* 45]: nqot ^ ^ ^ 

Mm99% tiii\kM(^mi^ ^pdartfiotiQmc inUiymp tMn^ on oi *ji(fyo* 

I: 







y« 1 



, ••'. 



08 



■>, , ' 



. / AddM quihio ^el iUio adfenmtur ecriptoreB primonuD i. etp. C. 

^-^ s'\.}''-'^:;'^ 11. saeculomm noXvfiadHQ Lyumaohui [eoholl. 1658. III 1178. 

.V /^ 1179] SelenoaS| cui libri a Charete ApoUonii familiari de illina £a- 

i^ ';^;}f bulis compoeiti notitia deberi Tidetur [sohol. II 1052], Alesander 

Polyhistor [scholL 1561. IIII 1492] unde schol. 1740 altera 

Armenidae mentio flusdt % fortane etiam schol. III 242 Diophanti 

' Ponticarum historiarom auctoris: cf. Steph. D7a.p. 6, 18: jiX£j»r' 

igos di ir Jip n^ ES^vov n6vmv ffirpiv cS( Jii(pavTOQ (Sbm oSm 

Xiy6a9m oi-io^ iw ri ii¥\Afiiavov noiufi^ mtoat^v. 

Multo minor Dionysii reliquiarum est numerus Pindarl ear- 
minis Pythii quarti Euripidisque Medeae scholiis senratanun. Ad- 
notasse saffidt Scytobrachioni deberi qui sohol. Pyth. IIII 398 de 
Aoetae tauris Antimachi tostimonio [cf. snpra p. 2] adduaitar 8o- 
^' phoclis Torsus neqne ez alius auotoritate schoU. ▼• 258. 450 He- 
siodo Simonideque auctoribus de lasonis origine ^el Indis ab Ar- 
gonautis in insula Lemno celebraUs disputari. Schol. yb. 288 iis 
. locis adnumerandum esse censeo quibns Dionysio anctore rea ante 
ipsam expeditionem gestas enarrari supra [p. 17] demonstraTi '). 
Scholio Toro ts. 61 cuius ea parte quae cum schol. ApolL HII 1562 
concinit [of. supra p. 2]» Dionysii sententia refertur» Asdepiadae 
grammatici mentio fit quam ut ceteromm oommentatonun fere 
omninm memoriami ad Didymi oompilationes referendam esae Teri 
simillimum est *)• Vt igitur per Sophodem in soholiis ApoUoida- 
nis» ita in Pindariois per Didymum Dionysii memoriam 
esse probabile est, atque diligenter animadTertantnr quae Med 
scholiis Bubscripta sunt: ngiq iuUpOQa AvtlfQoupa. JwwaUnf iXotgjh 
Qsg nal nva x&v Jtivfiov. 

Vnus scriptor praeter eos quos adtuli hand padcM 8eyta> 
. bra^hionis Argonautiooram reliquias senraTit; qua tamen imtioiie 



vavrm nliovng tis ^atv tov v^' ^Ofi^Qou «icl tmv SiVimv o/ioloy^Dvytcyor 
9vIovy oonoladere non licet. 

1) Cf. £. Maass, de Sibyllamro indioibas diss. Gryph. 1879 p. 22 
n. 54. 

2) Hygin. fab. II fabulae Phere<qrdeae fmstulum serfatam esl: 
'qubd oum Atham^ se faotnrum abn^disset, Phrixos uliro ao libeos pol- 
lioetur se unum oiritaiem aerumna liberaturom*. Noveroae ndmeii Pin* 
darioam apnd Hyg. astr. II 20 legitur; addas II 87 eadem Teriloqaia 
inter .se obponi atqae in Dionysii reliqaiis [ef . supra p. 2. 8]| ei ma- 
teriam loquaoem Argo nari infixam ad Aesbhylnm referrL. * ^ 

"^ 8) Cf. sbhol Kem. II 19. Oooorrit praeterea soholl.. OL m 22. 
VU 2i. VIU 10. 28. Pyih. IIU 18 insor. Nem. VL 

■■■'■■- ' "• - ^■\ \' ^'' ■'•• ". :. •;• ; ■ 



84 

koft «deiderili diffidle est indicaiii. Valeriiim Fleooaiii et fabulae 
aigimieiitaiii ez ApoUonio aiimpsisee et io ipea oratioiie poetamm 
RoiBaiionim more e Ghraeco ezemplari mnlta Tel integra Latioo . "" 
eemioiie ezpreeiieee Yel eleganter atqne docte inflesdsse Batie ra-; , ^ 

peiqm demonelrat ttm est^); hoe loco tractanda ennt qnae ab 
ApoHoido diecrepani. Gom Diodpro enm hand ita raro concinere 
olim q|in eom ediditThilo animadvertit *)• Inprimis Hesionae fabu- 
laae mpoA niramqae Argonaataram ezpeditioni inseri notaturi prae- 
BOtlim enm Ue eonsensns inter ipeas qaoqae narrationes interce- 
dmt ^ Deiiide Iphin qacm Dionysio aactore [cf. scholL ApolL 
im 228. 328. FHO H p. 8 fr. 6] Diodoras c. 48,4 ^ oommemorati 
m Aigonaiitis Valenas [cf. 1 441] reoensety nec paiica in carminis 
mitio eani qnae eum l^geris fieri non pot^t qnin Diodorea in 
memoriam reYOcentnr. Gaius rei docameniam hoc loco satis 
babeo deeeripiiones adferre lasoois oam ezpeditionem a patnio 
suscipiai mediiantis *)• Deniqae fabalae a Diodoro 






« » 




< » 



• . II u 



y 



1) Cf. Weichert, Leben und Schriflen des Apollonini p. 270 sq« 
C Taleri Haoci Afgonanticon libri YIII rec. Tbilo p. VHL XII sq. 

2) GH L e. p. Vin n. •♦. 

8) Cf. Diodor. IHI 42 . . • '. xtA nffoftptx^^^^ ^^ Tg^6og ngot 
Xfyeier. ivrnBSm iT nvrwr tiiP tinofamv nmiia«ftivtfy ivQtt^vui tpttat 
mm^ivw Mifiiv^w ni^fk tov tdytaliv . • . et 6 ivraBlht ^k tov fikv 'Hgtt'- 
mlik fiir» tmv *jifyomwmp rifr anofktmv noniaifitpov tuA f»nOovttt 

mm^ tifg «o^qc ttiv ntgtnitiittp cnm Valer. II446sq. 461—470 

Tol qnae de pesiilentia et functtp illo oraenlo narrantor [e. 42| 2] ; nQOf 

Sk toitotc lotfiop ifinMttp iit ta jrlif^ mcI unQnmp nttptilii tp^oiitp 

«Scrt mmptm^ iMnlijittitg^ ro fiiyi^ot rf c mgttntiaimt .... ittnitfoptot ^ 

^^ XWI'^^ ^ifivr vnuQx^p JIoattMpof vtti toti tavtifp XtiSiip Stttp ol \ 

TTgmtt f^ litx^p tmp tiupmp iMovoimt ntiitaJmtfi finQap rfi eifrffy ^alp \ 

mmiptmp tit t6p uliiQOPt ififatpoptmv inavtl^^ tlf 'Hatovtip tiiP to9 ' v * 

^bmiiAK ^•7«rr^i^ eam ts. 476; 

princnpio morbi oseloqne eseeta serono 
• ^\ iemperies . 
•iW. 480-484. 

^4) Olim Wesselittgins ez oodlonm leetione! V^^iror ror EvQtf 
mHtK i^thpop rcstitnii ^itptp th» *B. A. 

8) Ct eom Diodori ?erbis o. 40| 6; *iaaopu Jl ^oftrc oQtyofitpop 
SMil fir d^ler iotitpintop fiiv, od{ .itaHl nitv if Uipatop itQipopta utA 
Stk leere fiillop «^ir int^poPiditQop iataim italafifipopta rersas 

* y^ . an • • • • IMa iosm ospessai 
ri qo^ eperie fanti domito eonsafgere ponto 

;t in sok animos toentesqoe peraris C^ 



**> 



« 

exposiUe [o. 46, 8] /« • jca«^* Sp S^ Xt^vov n^ ^Anywwimi. • • . 
wxAq wnankBvtm f% KokxiiioQ Aq li nQomg^ifiipov tifU9og' 
sr9a dii fU(fmx6nag ig Mi(kltf nXawoifiirg n^l tAp aipaUr 

4k non nesciuB Valeriai Medeein noeta ut Phoebom pli- 

earet domo egressam et Argonaatis in litore ooearrentem fecisM 
▼idetur ef. V 829 Bq. 841 iq. 860 sq. 

Neqae fero cuiqaam opinor Tliilo persaamt haeo ez ipM 
Diodoro a Valerio deeumpta eeee. Qutd? poetam Romannm primi 
p. G. n. Baeeuli ut oarminis argumentum et materiam docte undt- 
que conquisiviBse Tideretur orationisqae ae ?erBOum elegantiae fabn- 
larum adderet noyitatemy ei auctori Btudinm et operam nayane 
qui niei a BoriptoribuB ChristianiB ByzaotiniBTe nunquam sit lecti- 
tatuB '), qui ex quadraginta libriB duoB ad Graecomm hiatoriam 
fabularem breviter enarrandam dcBtinaverity qui Argonautarnm fB- 
bulae miBcre confuBa atque perturbata rudera propoBuerit? Scilieet 
eidem poetae veteriB doctrinae copiaa adeo pracBto fuiBBe ut ipee 
Herodori libria uteretur atque Diodorum dignum videri qnem lee- 
titaret, Thilo eziBtimat. 8ane Tiphy mortno Erginum naTcm gn- 
bemaBBe et apudValeriam [V 65] legitur et in Bchol. ApoU. II 895 
HerodoraB auetor ect, Bod alii adcedunt loci qnibuB a Valerio 
eadem atque in Bcholiis narrautnr neque ea a Diodoro diacrepant. 
Apud illum enim tota quae c. 47 de Aeeta enarrator fabula b 
oraculo quodam Aeetae de aureo vellere dato*) vertitur. Ynde li 
velluB e MartiB &no ablatum oBBct ce perituram cbbo enm oogno- 
viBBot» regem teroplo TauroB cuBtodcB adpoBuiBBO et velleria eosto- 
diam Draconti cuidam oommiBiBBc; nominum Bimilitudine (aetum 
cBBe ut Graed de taurie ignem vomentibuB et draoonta inaomm 
inepta fabnlarentnr. Hae argutiae eui fabulae adbibebaninry eam 
hoc Bcholio Apolloniano oltm expocitam AiiBBO elucet [01694]: Sa 
ii xHfPh^ ^^ ^4^ MofiivoQ vni tSp aimB iyyiiwv anoUa9m 
xal *HQ6iat(^ Iv loiQ *ji(fyovavfai^ uriD^*). foifiDt; Sma mt Taff 
i^BvS^p vSiv wvgoiy Xiy» ovfiF imvo^aui^ quoniam Aeeta non ee de 
eauea tauroe iungi iuBBit ne ab ipBina progenie interficeretnr, aed 
. ut qutcunqne velluB aurenm anferendnm eibi pcopoBuiBBet, anmma 



1) Nihil valet qood Plinint [h. n. prooeni. 26] bibliotheeae tito- 
lom eommemorat. 

9) 0. 47, 2: fitrit ik tavra /htailivovtt f fc JToijfAlbc .^flfrf jppr 
Ofibv iMniattv 8r» rof i xmaOfgiyfMi rvv fiiav Ztmv iivoi MmitufUiamviH 
fo xQvaifiallov Hqoc iniviyamah pfi § ^. ., .'■:'r*\\ .: AJ . , 

8) Haeo iternm VB. 606 adBoripta Bunt. r > ^ 



■» ' t .— , 



86 






iMntii perioola tabiret Meliiia huiiiB fabalae memoriam Hygiaoa 
[fiab.XXIIJ ■enrarii: *Aeetae SoliB filio erat responsam tam dia eam 
. ngnam babitaram qaamdia ea pellie qoam Phrizua conBeora?erat» 
m Uao Martia eeeet itaqae Aeeta laaoni hano siroaltateln oonsti- '■ '^- 

tnit •• • taoroe • . . iangoret.* Neqae Tero qoin bano fabalam Diony- 
dofl priaaqaam rationea illaa pragmatioas qaasDiodoras exsoripait» 
ezpoioiaaet, aaoioribas nominatit adtalerit dabiam est. Atqae 
'pfforaiia eadem Taloriaa somno Aeetae portendi dioit [V 286]: 
tune tibi r^gnoram labea laotuBqae sopersant, 
rapta aoporato faerint oam Tellera laco. 
Naqae tamen tanta haias poetflie dootrina hisioriaeqoe fabalaris 
peritla mibi Tisa est at eom Dionysii libris ipsom osam esse sia- 
tiumu Malia opinor aliier institoissot, noya inseraissot, nota nove 
inoiataaset si magnam fabalaram oopiam a Soyiobraohione con- l 
geatam ipse diligenter perlnsirasset et perqaisivisset. Fere enim 
ab ApoUoiiii ezemplo non discessit nisi nt doctrinae adparainm a ' v 

- poata Alezandrino speeiose proposiinm reoideret vel orationem. nar* 
ratioiiemqae olegantius formaret, ao ne bellom qoldem qood a Saa« \ 
romatis a Perseo aroessitis Aeotae inlaium esse narrat, anttqaitos 
traditom esse videtori sed ne oatmini epico bolli pognaromqne 
deaoriptiones nationomqae et ozeroiiaam reoensas deossent, oz Apol- ' ' 
loiiio [III 351 sq. 892 sq.] ab ipso poeta ef&oiom. Immo qoae ab 
Argonaatiois disorepant| apertam Apollonii imitationem adeo non 
t^gant» tam faoile dignosoonior et divelloniar ot olim Taleriom 
fsre omniay at Orpheom personatam, ez oommentario sumpsisse 
pataren; ubi onm Dionysios ezsoriptos esset, factom esse ot Va- 
lorioi et oomDiodoro et com scholiis ApoIIonianis saepe concinore . 
Tideretnr. Soilioet oommeniario molio plora inerant qoam qaae \\ 
Bvoe margini oodieis Laorentiani adsoripia legontur; imprimis de 
nboa anto ezpeditionem gesiis ot oarminis Apolloniani iniiinm \ 
«silo et paene obsoorum longios ezpliearetor, baod paooa e Dionyrio 
oocosrpta \e8se vel te iis q«ae de fragmento Pherecydeo sopra 
{p. 17] dispatavif aeqaitor, similiqoe ratione ez eo consensa qoi 
intoK Valerii nliimam primi libri partem [of. I 767 sq.] et ApoUo- 
domm [1 9| 27, 1. 2] Interoedit, aliqois saspioetor ea qaaepostezpe- 
ditioaem lold aoeidenint, iU enosita iUsse praesertim oom nar- 
nlio Apollodorea non mnltom a^Dionysio [of. Diodor. c 50, 1.2] 
ikUL At' nbilto aadaoios totam Hesionae fabolam ez commen-. . - . v 
tario Ynleriaa liaaaisse eonioitar ; immo alia ratione poetas Romanos 

^tleonim' Grae^oram ope asos esse siqoando ni oarminam - ^ ^ 
ila"diMlo oomponerontiir, aliqna historiae po^oae notitia 

IH ^- ^ - -•,:■- 1 •'' *" •• • .^ • • *•' . ••' 



•« 



.1. .. " .. .' l^ •. 11 



87 

I 

■ • ' • 

opiu esaeti TsonenM mo. oommonofoeit inprimii OtMI litorie md 
Inliom Hyginum dooiornm Tirorum cnliorem et Mitietiteni dAtls 
'"•'' ninu: ef. triet III 14 praeeipne yb. 48sq.: 
4) eaepe oliquod qnnero Yorbom nomenqne loeomque 

nee quisquam eet a quo oertior esse queam. 
Handabont enim poetae amiois. olientibns senrii ut hane toI Ul«ni 
hietoriae poeticae partero e Tetuttis auotoribui oonquisitam broTiier 
redaotam multis poetarum loois instmetam proponerent: dooamonto 
extat Parthenii Kbellus Oornelio* Oallo destinatus. Quo Yoro tlie- 
sanro in einsmodi angustiis Oraeonlus aliquis oommodios atebatnr 
quam Dionysii Yoluminibns? Atqno ut eius sorinia in Talori nsom 
oompilata esse supra adpamit| ita nnm plnra e]ioiantor« «rii eir* 
' onmspidiendum. 

Pindari oarmen Pythium quartum enarratio Valeriana oom* 
pluribus loois sapit : inprimis oonferas qnas apud utnmiqae 
Pelias ut lasoni expoditionis perioula slne ulla dnUtation^ eab- 
. ' eund^ esse omnlbus* modis persuadeat» adfert oausas: Phrisd ambrmn 
in somniis Tisam, ipsins oorpus seneotnte debilitatnmi lasonie vires 
atque iuYentutem ')• Quominus antem Valorius Pindari eemiinn 



f » 



1) Nequo neglogendam est ol. lohoL Pyth. Illl 281 Phrisi amlirmm 
Pindari propriam esie. Geiernm hi sunt Yersus [157 sq.]: 
.... nXV ifff^ ^f ytiQtuop fiigoc Ahnta^ 

ttfitptnoXiT^ aov «T «fy^or^/fnc &(frt MVftttim' ^imuim iC tU^dMp 

/layiy /^WftiF* uilitnt ynQ i&v ^vxkv MOfii^ .; »_ .. 

4>qISos H&orrac nQhc jit^n ^Hfiovc 

JiQfitt tt MQioG fittl^vfittXXoy iyitv, 
Valer. I 41 iq.: • • . • . nostri de languine Phrixus . '^ v 

. ^ Cretheos ut patrias audiiti effugerit aras. ; tlV ;-''^ 

hune ferus Aeetes S<qrthiam Phasimque rigentem ,*. r 

qui oolit — > hen magni Solis pndor <— hospita Yina ^ 

• • • . 

nil noitri diYumque memor, non nnntia tantum 

famareferti ipinm iuYonem tam saoYa gemeniemi • * 

ipsum ego eum lerus fessos sopor adligat artust . 

adspioio: laoera adiidnis namque illius umbra . /.«... 

qoestibns et magni nnmen maris exoitat Helle. 

si mihi quae qnondam Yireii yoI pendere poenas 

. . Oolohida iam et regii eaput hio atqne arma Yideres. 

olim annis ille ardor hebet neodnm mea proles j 

.imperio et .belli rebus matura marique. .: : \ 

tu oni iam ouraeqne Yigent animiqne YirileSi "'''•< . ! 

> l deoos et peooris Kephelaei YelUnra Graio }; .• f 



♦ .« 



."^ ' redde tholo ao tantis temet dignare peridist 



• 



88 



1) Cf. L a TS. 71 sq.: ^iatpmop ify ITiliw 

ii iftnmv jffoliJiip (Ht¥ifitP ;|fc<^airfy $ povXntg iutifAmoa, 
8) Uoo ito ezpmsit Yaleriui [1 lOOiq.]: 

ooiniB adest qoao iam bellis •peotataqoe fama 

torba dooam primae aea qaot in ^flore iaYentao 

vfmplamenta tenent necdam data oopia reram. 

Geloram Pimlari memor^TheooritatXni 27 HUtt amof ^Qtiw et rt. 17 

«ftOTfc^. • • • nuaa9 1» noXimv nffoUXiyfiiroi iw ofptlit n diatit Qaem 

eit Tergilioa [eoL im 84sq.]: 

ot altora qaao jteliat Argo 

doleeioe beroas 






ipoe peraomtalai esso Tideatat obetant qnae de Peliao in laaonem 
odio Bamit [I 86 sq.]: 

sed soa olla qallei animo fratrisqne patenii 

progoniem divnmqao mtnas; hano nam foro regi 

oiiiio ▼atesqQO oanant peoadamqoe per aras 

torrifioi monitas iterant, saper ipsios ingens 

iBstat fama Tiri Tirtasqoe baod laeta tjranno. 
Ormcalo Aim illi oommemorato qaidem a Pindaro ') qnod additor 
Peliao aaspeetam Tirtatem ae famiun fratris filii faisse, id Diony* 
oiaai adtolisse testis est Diodorns [c. 40, 1. 8]: ftififi d£ Od^awQ 
"■^ y^VCi^ Ao^ffpdnjn Atviptana . . . . lir (T iM:^iy %iXafitiadM 
fiifMau aws(ffiv fyar f^r Mw inl9tpm t^ fiaaiXdtf ueqoe eom hoo 
uo looo Pindari oarmon adhibaisso ez ds qaae seoantar adparot 
[om 41,8]: ^IAao9a di* . • . Inkifyu rwv igsyofiipwp x^^ aw^ ii^oitt- 
fAMg woig iia^vaaiAmvg agunG^ oonlatis oam Pyth. IIII 188 oq.: 

I( di ^Lahtiy ind uajipa mvtav Bmmg ')i y 

A^io ndvtag ina^vijaaiQ Idaiap ')• 
Atqoo alio looo oom Homericam iUod ji(fytlt ndm fiikovaa a Pln- 
dmrQ poalo fiisias ezplioatom Dionysios sno moro ad rationes po* 

noqne Tolgari rorom homanaram natorae oontrarias do- ^, 

itoram poetam et mythogpraphom Valerias miseait [1 96 oq.] : 
at lono Argolieas pariter Macetomqae per urbes 
spargit inozpertos temptaro parentibos aastros 

Aesonidon: iam staro ratem remisqao saperbam 

pooooro qoos roTehat robosqae in saeoalo toUat^). 



• • 



8) Itaqoe meo iaro Pindari memoriam his sohoUoram ApoUonia* 
lods Diomrsio doberi oenseo: DII 869. 1668. 1668. 1760. O 498. 

4) Baoo PiJdaraa p. 0. Ts. 184 sq.]: 
nhr 4k noftnm^il ylmAi^ l^^^nmp ni9ap tpimiP^B^ .1^7 

niskiym^iiinpmXmnifitPaif ''■ 



i 






a9 



i 



&ao haiid acio an periineant qoae do DioMorii m Ironie aiden 
ferontibus irndit [I 568 aq.]: 

dixit et ingoDti flaromantem nnbila snloo 
dei*exit per inane faoem qnae pnppe propinqna 
in bifidnm disceuit iter fratresqne petivit 
Tyndareos plaoida et mediie in frontibns baeeit 
protinus ambomm lumenqne innozia fiindit 
purpnream miseris olim iroplorabile nantia^). 
Hagna teropestate apnd Samothraoen insnlam orta enm Orpbei 
Samothracnm mysteriis initiati precibus omnes ab inierita aerYoti 
eseent, in Tyndariduro capita siellas cmo demiBBas tradidit Dionj- 
sioa [cf. Diodor. IIU 48, 2], simili omine navem oeoe aoIttteni^Pitt- 
darus [I. c; vs. IDTsq.]: 

ix vBrpifav ii o» upvivas fiffonSg ahtov 
qMyfia* XofinQoi «T ^X&ov ootnpsg angonSg &noQQ9ff¥v§i&¥ut. 
ifinvo&¥ <r ^QOitg SamottP dvov aafnaap mX. 
.Poteji igiinr Valorium ominif tempns ex Pindaro, oetera ex Dlo- 
nysio hausisse. Ceterum Dionysiana commentario fttiMe iiiaerte 
Hygini [fab. XIIII p. 89M.] verbit probatur: 'his eodem qo«>qae 
tempore stellae in capitibus ut viderenturi adeidiase scribitnr*. 

Atque alius quoque huius Hygini fabulae locns adeo eom 
Valerio et Diodoro concinit ut certa Dionysii vestigia adparosuit. 
Ibi enim qui inter Argonantas singulis ad navem regendam niuiori- 
bus fungebantur, sio recensentur: *Dux ergo lason regnavit. tmber 
Argus Danai filius • •') cuius post mortem rexit navemAncMMoe 
Neptuni filius. proreta navigavit Lynceus Apharet filius qui molioai 
videbat. toecharohi autem fuemnt Zeies et Galais Aquilonio filii 
qui pennas et in capite et in pedibus habnemnt. ad prorom et 
remoB sedemnt Pdeas et Telamon. ad pitnlum sedemnt Hereoleo 



jav unMwov nuQa fiarQl fiiyttv tiiiiva niaaovi* iXV inl mU 
tpaQfioxov xaXliaTov iag aQnaf alittv iVQia&m abv aXXoit. 
Ezplicai Diodoras [c il| I]: ito »al rmv tiovtwf alno Tori kmtnnXiiw^ 
TOfiivmv arol r^c fpVt*^^ Jtaiodtiatit xara r^ 'SXXiia ntQi tt roS «Moer 
arol Ttjc xoTit rigfr vavnifyiav imfioXijf oix oXiyovf tnv iv vntQoxdtc 
viauttv intlkvfi^aitt fHTaaxttv Ttjs aTQortiat. 

1) Gf. ni 188. IIII 861. V 868. 

2) Tipbyis nomen excidisse vidii Munokerus. Quomodo 
faotum sit ut Argi paier Danans dioereturi prorsus inoerittm eet^ 
forie hio orror ex loco illo oommeniarii [of. supra p.3] neglegooti»^ 
sime exoerpio oftus. esse puiaiur qno ab aliis Argunii ab aUia 
primam navem consiruzisse namri adnoiatuin erat. 



40 

. ■ ' *' . 

N. 1 

filioB. pcMt relioto eo ab Hereule looo eius eedit Peleut Aeaoi filias*. 
Ptamifl eadem ratione Yalerius illa munera distribuii. De Orpbeo 
Ljneeoqae *) ne nlla qnidem est dnbitfttio neqne bis Artemidori >. ; 

M ooolatis [n 28]: loiAc d2 ffc ^^ v&y xv^r oiyia/ivft, lim- 
ror d!i viy ng^fgia KtU J/^OKog lir wfisg^iitrip^ tA H SnXn 
loAg Mving nal ri niQag rhp tolx»QX^^ YAlerius alind atqoe 
HjigimiM Boreftdnmm mnnns bis Tereibui desoriprisae ridetnr 
[I 468nq.]: 

qnin et GeoropiM proles Taoat Oritbyiae 
temperet nt tremnlos Zetes fraterqne oornobbe'). 
Qni Yoro apnd Hyginnm prima et postrema tranfltra') oeonpasse 
Heronles Idae Aeaddae, iidem apnd Yalerinm ^) inrignia 



I 

i 



1) OtI470sq.: neo Toro Odryrins transtrit impenditor Orpbeoi 
ant pontum remo eubigit, led oarmine tontas 

ire dooet eammo pamim ne gnrgite pugnent. ^^^ 

ei 489 oq.: at frater magnot Lynoeus serratar in usus ' \ '. . 

quem tulit Arene, possit qui rumpere terras 
et Styga transmisso taoitam deprendere Tisu. 
fluotibus e mediis terras dabit ille magistro 
et dabit astra rati oumque aetbera luppiter umbra 
perdideritt solus transibit nubila Ljrnoeus. 
^iy"^*— ^ ptopter ooolorum aoiem proretae monus susoepit ut qaae nari 
ia Uiu er e imminerent primus oonspioeret et gubematori nuntiaret. Gf. • 
Pdbtiffer. de militianaT. p. 802sq.. 

S) Ceruebis qui eztremis antennis adligabantur [ef. Luoan. Vlir 
17S sq. Z 482 sq. Soheffer. d. mil. naT. p. 146], Tok dirigi dooet Vergilins * 
[Aam.inft49]: ti 

eomna Tolatarum obvertimus antennamm . 
Oraiugenumque domos suspeotaque linquiraus anra. v 

Bno imtione etiam Claudiani Terba a Sobeffero [p. 809] adlata explioan* 
t» (d. cona. ManUi 42 sq.]: 

at Tslut eacsertus lentandis narita tonsis 
Kraefioitur lateri oustos 
datie remigum labor remittiiur. 
8) Hoo Terbis *ad-proram' et *ad pitulum* signifioetur neoesse . 
qaidiiaid tnb literis PITVLVM Ultet In nltima sententia ' post 
00 cto.* aliquid ooiifnsum est. 

4) I 888 bino laerom TeUmon Ji^elagus^ tenet, altior indo 
// ooonpat Aloides aliud nluure • « • i . 
408 neo Prient fretnt' tooerit et ooniuge di?a . 

doj|iiit ae prbra tplendet tna outpit ab alta 



»1 

• N • • • • 



^z- -^- 



480. '/ i lireriore petit iam oaemla remo 
''ompat et longe tna trahttra norittimnt Idat. 



M/ 



/ 






41 

loea obtineDt neque haeo arte inter se cohaerere n^ari lieet« «t- 
ei haad eeio an nomina ab Hygino tranepoeita eint| et yaleriaei 
pamm aperte atque olare loqnitnr. Deniqne enm Valerini fiibri 
mnnne ab Argo obitnm eodem modo deeeripserit atqne Diodonu ^, 
haee omnia de qnibne modo diipntavi ex DionTsio eeee deenmpt» 
non poteet fieri qnin existimentnr. Totum enim hnno eatalogum 
ab nno eodemqne anotore oompoeitom eeee adparet 

Simile atqne de Valerii oarmine» de paoeie Stati Thebaidos 
loeie indioinm forendnm eeee dnoo. Apolloninm ab eo leetnm 
e. g. Theb. V 51 oL enm ApoU. 1 601 docnmento est: Dionyeii 
nifeetnm Teetiginm eo looo invenitnr nl^i Amphiaraue narrat [lU 517] : 

iam tnm prima enm pube ▼irentem 

eemideoe inter pinne me Theesala regee 

duoeret, hio casne terraeque marieque eanentem 

obstipuere dooee neo me Tontura loeuto 

eaepiuB in dubiie auditns laeone MopsusJ 
of. quae supra de illo disputata sunt [p. 2]. Deinde Tyndaridamm 
habitum et Statius [I. o. V 4i0] et Hyginns [fab. XIIIl] iU deeeri- 
bunt ut praeter stellas frontibns infizas imberbee eoe fiiisse ne* 
morent, neo tempeetatem Argonautamm in Lemnum insulaai ad* 
Tontu coortam pugnamque eum mulieribus Lemniis commissam [cf, 
I. 0. Ts. 360 eq.] ex Aeeohyli Sophoclisque tragoediie ipee mimp* 
eisse probabilins ezistimaiur qnam argnmentis qnalia schoL I 769 
extant perlectie totam fabulae deeeriptionfm et ree eingularea da 
sno ipse ingenio efBny'jee. 



1) Valer. I4778q.: -. 

^ Arge taae tibi onra ratisy te moenia dootnm - 

Thetpia Pelledio dant mnnere; sors tibi ne qoa 
, parte trabat tacitam pappit mare fissaqne fiootn 
Tel piee toI molli oondaoere Tolnera oera. 
Diodor. 1. a a 41, 8 Zi^ov .... avfinUvifavrot frcMf rov ^^Mfvsfr mA 
ra nopovnn fjiii^ tns viii . . Ceteram Thespiensem. onm dixitVialoriiia 
Argum, aut obiter legit aat oousulto mutaTit ApoIL 1105: - 

Tiiffvt d*jiYVtttdtit Stfpain uAXhm i^op ' .\ - ' 
BMmimy* ia&lot ftky offiyofiiPoy nffo^ia^ym • ' ^' ; . 
xvfi^ Hht tvgiitii ••....•. * i 

109 ivvni fiiy Tgirmi^f &Qiat4$»y it Sfiiloy 

mgatyjilhgytUii* finit «T $lv^r iUofiiyotmy* • 
avtfi yoQ luA y^a ^y uAfiV avy ^i oijifj^ ; \ ' 
.. uvfty ji(fiinoj(fi^fis. uiiyffQ inotffnfioaiyifiiy* ' \' 

ot Valer.xl 02 sq. > : :, .^ > 

• • . . - ' , ...•.:. v- . *' 



42 



m 



V,- 



« 



At IMoDjni non •olani Argonautioa Diodoras oompilaTit aed 
oz iis qnae ille de AniasBonis et Bacclii rebns gesUs narra- 
mni^ haadpanca senraTit; certe libri ieriii 0.52 — 55 et 67 — 74 
ez eo ezcerpta oeee ipae didt [52, 8 et 66| 5]. Baocbi ToroLibyci 
Cobiilia onm band panca a Oraeds de Baccbo trodita praeposnit ^)| ^ 

sibi ipse Diodoms oonstitit qnia tribus primis libris barbo- 
ontlqnitates, inde a qoarto libro Graecomm bistoriam fa* 
biilarom se traotatnmm esse bibliothecae initio scripsit [I 4, 6]. 
Qiuun inconstantiam eo magis urgeo qnod qnae iibri qnarti iniiio 
[e. 2 — 5] de Baccho Graeoo narrantnr tantnm abest nt ea a libro 
tg r ti o [e. 64 sq.] di?ersa sint nt fieri omnino neqneat quin ex 
oodem auctore desumpta esse pntentur. ytroque looo Semeloe 
Bion Baechiqne ortus sine ulio discrimine narranturi neque in 
mrlns discrepantia est^ nisi qnis forte. quod altero looo lunonis , y 

fiJlama praetermittitnry Toteris nescio cuius scriptoris auctoritati 
trilMiere maTolt qnam Diodori n^I^entiae; qnae libro tertio de 
Paceharam ezerdtn, ezpeditione per orbem terrarum ^ta, impio- 
nuB poenisy Bacchi triumpho, sollemnibns trieteriois dieta sunt» 
hntfiter eontraeta qnarto libro repetunturi boe unum inseritnr 
Boeotiam patriam a Baccho Itberatam Elentherasque oppidum oon- 
dUoiii esse*). Hoo enim loeo quippe qui ad Oraecomm historiam 



1) in 62, 1: iifitTg «T iml nQonQ^xitfiiv iv rofs AfyvTnimiots n§Q^ 
Hjg too ^topvaov ytpiatme xttX rcSr M avrov nQax^iv^mP axoXovlh§s 
wmts ifj[mQioi£ tawoqttu£n oiMttov iivm 6talttfiflapof4tv nffOfMvw rk fAv^O' 
hayoifuvm n§Qi toS ^cov rovroo noQa roTip "JSAZ^oi, 

2) Plaoet looos inxta positos ezhibere: 

im 2 ' UI 64 ^ 



• • 



• 2 rj ^i JStfiilji M fo xalXof S.,.fiv9oXoyovatyttQiQaad^ivta^ia 

^im fuyivtm mtS^ fitd^ ^ovxiai noi» fii^ijvai nltovaxis avrj, Ji« ro Mal' 

mifuvov tof ofiiUat ^oSai xaratfQo^ Iq^, r^r «T "Hqov C^Xorvnovoav xak 

ptSv tAmjiQ* ^iontQ vn* avr^g naQO' fiovXofiivfp^ rifimQfq ntQtfiaXttv riiv 

jd^^fMs tat intnXotAf 6fiotas noi* av^Qmnov ofioim^^vai fiivrivt rwv 

tSmHBt tmig nQof ti/v ^HQmv avfint- wnoSox^i rvyxavovamp naQ* avr^ 

QtipbQmiu wiv fiiv oSv Jta naQayt* yffVtuxmiVf naQaxQOvaaalhu ^k r^y 

po/itvoiv ^tanQtnmg fittm fQovtmv StfiiXfnv* ttntTv yoQ nQot altfiiv Irt 

jmeI m€tQmnmv itikpmvms nwtta^mt xat^nxop ^v tov dia fitra r^g avr^t 

tifv' €9Voipaimv p^p 4k XtfiiXffv initpaptfai rc mI rtfifis not^a(hu 



• i/mmw mmm» MtA. ro fiiyi9os t^g r^ SfuXimv yirc^ X9^^ '"^^ ^h^. 
A MtQtmtmmtttg olm "Ivifm^mtw r o fikv nQif tiiv ^Qmv avftntQt^OQmv* ith 






.n i 



•Kfcl ^ -' 



. .;f 



/ . ■'. s ■■ l ■ ij ■ */^' ■• 



48 



*-*v 



fiRbalMrem pertineai, Tetweni illttm Baccbam Indicam omitti 6ne* 
oamqae pro Titis repertore haberi non magis miram eet qoMii 
alteram Baecham ex Ioto et PkxMerpina genitnm Semelee filio poet- 
poni. Immo in bac ipea diTeraitate similitado adparet. Neqae 
enim eolam alter Baccbai atmbiqae eodem modo deecribitar: 



PQitpoQ ixtqmam^ vno dk lov nvQOf 
nMiP uUviiiam, imna ro nm^Cov 
AvttXafiovnt tov Mn nttffadovrai rf 

'^Qfij MCI nQOCTtt^ tovwo fikv aJio- 

noftiatu nQoi to nvtQov to iy tf 

Nvitjl KttfitVOP fMftttSv ^HHViKfli Xttk 

NtiXoVf tttif dk vvfitffttig nttQttJovVtti 
tQfffiitv iNcl fitttt nolX^i anovJ^f 
intftilttttv ttvrov nottlalhu riyy 
ttQiattiv* 6to jml tQtttpivttt tov Jto* 
vvaov iv rfl Nvafi tv^tTv r^c » C^V* 
yoQittS tttvrtit kno Jtoi iml Nvatii 



6 ntQttiyta&tti d* ttvtov xcil arQtao- 
ntJov ov fiovov ttV^Qtiv ttXXa tmi 
yvvttiMtiv 



XttH tovt ttSixovf Mcl AatfitTs twv 

. ttV&Qtinnv xoXaCtiv m 

8, 1 arQttttvaitvrtt d* tts r^y 'tvJtuiiv . 
rQitttt XQOV^ tiiv inttVoJov ttf tiiv 
Boiwrittv noitiatta9tti MOfiiCovrn fikv 
XttipvQwv afioXoyov nX^lh>gf «cra- 
yttytZv Jk nQtkov tmv anivtmv 
^Qittfifiov in^ iXiif>avtiK *fvSittov. 
xccl roifs fikv Boiwrovt xccl tov( 
aXXovs ''EXXtiVttg tuti BQ^ttaf ano* 
fiVtifiovtvovrttf rijt Mttth tiiv Vnff- 
xiiv atQortidg xaraMim rac tQU^ 
ttiQiJat ^vaiae Jtovva^ ttak rov 
Stov vofiiCtiv xara tov jf^iw 
tmirov noitTa^ttt riic naQa tUe ikv 
^QtMoii inttpavtiae* 



tud rov jihv Jia r^; SifiiXtfe «&ov- 
atfi rvyxavtiv rtiv tamv^^HQ^ ri/it5y 
naQttytvia9a$ fitra fQovtnv tnA 
xtQttwmVf riyy Sk StfiiXtiv ovx vjto- 
fitivaaav ro fiiytthte t^g n€Qtarti~ 
atmg rtXivtiiatu incl ro fQiiptte ^jt- 
r^iiMrcci nQo tov im^iyxoiToc ;|ripovov. 
MtA roSto fikv rov ^ia tax^ote cfc 
roy jccvrcw fit^Qov iyttQvipat^ fi&rm 
Jk rccvrcc rov «crft ^ivtfiir rfc ytw^* 
atme jif^yov tiiv ttXtittV «cwSrmr 
irof^ccyroc antvtyttiTv to fiQiif*oc 
tlt Nvaav t^t iiQttfiiae, ivmv9m J* 
vno Wfiipmv tQtupivra tov naS^m 
nQOtayoQtv^^vai fikv ano ttw nm-^ 
tQoe ttttl tov tonov ztiowaott, . . . 
fitra Jk tavra atQttrontJov ix wmtt 
yvvttixmv awayayovra xtd ^iQtvotg 
tta^nXiattvra atQortiav inl 
noi^attaBat tifv oittoivfiivtfv 
65,2 oXiymv if' avrmiv rc5y #i* v^c^i|> 
ipavittv tttik i^aifitiav xatatpQO it ttt ir t mm 

ttoXttffaStu ro«pc 



• • • 



rcMOvrocv vn^ ttvrov noQajfQ^gAi 






\ ■ ,• 



7 • • ror <r ovv Jiowaov iftun 
aavttt fikv rovg&atfitTe, IfficcjrcSccF^ 
nQOitvtx^ivra tttte aXlmeav^^ttimmt 
ittt^6*lv^itt^ein^ iXiipKvrof rifv <fc 
Bifiae inavoiov not^aaa^tn, r^c- 
rove (T^ dtttytytvtifiivov ro«f «rv^. 
nttvroe /^roi; ipaaX totfeTEXhgttm^ 
ano tavttie t^e ahiae ayw xmg 
tQitttfQldae* fAvMoyoXfai d* 
tuA XtupvQmv i^QOUiota nX^9ttg t8 
&nb ttiXtMaitfie otQottiae MQmtm mw 
tmv itnivtmiv t uttaymy^ ^iitfkftop 
tte^tifV.natQiSa: , . ; r \ 



.'I 



*k » *. 



44 

ira 4 III 64 

fiv96l»ywm H vng md . isv^s^v H fiv&okoyovai yspia^ Jl- 
lc^por Miinmv fsyovhM 6vvaov ix ^ibg xal n^o&povtjg^ t^ ii 
no&v HMC X^^^ ngotB' nrsc, ix ^iijfititQog' JoHroy 3i na^Bu^ 
fovrm miwov. ffuai y&Q ix dyovai ngwwv fiovg vn^ S(fOT^p ^sv^ca 
^kig Mtd Uiffa&iAvff; M^ li n^A toi; tum^ X^Q^ ^^ nvdgiimav 

wao9 /si4a9m • • • • • . . tfjv yijp naie^a^oftivwv 

Xiyovm if ahAv ay/tvoUf noQaarigAOv d* avna nottfKu xiQam xovg 
dt§mptuv md nQfomr im^ xataaicivd^nug mgygafiig ^ %oi)giv' 
j^gtjam fiovg C^vyvvuv tud dQtdvtag Sfia fiiv iviXovwuq hdgav tov 
Aa vovwuv ihv an6Q0v tdiv ^toviaov qtiaiv^ Sfia H &n6 t^ negi 
MugMmv imuX^v* inf ov lo iQOXQOv svgia&ag ifiqmlvovmg li 
#9 md xsgadav aitiv naff* fiiys9oQ x^g imvoii&Blaijg vig ymgydig 
Btgiyovm. evxgtiaxlag, 

aad eHam qnmniTis inepta iterom ad Semelae filiam pedem Diodoros 
refSBrt etqne id eo ipso loco qno supra roonni enm de inventione 
«lia atqne in libro tertio' tradere [c^ 4» 2]: xal xbv fiiv ix Seftihfg 
yvpifisvov iv lOig veaniQOig XQ^^^ V^ ^ oio^an yeviadtu TQwpegov 
ued naveekwg anuX6v^ eingeneif ie nokv x&v Skktav iieveyxeiv xai 
ngig v&g ufgoiunaKig ^vSg eixaTuqHigov yeyovivm ' xaTA ie n^ 
avgatelaq yvratxmv nX^dog jiegtdyeadm MadwnXtOfiivwv Xiyxatg ts^ 
Svgaeeftivatg, Haee anpra ita dicta rant: [III 64, 6] • • . yevSfievov 
di np MttXket iuufogov ti ftev ngtatov iv xogeUttg xal yvvmM&v dtd' 
0OK jcb) ntsvtoidng tgw/fg Mtd natiiq iiateketv* fista ie lavva atgw 
vimsdovMdL; neqneBaochi habitnro et nomina Satyromroque comi- 
lUie longe descripta ab boe loco aliena esee adparet his 
[e. 64, 7] ngig d2 mvfOK nana/ot* nar^getg Syetv xalfiov' 
matovg iydfvag owteMv onm illie oonparaUe [c.5, 4]: xadikov ii 
voStOM 9vftsktMeSv iytivwv tfaaiv svgsti^v yeviio9m xai diatga xam* 
JmSfiM Mtd ftovatMwv iMgooftatwv avotiifia irmifoaada*. Qnamquam 
Jjgitor ha Diodoms rbm institnit nt qnae illic hmo ezponeret, hic 
▼«1 praet^prnMtteret tcI bretiter contraheret, tamen ei non eyenit 
«i boe dttoa loeoe non «Inceret pro nno eodemqne habendos esse^ 
QaoDiam nU Ghraeoomm historia fabnlaris exponitnr, panca inse- 
rnninr nbnnnl]* mntantnr omnia male. et inepte disponnntnri snpra 
varom oidine aenrato oratio recte ; et concinne fluit, hnnc tertii 
libri loeam nnotoria Teetigia prene | Beontus Diodoma deacriptisse 
Tridotnr, onndem qnippe qni ad Oraecomm ftvdokoyoifteva perti- 
(ef. e. 62| Itfli ad libri quarti initinm tranatnlisse. Adparet 
tnadeiB qni^e. 64ei66 ieripait| totnm hnne de Libero locnm 



idb ft «i 6S impie ed Oi 66 eompoenlaie. An Dicdorui Oraeoo- 



« J', « 



46 



i 



r 



' 






ram de Libero fabnlas Dionjni de Baecho Libyoo diapataUoni 
qao loco barbaromm dtcXoyovfiSva ezponebaniar, p^^aeminsBet, nisi 
haeo omnia in nnam ooniuncta iam invenisset? Qnid? qnod Dio- 
nynoe illa parte qaa- compilatas eese ab ipso Diodoro didtar, mdmo 
similia duobue ceteris de Libero loois Diodoreis profert at idom 
omnia «soripsisse fieri non possit qain probetar. Dli dobetnr 
Bacchas ab aniTersis gentibns propter merita di?iiiis honcnilNia 
ealtas — ani?ersis enim hominibas benefieia saa imperttTit ne 
asperioris qaidem caeli nationibnS n^lectis sed Titis looo arte tMr» 
Tcsiam de hordeo ooqaendi donatis: 

III 73,6 11112,6 

irp i* aivp tQOJt^ qwiv hnik'» InUfia ii flsnrsdoy ikf^ vS^v iit- 



9uv xi^v oUmvfiivtiv tpjfugovpia 
fih¥ Tfi¥ /cS^y xai^ ^vn/ai^, %V' 
t^imiivtu ii lot^ kaovQ ftsyd* 
hu^ nfiaig nal x^^ ^^ ^ 
alwva. iih wd navmq lovg or* 
^wnovq h wXq ngig lovg Sk* 
Xovg dBoi^ nfioXg ov/ ifiolar 
^vtaQ nQoalQMv iXk^hnq (^aMv 
inl fi6vov joif^iovvaov ovfKfOfvoV' 
fiivr^v dnoiuxvvHv fiagivglav v^q 
iSavaaiaQ* oii/Sva ydg oid' 'Bk^ 
Xijnav oSxs fiagfidQUiv BfioiQOV 
$hm T^( Tovioti iu}QsaQ nal ^oi- 



mvfiiv^v nokXijv /Af^ ^&V^Vi^ 
aai Moi iiit io0io nix^m 
nS» fioytoMv nfi&v. • - 



:i 



f < 



svQHv <r avAv wui tb tn vijQ 



QiTOQ^ iXka naX fotng amf/QiO^i^^ ^^^ HamoKtvaiofiivov nofMu ti 
V1IV ijnovittQ xwQav f nQhq qnndav nQogayoQSVOfiBvov ftiv &K* tt4o§w 



ifinikov navttkwg Anf^TQuafiir 
v^v fiaSttlv xh xamaKSva^ofiSvov 
in mv KQt&&v nifia fiQaxv Aa- 
nofiBvov Tf^ TtfQl xiv JLvov «V- 
Oiila^ 



{t;^, oi noki ii kBnifiOvom r^g 
nsQl lir olvov tvwXaQ* lovio ds 

ivvafiivtfff imi^x^adm j^v 'g^ 
ofinAov ffvtdav. 



illi debentnr popnli Liberi hamanitatb et comitatis fama sine paipnia 
Tol oertaminibns deTioti: 



11178,6 
n&wri df itaiiiofiiirji; nsQl aitod 
tpiififfQ Ayad-ijg fiffiiva xa&djUQ 
nQhQ noXifiiov avntdTtaadai^ ndv^ 
xaQ d2 nQddvfiwg vnaxovonag 
InalvoiQ wd OvaUuiQ lig ^ohv «^ 
fi&p^ 



ni66, 1 

iiafioffioUni; d2 mti^ mtntt rt^ 
nov f^ YOt; ^sot^ naQOvatoQ md 
iiiti naav hututwQ ngogipSQiftS' 
voQ ifoAXck oiy</bU)Uii)tt nghc t^w 
iffffiiQWOiv loS MOiyoO filov mw^ 
ifj^d avvavt&p avv^ tud ifQooU* 
XBo9iu fi$t& noXXijg JCHfi^ ^ 



46 
illi Titea poniaqae agreeiis eolendi et eonBemuidi rationes a Liberb' 



m 70t 8 III 68, 8 

imum^im yiQ aMr $n mdda ••• T^^/eipa^ a^/iaioic dick n^y 
%i§w ^JUiciar lim mv fiir oliw %inqwda¥ ^tgavofn nokk^p Xfi-' 
Hgp qfiauf is wid Xffdai^ ino^U' nskop ngwmv nvto^. ano^Xitfwi 
ifmnm fiitgvg tij^ aiioq/vovQ fiitgvuq tud t^v XQ^^ ^i ^^ 
ifgnikmff vSp i* iig&liu¥ id dt> tiv fivov fpvam^ imvo^im^ ifiol- 
tmiMMm {qpo^yioADtt tud ngi^ ano- ok ii Mti nSr oiioav utd twv 
9tfmvguif»iv trtu X94^^f ^*^ SkXu»v iMgoigvwp t^v xa&^xovaap 
dfi «Bvm tud «ic i«datuv navt inifiikHav nmijacMm tud «a^ 
npimop fvtila^ itgoip^ Aoti tA ngig t^p iwyKOfiiiijp «ai 

nagd9mp vmwp t&p nagnwp 

impo^am. 
QoM ODiiiia qola orationl ita intezta snnt ut eioi omnino 
MqneaDt iieqne Diodoma qoae alio loeo ezposnerit consnlto repe- 
tila nanrationi InterpolaMe pntarl poeaiti totam de Baocho dispn- 
tatkNiem iiide a III 62 ad IIU 5 Sqrtobraohioni ▼indloo, atqne ti- 
mila qnid ae inpra adpamlt: non lolnm ille de Bacoho Libjoo 
aofaa et inanditaa fabnlas enarratit eed eopiosi( diepntatione de 
BaeoU natora enltn rebns gestit inttitnta qnae alii yel popnli yel 
meriptoret aliter de Baeeho tradiderant doote compotuit. Qnem in 
JLigonaatamm eatalogo eonttitnendo ottendit morem didtingnendi 
«i ditcriinina faoiendi *)| hoo looo rebnt dirinit adbibnit tribnt 
BaoeMt et apnd Oraecot et apnd Libyat ttatntit. Intigne hnlnf 
«odi argatianim ezemplnm ett deomm reoentnt Oieeronlt de na- 
deomm libm Inaertnt [III 21, 58 iq.] *) atqne. etti qnalit 



1) Baee tdhoiia dooomento tnntt 

1 28 'Hgoimgot iio dpfi X)gip9fc ipiiaiP iSi^ rhp tugoip. ayfinlivam 
fofc jigyominiit. \ 

162 iio ii clof JT^fc, i fiip *Miov oS fiPtifioptvu *uf JioAitiivoc, 
d ii itigo^ ov fiP^fiOPiiu *Sllipi«os Ip r^ niffk *AgimHa£. 

in 1087 :V ian ik ««1 frf^ /livmdimp ni^ oS *SlXdpt»og ioTogii 
[ct ad m 1086. 1066] luik aXlos 6 M(pmos mgi ov ^c^carM?^ arirl r^ 
wmgtog i 2f/teiToc oi fiP^fiopiiH jigiatinnog ip Uguaiinoig, 
Dioqjainm Phereqydet BeUanieot fler«|d\omt prodnni Ceteram ef. Valer. 
I S66 tq. Byg. fth. Xmi p. 44 IL i 

2) Admodnm timlllt ttt loooil 
tatiiea paiica Did jmo aaetorc adielnntor. Qni ibi adfertnr llbcr Arltto^ 
tolit^.enadeiileitaiocnteo atqno qniBhctl tehol 28 de thcogonia oom» 
aaeinonifirf.'^ Praeterca eonferat loenm Strahonit dc Baochi nrbe Ubyca 
[VII 9^289]. Ampolii m 11] tM Bnechelemt eommoncfecit 



Clcmentit [protr. p.24P.] nbl 



' ■ -■ . 47 



•4 



-r 



neoessitas inter illiuD Dionytiiimqiia interoedaty oerto emi ikmi poese 
^ oonMntaDoaiD eett tamen praeter Libemm Iotis ot Proecrpinee 
filinm [Gia 1. a f 58. Diodor. m 68, 1. im 4, 1] OrpUois debi- 
tnin Oioeronis *Liber qnartni Ioto et Lnnn nntne oni eacn 
Orpbioa pntantnr confici' ad Dionysii Baccbnm altemm a Libyia 
oonetitntam qnadrat [m 7i, 1]: wv H isiisQOP ffomp H^ Yot^ 
T^ ^lrJtx"'^ Jd Y$v6ftsivp fiamkitaiu fiiv r^^ Alyvnwv^ icanxdtEi^ 
ds rac TsksmiQ — •aepissime enim lo ad Lnnam refertnr — et 
tertine • • . • oni Sabazia ennt inetitnta alteri Dionyeii Bacobo 
Oraeoo eatis similis eese yidetnr [im 4, 1] r^ hii nmv SaifiaQ^ 
ivo^ofyfiivw. Deinde fabnlaram de Bacobo Indioo inde ab Alezan- 
dro Magno Tolgatamm natnram atqne indolem boc looo fnae ez- 
ponere non ficet: boo nnam adnotari TeUm Dionysii Baocbnic illnm 
Teterrimnm apud Indoe natam atqae edacatam, caius praeter Scjto- 
braebionem onns quantnm scio Pbilostratns [vit. ApoU. II 9] men- 
tionem fecit, adcnrate a Bacobo Oraeco qaem totam orbem terra* * 
mm penragatam Indiam qnoqne domuisse plarimi poetae eoripto^ 
resqae tradidere, disceraendnm eese. Deniqne ne bio qnidem Pin* 
dari desont vestigia [of. snpra p. 20 sq.] : illins enlm eet Torilo» 
qnium qnod apnd Diodomm extat nominis Dionysi*), neqne eeio 

^ ntram eo an Neoptolemo Pario ') anctore Scytobracbio Baocbaa 

pomoram oaltum inyenisse tradiderit. Neoptolemnm scboL ApolMI 
899 inxta Nanpaoticoram poetam et Pberecydam commemorari oerte 
non neglegatur, 

At Dionysins non satis babnit de Baocbis Oraecoram Indo* 
. ram Libynm dispntare sed etiam Osirin Aegyptinm adiunxit. Ibi 

^^ enim redit Baccbns Nysae edncatns [I 15,6]: ysvia&ai ii xni ^ 

loy&o(fyov tov ^Ociqiv ml XQoup^vm fiiv tij^ iviatfiovog jiQufiUtQ h 
Nvag nkfjfdov Alyvntov Jih^ tvm naUa wd t^v nQogiffOQlav bk»» 
nagik xoIq 'EXkffiiv an6 n fotf naiQbQ Koi tov T6nov ^i^rvoov pst^ ; 
ovofiaa&ivttt et cenresiae inTontor ab nniversis bominibus pro deo 
"^ ./ babitus [l 20, 8] : likoQ ii tiv ^Oaifiv Twlaav tijv obeiyii^r inA- \ 
96vta tiv xoivhv fiiov toig ^fiSQOitumQ^ KOQnoig sisQyst^aas* sl it 
tig XfiQa Tit qnn^ tfjq ifinikov fi^ itQogS^tOf AAkSqei li Intij; 



V 



1) Cf. Lobeok. Aglaopb. I p. 647 sq. 

9) Cf. £t M. p. 977, 89 ... ol ^l Ani toS Jtht Jml n|( Nias^ 
foS Sqovc ivofiia^ imX iv rovr^ fytwiil^ii lit liMuQot «lU ivsfQifi^ 

8) Cf. Pind. fr. 126Boeokb. Athen. m p,89I>: Nwnriktfiot ^ i 
nuQjiavoc iv t^Jiowamdi mcI mitoi tatoQiims vnh^ioviaov svQS^inm 
tmv fiiiiMV ua^^tQ mA tmv cUieir lutQo^iQimv. ot p.780«^v mm - ..( 



Mgt9ilQ Mmamadofuvow nSjfia lun6fibvov av noXi t^ ntgl rw' 

Jbfw 9vfaXaQ u tud iwafisio^' InavsK&ona 4* sl^ x^v Alyvniop 

mmanmofilaai iwga u navn^Mev t& XQdnom ml AaTb fjiiyedog 

iwr 9iefffBMW¥ avfinsqxanifiiv^v Xaficlv naQ& n&m Ti}r u&amalav ' ; ^> 

wal n)r ta^ tolg oigavlotg nfi^p, Neqae alio connlio illio Otiris 

«tui asM dieitiir [1 17, 1]: v&y H T)ai^r Xiyovaiv Sonfg evBQym" 

Kor trm nai ^piXiiolSoP atQai6ntd6v fiiya avatijaaadai Accroov/ucror 

insk^mp Snaaap ri}r obtovfiipfpf xai itSttfiu thyipog twp ap^Qtinwp 

vljp ta iqg ofinikov ifvtslap xai t6p anofop tov u nvgipov uul x^- 

91p9» uafnoS. inoXufifidpmp y&Q aitip Sn naiaag Tffg AyQiittjtog 

10VC iu^Qiinofvq ml Aatt^ 4f^(f^ finaXafistp noifjauQ tifitvp i9a* 

vJmv taC^iBtm diA r) fiiyt^og t^ tisQysalag atqae Bacchas Libyoas 

[ni 70, 8]: fiovXfj^^pai t^ yipa nSr ip9Q(inwp fistaiovpui nSr . 

Mnw 9VQ9i§idvuip iknlaupta Acl vi fiiysdog t^q svsQysalag taOupatwp 

iivSmi9iu n/uSr. Dentqae Masaram Satyroramqae eomitatu adsoito 

eDmii bilaritaa et diligons artiam masioaram caltas Osiri adiri- 

baitnr [1 18] qaae Ghraeei Bacohi propria faiaae ferantar [IIII 4. 5]. 

Quae irero et I 24 et III 74 inter plarei Heronles et Bacchos di- 

■erimiiia atataantnri etai altero looo duo altero tree Hercoles distin- 

.gnmitiir, paoca tamen adeo propria ezhibent nt ex diyersis aactoribas 

ea deaompta eeee non poMim non negare. An oasn adcidit at . 

ntnibiqae Hcreales Aegyptiai solam alteram colamnam in ora Li- 

bjrca statoiiae ferretnr toI qua ratione Heronles Oraecns interfaiMO ' 

negatnr deoram Oigantamquo pugnae qnippe qnae belli Troiani 

temporibna non qnadrareti eadem JBaoohi parentee Titanibas aequa- 

lee Ibine redargueretar? Neque obsiat qaod apad Aegyptios non 

tribni iod ono Baccho toI Osiri etatnto oeteri a Oraecis ficti esse 

dieantar, eed hano qaoqae opinionem a Dionysio relatam fiiiiie 

Diodori loeo probatnr [m 63, 2 cf. 62,2]: moi fisp yuQ Spu nai 

fiy si^iir inoifalpopm yifpiodm top u xttmdii/^rm ti «ati t&Q 

siwamiiaq wd avyxofuduQ tiSp l^vXlwwp naXovfiipwp xuQnwp kuI top 

ctQanvadfiS^ iid nSauptijpoUovfiiftiPp su ^ tbv t& fivatiJQia «al 

tAq ttXnig nii fiaigfllag Ag/ffrpdfUPOP^ et dooamentii qoae de Br '.uhi 

«ita altlndii oitendi eolita oiio illo loeo dioantar, Kbro primo 

oppoid ▼idetori talia oom Teetigia ezpeditionii ab Oiiri in Indiam / . 



fteCao remanriiienty ab Indie nt libl 
\J^ ,Iam intellegitor qoomodoi 



dei genni rindiearent adhibita 
iGMitom rit nt Diodoroi quae 



m 



1) Or, mai ft ittma^m ih nuf 'MoTc fiijCQt rov pvp roV rc 
ip ^ avpifiij ^yspioHu foi^ ^r Mok nQociiyoQiut nolimp in^ uirov ' ^ 

k t^ tSiP '^fyvl»Qtm» iiulsntopp utA woUm htQU itufiipttp ittoloyu 

■■.- • . \ \ - • '-'V- f ■•*::;^--v. ■•:■" 

•11/ * I ' M v N. - 



40 



N 



prinur libro de uno ilTo Osiri yiiis pomommqiie ealtore dixemt, 
, eadem qoarti libri initiOi nbi Baocbo Indioo omiaso benefidiim illnd 
filio vindicabat [ef. snpra^ p, 43], interpolaret: 

Jx ^ ii6f7 iina,4 

fiSfiv^o9^m a jifg Nvoiji xai tip notrpijy wd lAy ^fitifop dc yov- 
iy •loiQ vfzvoiQ 8n ns^ v^v Aiyvjmv yi* toi^ fioQtVQ^OM iv xxSq 
yovsv^ iv fSl^ liyHi vfivotg Iv oIq Uyu* 

'\, . sott ii nq Nvofi ^<*<oy Sqoq &v9iov vhj mm ii nq Nvmi ini. 
ttfuoti 0oivlinjg oxjsihv AVyvTmw (oawv. XQoxpivia i* aiMv vnl 

^'^ ' ^ ' $ig€Tijv (T avrifv yhviodm <pad fi^ £^- viav Wfi(fwv iv rg Niog 

nSiov negl t^v Ntfoav nal^ r^y natBQya' fpadv oiQitijv tov oSvov 
dav toij tavtfKQ naQnod nQogBfuvoijoavta YBvio9m nal ti^v gwtslav 
'. nQWtov oivtp xQi^oaodai xal iiia^at toi>Q Ado^ njc ofinikov toiq 
Skkovg avdQOfnovg tijv n ijpvtslav t^ itvdQmnovQ, 
' ifiniXov icai t^v XQV^^ ^ olvovnaltijv 

^jjO^ ^ ovyKOfui^v avtov nai ti^Qtioiv, 

. Hot versas et pleniores qnidem altero quoqne loco nbi qnae patriae 
Baccbi in Oraecia ferebantur oomponit, Dionyeina adfert [IH 66] 
neque ex alius auctorttate eoa eoholio Apoll. II 1211 inBertoe eue 
patavorim. Neque solum inter Dionysii libroe Argonautica a oom- 

L- montatore Apolloniano adhibita esse Amazonicomm locns acfaoL 

II 965 servatueO documento est. Qupd vero et in •choliia et 
apud Diodorum Aegyptios propter Mili aquam salubrem et geni- 
talem inter omnef gentes primot e terra exortos eese Tbebaaqne 
urbem vetuttisaimam condidiase slmillimie qnidem^TerUe narra- 
tur *), baeo certa Scytobrachionis vestigia dicere nbn auderem niti 



TiKftiiQta'' rJ}c noQ^ ^lvdoU yiviattas ei I 10, 7 Mtiom ^i Mtd noUis omt 

iXfyaf iv 'iviots iv alf Moi Nvoav ovoftdaai fovlofievov fivtifi^ov ojroif- 

. ntiv ixt(vfii arcr^* ^y iiQafpri Mor* uityvnrov, ipvttvooi ik ntA mttop iv 

Tj noQ^ *Moi^ NvOjii xal imfiivtiv tovto t6 (pvrov iv itttiv^ f^ov^ r^ 

' «. V ron^ T&v Tt nata r^y *ivdixfpf xal Tfiv ofiOQOv x^^^* nollik ik mrl 

. akXa otifitTa Trjf iavrov noQovoiaq anoltXotnivoi jror* inttvffv tt(p x^h^ 

ii* iv nQoax^ivtaf Tovq fittaytvtofiQOvt Tmv *ivimv afnpiofiiiT^m roS 

&tov Xiyovrat *ivi6v ttvai Th yivoq, 

1) .Quis Dionyrios lohoL II 004 nna Qum Ariitodemo et Ctiiaieho 
commemoretor non oonstat: neaoio an de Dionytio a Ptolemaeo Phila> 

^ delpho onm Megasthene ad Indot xniNO oogitandtim lit oL Plin. YI68. 

2) Cf. lohoL im 262 rev^ AlyvnTiovt noXXoi naXmotarovs thmt 
tpaotv,*iiQ6ioT0( iX t^vyiBig, Mwffific ik iv nQW^ jHyvntiOMmp nmX 

^ . ^ uiinv iv nQmT^ tmv nQh^ t^ip fitiTiQa ttal Xvmaoot ip S romxQm-' 
(ffixuv r^ *jiaias navrtav aQxtuoTarovt jiiyvnriot^ thfoi tpaotp" mik Nv 

■'..•'• 4 .' 



60 

•pod Diodonnn [1 19] Fromethei fabnlae ^ndem fore rationem 
pmgmaticMn atqae qnae sohol. ApoU. II 1248 Agroeta anctoro . 
eKponta sit, adhiberi animad?erterem ^) neqne Leonie Bchol. Iin 262 
eoBiiiiemorati plnra Toetigia repperiMO mihi Tiderer. Qnalis hnins ^ 

aaetoria.liber inerit Lobeokini [Aglaopham. II p. 1000] oognorit, ^ 
modo Angnstini looo ibi adlato [d. oiv. dei VIII 5] addas Tatian. 
or. adr. Graee. 44. Angnttin. de cons. eyang. I 28 [t. IIII p. 18 
ed. Boned. 8. Manr.]. ^olim hoo urgere qnod Isidem, qnam Oraeoi 
^^§amfa nominaTerinti primam frngee xepperisse tradidit etsi qnae 
de Iiae re Clemens [Strom. I p. 382 P.] et Tertnllianns [de coron, 
mil. 7] dicnnt Diodoreia optime qnadrant, sed mnlto grarine est 
Mevonrinm eoneiliarinm eodem anctore apnd Angnstinnm comme- 



niyM^ ifl Uymv h Alyinrffi ngmiw xtia9^t noltp S^fiitg xai aMt 

€Vfi^pmPit ff ^Aqx^M^XV ^^ ^^^ MtTovofiMimc* Joxc» Ji nQwop S^f^v 

jMcr* Afyvntov Mna^vtu Sg ^iyin StvttyoQnf iv S XQovfov, "innvf Jk y 

fovc Aiyvntiovc nQwovt inoxiffna(Htt rifc rov a^Qog XQttana( xnl yovifiti» 

ntrov tHnu to ? ov Ntilov vJmQ cum Diodor. I 10, 1 : ipttal toiwv At' 

yintiot xar& tiiv i^ aQx^ tmv oXmv yivtatv nQtitovs iiv^tanovt y€via&t(t 

wmrm wtiv Atyvntav ^iti ri tiiv tvxQaaiav r{( /<ic^( ^ttl dia t^v tf^vaiv 

" rov NtHov. toStov yoQ noliyovov ovta xal tng tQotpat ahotpvti^ naQt* 

j[ifttmv ,^img iatQitpiiv ta (imoyovvi^ivta 8 i* tovtov J' tlvai if>a^ 

9§Qop Sn attta tiiv i^ oQxit tov aoafAov aiataaiv tfjc yiif ivaQotov aric- 
^itntioiiQ fMoitat* av ia^i tiiv yivtaiv tttv av&Qtiniav i} arar* Afyvntov 
gtiQtt •« • .6 rf; yaQ nttQn roTf nlXoit inoftfiQittf tip naQ* airofc yivo* ' . 
/i/ff» tmvftmtt fitytiatis ilxos ivxQototatpv ytviatha tov aiQa nQoi r^ .... 
it «pjtV ^**^ navrmv (moyoviav, ,^ 

1) Yel ex omnibnf qnae adhnc de Diodori primis Hbrit ditputata f' ' ' 
sant eum Agroetae librot non intpexiate adpftret neque cl. tchoL Apoll. i ' \ 
IIII 1896:^X^r«v ^k iv f Atpvnmv tpnat ftii ftijXaf AXXit nQofiata irnA- . ^ 

JUer» i XQ^^ Avoftua^. ix^iv dk tama notftiva ayQiov Sv (Sia ro Av^' l'. 
ptMQoiw AQoaavra mvoftaa^' Atlantit &bnlat a Diodoro renim ab Her- t ; 
eule gettarum enarrationi interpolatat \UJ1 26. 27 cf. imprimit 28, 2. 8 
ei 27, 1] Didnytii Argonautidt rindicaredubito quibut de Libya actnm 
eete e Diodo^. IIII 66,9 elnoet Hinc tamen fabukt Atlanticat teriii 
lafari [e. 66—61] Dionjtii ette, id quoJ( coniecit Sieroka [L c p. 2], mit " 
nime teqnitur neque mnltnm yalet quod Atlantcm. mundi et tphaerae , "^ 
caelettianoUtiamHeronlitradiditte[£^od.Iin27,4of.m60,2.] Hero* \ 
doms anetor apnd Qem. AL ttrom. 11 p. 860 P. adforturi Atlant enim 
etlraiOBii4e infentor poitPotidoiiinmJnt monuitVtenerut, taepe occur- 
vit: Oe. Tute. Y 8, a Yerg. Aen. J 741 cum Serrio, Plin. II 81. YII 208. . 
tam.YnU 20, 8. tkert Diog. I I. Senr. Aen. JUI 246. Amob. ad?. nat 

^n 66. aeboi Ap. Ahod. np 264, CJt Oortieni de Potidonio Rhodio diti. . "'■ 



1878 p,JV * 









61 

monirl [d. oiy. dei VIII 27]: 'nam de bido Qzore OsiriB Aegyptia 

dea et de parentibi» eomm qoi omnee regee fiuBse ■eribnntiir, 

quibue parentibns rais illa onm Bacrifioaret inyenit bordei BOgetem 

rrs -. ■ atqne inde spioas marito regi et eius connliarioMeronrio demon- 

, etrayity nnde eandem et Cererem yolnnt, quae et quanta malwnon 

. a poetie sed mystiois eorum literis mandata sintt eiout Leone 

sacerdote prodente ad Olympiadem matrem eoribit Alezander, l^gaat 

qni yolunt yel poBsunt' et aperte apnd Diodorum inyeniri [1 16, 2] 

Ku&ilov a wvg Ttsgl tiy "Doi^v tovrop fy^nug t^foyQOfifiaTia 

&na¥^ ainaf iiQoqfiivaxoivoiiad-m xai ftdkuna XQ^^^ ^ lovsov 

avfifiovXla of. 17, 8. Quae yero MtnuduB Feliz eeryayit [e. 21]: 

^AIezander ille Magnus insigni yolumine ad matrem Buam ■eripsit 

'metu Buae poteetatiB proditum Bibi de diiB bominibuB a Baoerdote 

Booretum: lUio Voloanum facit omnium principem et poetea Iotui 

gentcm', ita apud Diodorum ^) redeunt ut alii fabulae quae int^^ra 

apud Plutarchum [de Ib. et Oeir. 12] eztat, parum apte interpo- 

lentur. Illic enim quinque dei OBiriB IbIb Typho ApoUo Venus ex 

Satumo et Rhea geniti obbo feruntnr; DiodoruB loye et Innone 

' interpolHtiB fabulae argumentum eonfudit et parum olare per^^t 

[I 13, 4] ^x dc toiiTfap yeviad-m nivn AmhS(. Quae yero infirm 

narrantur LeoniB fabula niti docot I 15, 8. 

Ea igitur ratione ubub Boriptor iste yolgatae de diie opinio* 
nee atque omnem religionem tollebat ot regum de genere hnmano 
bene roeritorum memoriiB pie poBt mortee ouItiB diyinoB ritus atqne 
BuperBtitioncB Beneim et pedetemptim increbuiBBO oontenderet*) hnine- 



1) 1 18,8 lyiM ^k ttSy ItQiuv tpaol nQtkov^^HfpmOtov fimttliiHUu 
. . . i fitrii ^k Tttvra tov Kqovov Sq^ xtA yiifiavta tiiv adtXtf-iiP *Miy 

• ytvv^om xata fiiv nvag ttSv fiv9ol6yiav^OoiQtv mcI Vcriy, natk 6k tov^ srie/- ^ 
ffroiv /l(a tt xai^ilQav otg J»' oQtfiiv fiaoiltvoat toB avfinavros nwffttw, 
No propter Voloani ignis repertoriB regnom de Manetbo oogitetur, oV- 
stant quae oetera et prorsus diyerta ez einB libriB Bcryata eont cf. 
FHO U p.626iq. 

2) Qoae Plutarchui [d. Is. ot Otir. 18] tradit: fiaatltvovt» J» 
^OaiQiv Atyvntiovs ftkv tv&vc anoQov ^i^v nak ^i^QttUovs anttllitiu jmt^ 
^roiic tt ^tiiavta MtA vofiovt ^ifitvov avtots »ak Hovg Matmna.tififhr 
SattQov ^l ytiv naaav' ^fHQoifitvov intlMv ilaxiata fikp Snlmv ^cif 
^ivta^ nti^ci 6k tohs nUtatovg xol Xiytf fitt* ^^c ittA naaiis fiovtNat^g 
Myofiivovs nQotayofitvov o&tv "SXXiiat SoSat /liovva^ thv avtop ohnut 
adeo oum Diodoreii liidii et Oiirii laudibui oonoinQnt •*- legae modo 1 14^ 1 
nQwav fikv yhQ nawtai t^t iXX^Xotpayidt to tmv av^Qtinmv fivof t vQ om ' 
OTng filv^taidog tiv tt rov nvQov tttA ttic »Qt9^iwaQnivv^i*4jom n 



-> 



« . . 

qpm Mnientiiie doouiiieDtiim qnam ribi finzit Aegyptaoram antiquis- 

nmMi Jiiitoriam proponere^ Quibnt nifail est qaod Scytobrachioni 

grmtina fnlsie pnteturi atque ex Ikms et aliit einsmodi anotoribuB 

Aegjf^mB dtf Otiri fabnlas enm eongeMiBee exiBtimaverim qnae . , ^ 

apod Diodomm in oapp. 14—20 legnntnr. Neqne tdo an eapp. 

21 ei 22 mala illa myttica Iridi adflicta lateant: rimiliter enim 

stqiia apnd Augnttinnm [d. riy. dri 7111 27]| Tolgi jfabnlit sacer* 

dotom eeereta obponnntnr [a 21, I]: vdSp i* Ugiwv usqI t^q X)a^ 

fiSog ttikBVT^g Q a(gxttl(ap h inoQQijtiHg noQSihffpimv rw XQ^^ 

mni mndfifi Aa nmw dg wvq nfXkovq. i^vtx^vtu ih amndfievoy. 

Certo eapp. 28 et 24 Dionyrio yindicantnr; alternm enim tnpra [p. 48] 

cam Scjtobraebionit de Baccho Libyco ditpntatione compara- 

tmn eet: qno yero consilio hoc loco duo Hercnlet diBtingnuntur 

aU vt in Baecho rimilet rationet obtinere probetnr? Praeterea 

CK oumerit a 28^ 1 inter te obpotitit alter corte ad ea quae 

c 24, 2 dicuntnr tpeetat: An* iitslvt/; fjiiv y&Q nuQ* jilyvnjioiq In; ^S 

tuaa^dfi$ur9m nkdm x&v fivQlwv. — Pottremo adnoto Ijeonit * 

Indi parentibnt tacrifioanti Enhemeri Io?em Oaelo aTo hbttiam 

mimdiantem tttit qnadrare [of. Lact. diT. intt. I llj: idem Inp- 

piter illie hominet came hnmana Tetci Tetat [1. c. o. 1 8] et tiqnit 

qoid noTi inTenittet enm hoo tibi ottendere inbet [I. c. 11], quocnm 

IModorta oomponat [I 15, 4]: nQonfiSa&m di noQa xm ^OalQiii xal 

^ ImA inig iAq t^x^ av9VQta»ovaMg ^ fu^oisvovmg n viv XQ^" 



tM^if imvofnaafiivov zak ti(v toirw xartQyaatttv ttSv xaQnnv ffHmg 
ft9tmHa9m «iicyroc tiiv tQOif^iiv Jia r< r^i^ ^doviiv tij^ tpiattas twv tvQi' 
Mvrmv Mcl M t6 ffmtvia&at avfnpiQov vnoQ/ttv an4x'a9at. tiji xat^ 

mUJtJilmv t$fiotfiios 8 &itvat H tf^aat. Mal vofiovg ti^v ^faiv xad^ otfg 

mi l i lo i t Mivm tmn av^Qunovs to iixaiov xal t^s a^iofiov piac xa^ 

9PQ§mcnaiaaa9ai irn ror ano tijt ttfiUQiag tp6pav .... 16, 8, UQiaaa^t 

4k mA Uqov riir yavtmfv Jto^ ti irarl "ffQaf a^oloyov t^ ti fnyi&a imrl 

Tf loffir j nolvtil^q xai vaohf x^^ .^^' ^'^^ . • . . . 4 mraaxiva' 

. «n ik jmI V^ allmv ^imv tmv nQoiiQ^fiivtav vaovc XQ^^ ^ 

hmat^ tifias anavHfiai xak' Motaat^atu tovg intfnlofiivovg hQiU .... 18, 4 

dvm yoQ tov "OatQiV tptloyilmta ti aral';|fiK^(?oiTii fiovatxj vtA jjfo^c'. • • 6 

oir ymQ nolifitMov ihm ror ''OtfiQtv twik naQata^itt awiataa&oi miI » y- 

iivavg Sti/navtof iOvovs tk ^iov akbiixofiivojif it& tas ivtQyiaiag-^ 

oi ail eoadem anetorem refertnda ett# Tideantor. Ynde tamen Plutar- 

ehnt haee tnmpterit Tereor nt eruttnr, etri in illo libelio tat mnltit 

loeit enm Diodpib eontentit: non enim it ett toriptor apud quem 

^tiSa'ad ^^mm omtiia ex nna et eerta eanta repetanturp ted tua ouint» 

^ qne lori ralio diligentitrime esqnirenda ett Cetemm. Oririt merita 

TiMlntiiie^BDtel [I 7» 27 tq^]. 



M 



1-/ 






#' 






Jp 



/imr, Sed Enhemeri tota rmtio diTerm liiit: iMii enini post 

* moitee prineipilnie a' progenie et peeteritnte diTinoe honorei adiri- 

bntoe oeee oontendit, eed lorem ipenm fiuin eibi conetitni inben- 

Jy tem fiustO- 

Omnia Tero Aegyptiomm tlieolognmenn ne Diodome ez Sey^ 
tobracbione eumpeiBee etatnatnr enmmopere oeTendnm est. A Leoiiie 
enim sententia qna regee olim cnm firogee inTenieeent urbee oon- 
didieeent moree oonetitnieeent pro diia habitoe oeee ezpoeuerat» 
prorene dieoeeeit oum a 43 antiqnie temporibne Aegyptioe herbin 
paliiBtribns et piedbne Toe^ eolitoe fuieee, poetea demnm Menamv 
qni primne poet deoe regnaret, frngibne inventie enltiorem ▼itam 
institnieee narravit *). lidem anctori iUam de Tnephaohtho Boceho- 
ridie patre hietoriohuni 'quae infra eeqoitnr [o. 45, 1. 2] et apod 
Plutarehnm qnoque [dele. etOeir. 8]legitiir, deheri adparet Atqai 
Hecataenm Abderitam Alezino philoeopho anotore eam narraeee ex 
Athenaeo iconetat [X p. 418 £]: AlyvmipvQ d* ^Bfannibg iqmfaywg 
ifoitdr dim xvXk^anag io^iovTog^ xigdi XQidug elg mniv xaiaXioytu^*^ 
Aa latm $ud *AXsl§[vog ip t^ negl ama^xda^ Bjp^ H^H^ 'Rf^^Vn 
ns/jff^^M -AvBontxpQiv tud -Ap naxiQa aimv Ns^afiiy ^). Adcednnt 
graviora. Quo enim looo Diodorue ee Heoataeum eeqni ipee dioit 
[1 46, 8], haeo adiecit: ov fiovoy d* oi xa^ AtyvfOOP Ugu^ & -nSv 
' '- ipaygatpdfv tamgovoiv, akXu xai noXkol rtop *Ekk^mv ttS» naQOr 
fiaXormr fiiv dg' xag &^fiag inl Ilmkefialov toit Aiyov, ovym^* 
fiivwv a Tug Alyvnnaxag iovo^/ci^, wp ian xai 'BKomto^ ovfKfWvavci 
joiQ igp ^fiwp slQ^ivoi^ Qoodsi et in iie quae praeoedunt [o. 46^ 7] 
et altero loco [o. 81,7] Ptolemaei Lagi tempora et eacerdotDm 
annalee nna oommemorantnr, non temere opinor oondnditnr nlii* 



1) Cf. Lactant. 1. a c. 22 et Plutarch. d. fs. et Osir. 22: noUmp 
* ' / 6k TOtovrufP ItyofttPwp Mtd detxpvfiipttp ol fikp oiofiiPW patuliwp tavrm 

,'• «ftl jVQAwtap J*' iiQetfiP uniQipiQodaap $ dvpufup a^imfia 5 ^ofav ♦fot^ 

-. /S W intyQu^lfitfiipufp^ 'i7ttt x^^^^f^^^^y ^^'X'"^ 'W^ *** ni^ Snpa fud 
*- " fiiyaXa Jiafiptifiopivia^t (^atif fikp anoSQaau rw.ioyoM ;pp«wia «ri. 
. G. 28 ipsam Eohemerum nominai. 

2) Vel ipfle haec inter se obpotait [o. 43,6]: fuA toirmp tnp 
iVQiatp joi fiip itf trip ^fatp iputpiQOvaiP^ oi ik ii( ttpa tmp nahump 
paatlitop top opofiitCofiiPop Mfipop, . 

8) Varie nomen fcripium est: apad Plutarchum legitar TixPanrit, 

Rectifsime ^ro !kXiStc Meinekiut [anaL crit ad Athen. p. 18^ iMhfot 

reposait; optime ad eiat de autuQXii^ librum adhibitam qoadrat qnod 

^ ; Abd^riU at,caemente [Strom. II p. 49?) tihtt avraQMitaP eiee etatoieie 

'• '.'' '■ dieitar^ ' ■:.*"'• ; 



64 

oumqa* UgQp illftrum aifayQWfkay meiitto factn sit, certa Hecataei> 
Twtiipa eztare'). Atqoi loeo illi de qao modo di8pataTr[o. 43, 6], 
baoe adieota mint: Ao wd lo nakmhv nagadUoad-ai ra^ fiaaiXelag 
fgil toiQ ixyopotg mw Ag^iymp aXka toig nUSatu^ xal fiiyujm tb 
mlijl^og svt^ynovmp da nQoxaktovfiimp twv ap&gwmop xoig i(p^ 
hmmp fiamXmg hd t^p iohp^p svsQysalap sire xal xai' «Ai/- 
^ctar |y xalg IsQalg ccra/po^a?^ ovrw naQsiXfiqtorwp. 

Omnino totam alteriaB libri primi partis initiam ex Hecataeo 
deeomptam ene Tidetar. Praeter oapp. 43 et 45, 1 • 2. amplam 
et eopiosam Thebaram descriptionom [c. 46, 4 — 7.46] ei yindioo 
qaippe quemThebas profectam esseDiodoras ipse dicat [c. 46^8]; 
neqae qai in medio positni est regnoram catalogam [c 44] aliunde 
floziase ItQoi apayQatjpul io clausala [§4] commomorAtae')^pro- 
dant^ Atqae annis qaoi dii seroideiqae et homines asqae ad Dio- 
dori aetatem io Aegypto regnasse hpo looo dicantnr, oompatatii 
Tiginti triom miliam annornm namen» ^fficitar qai sapra . ad 
temporia ipatiam inter Solii regoam et Alexandri in Aiiam ti*an- 
giiam intercodeni rofertar [o. 26^ l]: o! d- leQslg xwpAlyvnxlwp v&y 
XQOPOP ani x^g *HXtov fiamXdag avXXoyt^OfitPOi fii/jQ^ r^$ !^Xc^y- 
Sqov iiafiaasiag dg t^p \tialap g^adp vndQy&p itfap fioXuna mog 
Aia§iVQiwp xal ijpic^Aioir, altero looo [o. 23, 1] Dionyiii namero 
[cf. rapra p. 62] opponi: shtu dc In^ ^^ooiii' anb X)olQiiog xal 
Tbidog Sug r^ig ^jiki^piQov fiaatXslag wv xrlaapzog ip Alyvniw x^p 
imwpvfiop avwov nohp tiX&Iw twp fMVQtwp^ &g (T iMOt yQaqiovai^ 



■ fy 



r^ 



. 1) Addi plaoet Plut d. Is. et Osir. 6: ol J^ fiaaiUTs xai fttTQti" ' ^ 

to9 Mntpop i»-tmp UQmP yQafifiatmv^ t&s 'Exaraiog laxoQfitiV; liQtif ' \ » < ; ' 
owtit cL Diodor. I 70, 11. Hand improbabiliter Muellorus [FHG It . >' 
p. 891] Diodomm prae oeteris Hecataeum ducem sibi elegisso ooniecit: ' -^ / 
eqaidem satii habeo praeteroundo adnotasse yerba quae c. 81,0, ubi de 
Acgypti inoolarom multitudine Hecataeo auctore disputari mo^o pro- ^ . 
boriy dansolim fiununt: ito ttA tovt ftQx^ovt paaiUTs laxoQovat. xata 
t^P Afyvntop ilQya ftiyala mil davfiatna ita tfjg noXvxitQiag ttxxaativa^ 
0mptmf §t9amxa tTjs iatmSv ioitif antikfmtP vnofivifitna iufra ubi de 
piieroram^edncatione sermo est [aSO, 6J iterum l^, et iudicii adpara* 
inm in Osyibandyae lepalcro [o. 48, 6] depictum — triginta iudices, unum 
iUttBi oQxiifxaafip Tcritatis i^mbolo ornatum libros legum adpositos — / 
Ineo omnia qno looo Aegyptiorum iudicia desoribnntor [o. 76, 8^], redire. 
2} jrff^ mp ^navtmv pt ftiv liQiTg ilxQP ttpayQatpax ip toTf tiQafs 
ftflwti» ^almt& j^Qovmi^ ecl xofg diaiixotg naQttMofiivas ojr^A/xof 
InMW iSv famiiiifattvtmf iyinto ttf fiiyi^u MtA indSoi ric tf tpvau ,r^ 

tnA tA M^it toue Uiovc''XQo9ovg iMaipnQttx^ivttt» > 



-i 



%• 



■-<-.. 



66 

Pgaxv Xsinomm, xwp iio^ivqiwv xul tQUF;i^Xlwy, Diodomm igitar non 
ipsam oompatationem illam regnoram nsqae ad soam aetatem de- 
duxisso adparet| sed qui compiatationis terminas ab Hecataeo quidem 
8ub Ptolemaeo primo florente apte poritnji erat Alezandri in Asiam 
tranBitus. yel potius Alezandria ooodita, inde a quo tempore Mace- 
donum in Aegypto regnum initiam oepit^), huno temei'e cum soa 
ipsiufl aotate commatayit. C. 2G igitnr quae de Aegyptiorum obro- 
nologia exponuntur Hecataei rant neque ido an eidem laidis deae 
naturam prorsue aliter ittque supfa Leone auctore desoriptaiii 
Yindicem : Hori postremum regnum diyioum utmbique [c. 25, 7 ei 
44, 1] commemoratur. Gur yero c. 44 regum non ex ipsie Aegyp- 
tiie sed ex ab^enis gentibus oriundorum anni numehiti sint, c 69 
explicatur: eam enim legum Aegyptiarum fuime praestantiam ui 
per plurima saecula in alienam potestatem non yenerint regno ab 
ingenuis fere semper obtento. Neque minus ei conrilio quo Ho- 
cataeua usus esse yidetur nt res Aegyptiacas cum Oraecia compa- 
raret, oomparatas quam summis laudibus extoUeret, apta ■uni 
qnae iUic adiciuntiir [69,4]: tudnBQ yoQ r^c X^H^ ^ naXmip 
dvgBmfiaxav loig l^rotg oiknig • • . Ofnag ioTUvttav dg avr^v naQofiu^ 
Xelv xiiv /liiy aQxatovuMv X)Qffwg koI i noujr^g ^fajQogf v&p H 
furaysvtatsQUv akXoi u nXelovg »al TIv^yoQag i Sdfuog^ tn ii 
SoXiav i vofio^rfiQ, /Boo qua ratione expoBuerit, Diodori catalogo 
Graecorum in Aegyptum profectorum [o. 96 — 98] demonatratur, 
quippe ubi omnes ,iUi itorum oommemorentur cetrtnmque Hecataei 
Yostigium sacerdotum annales [c. 96, 2] adpareant Atqui nt illic 
HomeruB Helenao venenomm Veneric aureae lovis lunonisque amomm 
notitiam ab AegypUis accepisse fertur [o. 97, 7—9], ita supra [e. 12, 
lOj vere^sHomerici [^485Rq.]: 

xal T8 dwl ^ipoiiHv iofxdisg aXXoianoSoi '.'■ ' 
navToioi xsXi^ovag imoiQWfok» n^XaffM/g 
AvdQ(inwv vfiQiv xs Kal svvofiiriv IgoQ^ivxfg 
cum Aegyptiorum de deorum symbolifl opinione confemntur: in- 
primis haeo Yerb\ animadverti. velim:^xat xiv Tnupiiv (K «Ig 
^iyvnvov naQafiaXdvxa »al fjisxaaxivta naQii xwv tsQiwv t&v rmov- 
twv Xiywv ^¥al nov xaro x^v nolrfKv xh nQO&QtifAivov cSg pvpfiB^ 
vov. Hecataei -vero narrationi c 18, 4 ea quae rapra Leooi vin« 



1) Male Diodofttt hoo ad Scytobraohionic numerum rettolit oai 
ut doorum cum Gigantibus pugnam mnltic annis ante beUnm Troii^ 
^. num adc,idiM0 demonttraret, adeo certo tormino coiittitato taiiiiBie 

- opuB eetet.. .. - ■••'•..'•:■:.• 






• se • • . 

i ■ . 

didt» sant iiiBeii yel inde aflparet qnod ibi 8ol a qno b. 26 re^^nm^ 
anni Gompatantnrf primns rognasse dieitur [13,2] et in ixs quao . 
praecedaDty Sol et Lnna' summi dei ab Aegyptiis Osiris ot Isis 
idpeUaii [o. 11] optime ad Laertii Diogenis looum [I 10] qnadrant A 

ubi fa Uooataeo anotore Aegyptiomm philoeophiam refert ')• Atquo 
ne hie qnidem Homeri et Orphei testimonia desunt: ef. o. 1 1| 2. 3 '). 
12» 2. 4. 5. Ex Heoataeo igitur eam theologumenon partem qnae 
eapp. 11^18 ineet deeumptam Diodorus Dionyeianis interpoBuit -^ 
atque timt qnao ipsi ' Scytobrachionia orationi ex illo interpolasse - / 
fidoatiir. Conforantnr nominis Nili fiuTii ▼eriloquxa o. 19, 4 re« 
oenta oaro Nilei regti mentione o. 68, 1 ex saeerdotum annalibus 
petit» Tel iis qaao eapp. 12, 5 et 96, 7 de Oceano Homerico dispu- • 
tantor *)• Deinde deorum Osiris loyifl Volcani Cereris Oceani Mi« 
oenrae Ammonie nominum ▼eriloquiis si repatabitnr quantnm operae 
Heeataeas navaTorit ez ipsa Aegyptiornm lingua ezponendis ^), du- ' 
bitari opinor non lioet qnin hederae quoqae Osiridi sacrao Terilo* 

' qaiam [o. 17,4. 6]*) Hecataeo debeatar praesertim cum postrema * 
▼orba Sn§g mvg naXmoi^ xal if^ hsQtap qmtHv AA ^uXkdrmv nc- 

, mnftimu ijgf liiv ^AtffMv^ djk ^^vfclvriVf toi (T *ytn6XktaH r^v 
impptlP ngogkyfavn^ fjgf cT *A9fiv^ t^r ikoilav eiui scriptorii qui 
paolo sapra [c 16,2] Mereuriam non Minervam oleam invoniiso' 
tndiditi oase non posiint. 

Boitat at do Seytobrachionis libro qno bellam Troianum ^ 
traotaverat diipatetar. Hnno onim et Diodoros [III 66,6] *) re* 
neqno in loholiis HomoricSs dosunt quae illum oleantE. g. 
bibliotbooa I 9, 21, 4 ot Hygini fabnla XTIUI [of. sapra 



1/ 



. V • «. . ^ " ■*• • 



" '/. --^.i -'^ 



T 



1) Ocoog ^ ^hov.xai OiltiVfiv tov fAkv^Ooigtv, r^K ^*^IOiv moXov-, ^ -'' /\ 
ftiwnv. ■ i •;■ ' 

2) Noo colom Vertam exaoriptum Orphei ewe, sed etiam quae 
•eenotar Maorobiut docct [I 18, 22]. . 

8) Eadsm PluUrohui tradit [de Is. etOsir.S^]: otovTM Jk xnl ' 

y^^Qov m^niff fkil^ fio^ivto noff AlyoiiUtiV tiwQ iQxh^ onnvtmv *xttl 
yinotv J(9to9at, Heoatieo deberi quae praecodunt vorba: ^Xiov dk xol 
MLiv^v obx oQfutotv aUa nloiotg 6x^fioot xQ^f*^^^ ntQinliiv Ail ofviT'- » . 

wofttmm, ttiv wp* vyQov tQoipiiv auttiv Mok , yivtoiv adparet to FHG 11 
p. 888 tr^fii ^HQOMXiitoc xai ^Exatt^iif^ avaftfia votQ^v th itt daXAtuif . " 

flM» tov ^itoVf ouaifoiidH it ttvat vnoxvQtov, 

4) Cf. Diodor. I 11. \% Plot. d. Ii. et Osir. 9. 10. 
•* 5) Bodit apldd Pltttarohum do li. et Oiir. 87. 

8) Hoo quao' Dionyiio Milnio 8old|i adtribait 7^^»« Welokorui •)!^ 

[ep. OlroL I p.ip6j| rottnlit ' :. 






67 



r. 



p. 19, 22] Boholiuni /u 69 oooferas: * . .lotfor oJi^ ihv Oii^^a ^ioi^if- 

' oams o2 n«pi lor Vaoom jia^aJtovi^ vnoSia^ou nwg Sh dianlsikfiM^ 

t&g nXaYifTug iByofiimg nivQfig* i di JtnBV iitv titg*^gnvlag &nttX* 

J^ Xa$aai t9jq ngi^ adtbv igfi^g' &i9fKQ Si av¥&i^xa^ inayyHJiomu 

aivp Tovto ig&aai — evLm sclioUo Apoll. I 81.28 verba qiiae initio 

legantnr: dxovaag H Tuvr» o *Idaia¥ kiy» mS Xsl^yt xal aiw^ H 

XilQOiv - avvsxnifinH loifg ^fudiov^ — quae de Phlneo eeqnitnr nar- 

ratio: xoi iQdkk xbv Oivia mf^ov di& lavTriv iijy oliAxy* ^oir yikQ 

":*.'■' ncuiag in KXeonaTQo^ T^g BoQiov xal imyiifiag^) EvQVTiav diduKH^ 

avTOVQ TJ fifiTQVtA dwfiXti&iyTag nQbg avalQ$mv. Zeig ^ ;|faJlcjKi;mg 

Xiy» diTw noTSQOv fiovXtTai ino&avilp ^ tw/^ ysvia9m* i ii 

atQsttai fiij iQ&v Tiv fjjkiov* ^^^yaxnfoo^ ii i ^^bhog *^Qnvlag im" 

nifiTm ainTt alnvsg stnoxs fiiXXoi ia^tsiv avTOv AinQaaaov ififiiX^ 

Xovaat q^&oQdv nm ex fabnlis Heeiodea et Sophoolea mizta esse 

' tidetur [of. schol. Apoll. II 178. 181]. Praeterea oomponenda esso 

iV . pntayerim Boholl. H468 XsysTm Tiv^Iaaova fiST&Xfjg^jiQyovg iJSoxeJ- 

^^ Xavra i^ nQaTtarjj naadv *Y^4niXj] fuy^vat et sohoL ApoU. I 769, 

BchoL fi 124 et schoL ApolL IIII 828. Haeo tamen nt olare cx« 

plicentnr, longa de scholiomm Homericomm anctoritate et prae- 

oipne do hietoriarum illarnm rabscriptionibus dispntatione opua 

est qnae neqne huic libello apta erat neque instiiui omnino poteat 

prioBquam adcnratior oodids Tpwnleiani notitia propoaita mt. 

Dionysium Scytobrachionem aDionysio cydographo [cf. FHG 
II p. 9 sq.J diacernendum esse qul et primoB ot nnoB de hac ra 
docte et muliie disputavit Welckems [ep. OycL I p. 78] *) stataii. 



1) Nesoio num adferri lieeat •ohoL Soph. Ant..980 xara ii uvag 

Eido&iav ffiv Xadfiou adiltpiiv ^( aricl amoi ZoipoxX^^ finiftovtvtt iv 

TvftnaviaTois oL Anton. Lib. XXX JBido&iav rify EuQirov ^vyatiQa, Ce^ 

. terum in scholio Homerioo aliquid deetie cooaentaneum Oit quia Pbinei 

. oaeoitae praetermiititur. 

! -^ . . ^) Quam Hachtmannus sibi finxit opinionem foae Sieroka [L o. 

(- "-■ p. 9Bq.] rodarguit. Qdi praoteroa hoo profedt ut in quarto Diodori 

libro praotor Argonautica nulluro Diouyiii Testigium extare probarot 

[p. 26 Bq.]. MuelleruB a^tem [FHO l\ p. 10] quo iure Tcetiae in alle- ^** 

goriae Homericai Bcholiorum loeo uiui iit: 'XfiQovatv di slnov or^ 6 ^ 

^OSvaaitH TfikifiaxoQ latiQov ^v 'OfniQo^ ^ J^Xov in tov /^yov i7(po- a. 

vanfJov rov 'Ofi^v MaaKaXov 8; ^v rgirof Ani Kadfiov^^Ofi^Qog dk wi» ^^ 

raQrof, *0 BdftVQit «fl naXtv naXaiig jy taoj(Q6wt Xadfiov nannoiOQtpimg, . j|i 

^OQfpihi dk Mivinntic ^v vlof r^g 9afiVQtdoc ^vyarQit »&v oXXtiyoQtMmg l 

'^ rns sXaXXionvit vtos Xiynat ut Dionyiioc Mytilenaenm et Samium di* ^^ 

•Ungueret non intellego.'^ Pronapidam tertio poet Cadmum genere , T^^ 



.' •• 



n:/; 



> 



SoidM oonfiisiones in eiosmocll dispatatione abioiendas ease Welcke-^ 

ma ipao eoneeaait [p. 76]. Athenaei vero loco [XI p. 477 D ss 

p. 481 E] olii ^lographua Saiuina adpellaturi yereor ne uimiam 

aactoritfttia tribnator. Quantam enim Tetei*ea einamodi oognomina > 

variavorint dooamento annt e. g. Eahemeroa et Heaaeniua [Strabo 

I p.47. II p. 104. Aelian. y.h.IISl. Laotant diy. inat I 11] et 

Agrigentinna [Olem. Al. Protr. p. 20 P. as Amob. adv. nat. UII 20] 

at T^geatea [plao. philoa. I 7 p. 297 Diela.] dictua vel Athenael 

de Polemono locua [VI p. 284 D] : IlolefiWP yoifr i itn StifuoQ ij 

SxvMMOC M *A97ivqioi ivofiofifiSvoQ x^Q^ ^ ' Motptar^ ^HQa" 

aUiiiis liyH nam^&fiovfi€POQ iMviop lecij dn* Skktav niXstavxi^i. Qain 

etlam ipae cjelographna apnd Saidam et Samiua et Bbodiaa dioi- 

tar atqne in acholila Apolloniania Argonantioa Dlonyaio vel Mileaio 

vil Mjrtilenaeo aine nllo dlaorlmine adtribnuntur. Deinde Scyto- 

braehionia et eyolographi libromro naturam atqne Indolem eandem 

fiuaee vol Welekeraa adgnovit [ep. Oyd. I p. 79] ncqne aolam 

In pragmatiob rationibna eoa oonoinero aed etlAm in veteram teati- 

BMNiiia adponendia ex eia quae de Scytobraohione dlapntavi adparait, 

qoia etiam ei aoetorea^ qnoa Scytobrachio adhibere aolebat a oy- 

dognipho adfemntur e. g. Hecataoua [cf. aohol. Eur. Oroat. 872] 

val Aegtmii poeta [aohol. Eur. Phoen. 1116 cf. achol. Apoll. III '• 

587]. Eodem aoholio oUam illa Soytobrachionia conauetudo ifioh 

rr/cot^ diatingnendi [of. anpra p. 46] occurrlt; praeterea Argi Are* 

ftoridao deaoriptlo aperte ApoUonii Bhodii Argonautica [I 824 aq.] 

redolet neqne acio an olim in oommentario diacrimen quod Phe- 

recTdea inter Argum lovia filium etAreatoridem atatuerat| expoai-'' 

tam faerit: eerte in Argonautamm oatalogo Laurentiano Argna 



3 



. r 



\- 



flacentom Soytobraohioni deberi o Diodoro [III 67] elucot [cf. Cram. 

•a. Oxon. IUI p. 876]:. tum vero quid obstat quominua Bysantinua istc . 

Bovom dootriDae fruitulam nesoitur unde oonrasum adgluUnasse pute- 

t»? Hnina o4nauetudinia in oeteris Tsejtaae libris et apnd Enstathium 

oampla innumera aunt At aliud qnid animadvertatur velim. Diony- 

■na iqrolographua Homero quippe quem bellomm Thebanl et. Troiani 

laqnalenr foisse statuerot [FHO II p. l6 flr. 10] Thabaida vindioasse fieri . 

aao poieat /qnin putetor [of. Welokeri ep. C^ol. I p, 201 sq.]* Atqui 

qeao eoiioL Ap. I 46 Soytobrachione ijtuotore dlountur oSri "bfino^^ 

mi 'ii^Moc oSri •NQiMv^^f liyowu rop "iifiMlov our tois k^miinis 

id lUadem et Odyaaiam referri . minime poasunt quippe ubi praeter 

/1 69.^AjrfOttaatamiji expediUonia mentio non faota aiti aed aperte ad ' 

ilind oamlbn Homerb adsoipiptniil pertinenti fortaase ad Noatoa oL Paua« r~ 

xa^cwd.a^*Yit>^.ijoc. • :■ 

• • 1. • ^ -^ * 






tl 



4, 



t\ 



loYM filiiiB reoenaetur ')• Doniqae Dionysii apud AtltenMain mea- 
tionem Didymo, quippo qui paulo inflra nominetar, deberi adnoto 
atque quae snpra de Soytobracbioue ab eo oompilato ditpataYi in 
memoriam revoco [p. 88]. — At quoniam cyeli Tocalmlo totam 
historiae poeticae motem fabulis deincepi enarratie qaaci nno dr» 
culo deductam significari cognitnih esti buic rationi quae Diodorue 
Dionyeii libroi reoeniens dicit [III 66, 6] bene quadrare bodie 
negari non licet Sed ipia Procli verba apud Pbotiam perl^ai 
[lahn-Micbaelii grlecb. Dilderohr. p. 98] : SuAofifiam d§ ttai nsfl 
fot; Xsyofiivav inutod xvkXw Sg SeX^VM fiip & r^ Oigapoti koU 
r^ ftvMioyfWftivtiQ filSiBwg — nrgere nolim miram qaae apnd 
Diodoram [I 7] traditor e caelo et terra coimogoniam qna Yete- 
rum iUorum deornm ooitai qaaii in hominum pragmaticomm 
linguam vertitur, quia illam Scytobrachioni deberi c«iii rationibui 
probare non poiinm. Sed baeo quotieni legi: Aanoffi^vai ii vii 
VB SkXt^ n8(^ 9wSy io2g *SU^ fiv9oX»yovfitm tkooro non potui 
qoin Scytobrachiottii copioiae de Baccho diiputationii meminiiiem 
— quid? quod ipime pragmaticae rationci a Prodo oommemoran* 
tur: iud d nov n xal n^ UnoQlaw Ifyihf^liSsm. Epicomm ear- 
minum fabulai a Pionyiip laepiiiime adferri lupra eompluribui 
locii adparuit, Non auiim in tanta re poit viri illiui incompara* 
bilii lummoi laborei atque merita minutiii argutii innixui lubi- 
tarium iudicium ferre, hanc tamen coniectnram proponere milii 
liceat, propter crebra epicorum teitimonia primum illum «qrdum 
diotum ene epicum quo S<7tobrachio totam hiitoriam &bu]arem 
inde a mundi initio nique ad bellum Troianum Achivommqae 
reditui rationibui pragmatidi quam lacpinime adhibitii vd fidiulia 
vetuitii commemqratii complezui eiiet Hultum lane ab eo dutant 
Procli (^dui vd ii de qno Olementli icholiaita [cf. Welcker. 
ep. Oyd. I p. 82 n. 88] cogitaiie videtnr, ttcqae grammatid poito- 
riorii aevi id agebant nt qnam plnrimai fiibnlaram formai more 



* > 



-) 



1) Non omiaerim et codice Laurentiano et ea reoenioiHyginiani 
parte qua catalogui Apollonianni refertur enumerari quinquiginta 
quattttor heroai qoam omnium lummam faiiie Dionyiioi tradidit of. 
Diod. IIII 41, S : i^i ahv twrf tovg Snarrng ifvtu mvnixovfm mkI tHfOQas 
et 0. 6(^ i nmifitovta miI t(na\v «vJgiai. [porierat enlm Iphii e. 48^ 4]. 
LV enim yirii ab Apollonio enameratii oum propter vi. 101 iq« Theieai 
intruiui enety in oatalogo Laurentiano numerui ille ita reititatoi eei 
ut Phalereui et Iphitui Nauboli f. omitterentor; apud ^ygimun • qoi 
Pirithoum quoqne addiderat deiunt Talani Ariui Leodooni. , 



60 , 

Dhmitmiio in imiiiii ooDgererent, ted ez 'singnlaram oanninnnr 
«ngnlie nigamentie aliqnnm hiatoriae fabnlarii nmbram atque*ima« 
l^nem. .eenpoenisse ealis habebant: qnid tamen? ETannit (^oli Dio- 
aysiaiii doolrina; remanebat nomta elariesimnm atqne libellie ab 
irtie gnBnmaliflie apeaioeo proponi eolebat. 



' ^ 



'.,» 



». v . ■ I 



• *; • r - • 






. t 






- ' * 



"... » 



^ •'. 



i ■ 






f .• 



1 < . » 



1 • 









<• 



t .'I 



• . •• 



:,J 



tl 



« 



. \ 



, 


.«'• ■. r 


V. 


i.-i 




••> ' \ 


A 


. V. • v\ 




* * 


• 
/ 
• / 


> - ■ 'x 




■'. •''.V' 


< f 


^- ^- ■' 



il ■■ 



.y\ 



r ■ 1/- ■ 



r : .. 






y 



« 



• I 



. I 



r-- 



■■■ t i---'i- •■• •■ ■ ■■ •;• 

# I . ' .^ . • . • 

^ » » «.*— wk— -•—• ' •• •• • . 

I.f" . . ».- • ... - :•'• . L , •' • • V*. ^>*. 



4 



I ' t 



Vitft 



..^ 



NfttuB Bam Eduardas SchwArtz KiloDiae »• h. s. LVIII patre 
HermAnno roatre Sophia do gente MichAolis. Anno LVIIII Harbnr* 
giumy a. LXII Oottingam parentes migrarunt. A. LXV gymna- 
linm Gottingense adii. Cuius disciplina per decem annos nsiu, 
a. LXXV maturitatis testimonio instmotue inter Georgiae Angnstae 
dyeB receptus sum. A. LXXVI Bonnam profectui per biennium 
hnini almae studiomm sedis ciYii fui, tum per lenoi meniei Be- ] 
rolini et Gryphiae oommoratni sum. Autumno a. LXXVIIII huc 
redii. Doouemnt me yiri clArissimi Baumann Fick Pauli Sauppe 
Waohimnth Oottjngensesi Aufrecht Buecheler KekuU Leo Vsener 
BonnenseSf Mommsen Zeller Berolinenses^ Kiessling de Wilamowits 
Oryphienses. Vt in seminArium philokgum Bodnense reciperer — 
euius sodAlis per nil semenstriA fui, per nnum senior — - Bneche» 
leri et Vseneri beneYolentiA fACtum est, exeroitAtionibns philologieis * 
ut interessem permiserant Buecheler et de WilAmowiti, Arohaeo- 
logicis KeknM. Quibus viris omnibns magnAS habeo gratias, im- 



primis vero Bnecheleri et Vsenerl praepeptoram menoriam grato 
pioque semper animo oolam. 









.^ 



-) 



»:< 



.t 






1 
105 

<4 



f . 



SententiM eoBtraTersM 



^ 



■■I 



Steliai iilT. 18, 81 scripsit: 

slo OhAloicUi fluoino 
exp^llontoin Anlit, sio dinociata profmido 
Bnittia Bioaninin oircnmspioit ora Polomm. : 
CMd. ozpdlnnt flnvii. Do Anlido et Ghaloido of. Strab.. 
Tlin p^8. Plin. HN mi 64, do Yorbo ozpollendi Plin. t. 1. 78 

'. " ' '• ■- •'" ". •-• 

Taler. Flaeo. H 635 •oripdt: ^ . 

finotne defertnr behia in imoe 
iam tntis roTolnta iradis. 
' Codd. totis raiolnta. 

m 

.Horati iter Bmndisinnm non a. 717 sed hieme a. 7 16/7 onm 
Odtttfiani nomine Ifaeoenas ab Antonio peteret nt contra Sez. 
PDnqpeinm anzilinm ferreti faotum est 

mi 

Horat sat I 8,, 10 iU distingno: , * 

hoo miserae plebi siabat oommnne sepnlcmro; 
Pantolabo seorrae Momentanpqne nepoti 
miller pedes in finonte, treoentos dppns in agmm 
^Uo dabaty heredes mbnnmei^m ne seqneretnr. 

FlanjU Trinnmmi seaena ys. 8^2—907 dittographiis oonfosa 

«1 fiAwB. 924 sq. ar 92§ sq. 928 = 9pl . 929 sq. « 986 sq. 952 sq. 

» M6 eq. .968--^71 a 981—986. Ci^ntio igitnr est ne tnrbis, 

fsaa iBsalMf nt ninltae^ .ez Yordbns transponendis Yd laennis sta- 



ZMdek petatnr. 
i 4' 



- .-».--, — 



/• 



•• \ 



m 



: •J. 



ii 






X 



"^ 



X- 



r. 



I' 



r.< 



^.., 



VI 

Hesiodi fragm, Y Ooettl. [ap. Mhol. Plai. symp. p^ 183 B 
(t VI p. 257 ed. Herm.)] iU restitiiatar: 

ix mv <r S^v sdfptsv dnolvifiop dv^gtitnHav 

vocqndUav BQyiav ntgl KvngtioQ 
ood, ifiiivova. Gf^ yerba eoholiastae: l^^pffoXmoqiffKogoixifinolvtfiog. 

VII 

Hymni Homeriei in Hercariam tbi. 268 — 277 non antiqai 
esae Tidentor. Forsitan hoc loco mmilia olim. enarrata fiierint 
atqne qnae tradit ApoUodoros [bibl. III 10, 2, 5]: nffbg Mouav ^ 
KvXkipniv nagaylvsim mi t6v ^Egfi^v jn&w^ i} «T inidulSisv nMr 
iv nltg anoifydvotg, 

VIII 

Plat. Theaetet. p. 166 B ita l^ velim: mvm i^ o^ot ^o- 
koyijfiaia jgia ftdxBUu avi» aiimQ iv t^ ^itiQf ywf^ Svuv xA ntgl 
niv daigaYdltav Xiywftsv Ij Smv ffwfnsv ifii TtpitK6vdi Svm fc^» 
av^ivm fiijxs loirdv^v na96vta ifiovwf [oodd. iv inavm} (Jaov 
ivmy aov lov viav vZv fiiv fuli^ Jvai^ vav^v di Ikdnw fi^v 
mv ifioZ SyKOV dqm^^iwoq iXkd aod aHjtf^ivioQ* 

vnn 

. Diodor.. bibl. I 6 scripsit: Tugi fiiv ovv ^mv jlvag iwotag ' 
&JXOV' oi ngwtot HamdelSiavr^ ufi&v i6 dtSov nal mv fiv^oloyov- 
ninav ntQl SKdawv xdiv ddavdmv^ iib fiiv nokkd avvidlSaa9m (^oiy 
n»Qaa6ftsda xa^ lilav itd vi x^v ino^satv mvnfv nokXov liyav 
nQogfi^Maif Saa (T av mtq nQomfiivatq bnoglai/g ioix6m iHlfitfisv 
vntiQx^v noQadilfCOfjisv iv xsifaXalotg xA, cf. o. 9, 4. 



« . • •• 



X 



ApoUodori [bibl. II 1, 8, 8] yerba foede disiecta el Paaa. 11 16. 
schol. fi. 120. schol. Ear. Phoen. 1116 ita fere conaarcinentar: Sv 
ItiakhpndirjQ ftiv l^giamQOQ Xdyu (iud MvxijvtiQ i^ ^lvd^ov ^v- ' 
yatQ^c^y.OsQSxvifiQ is \^lvdxov] (xlv fiiv Jti^ n&r ^ldQianQOQ^^ 
KiQxaitff is [jiQyov xdl ^lafi^vtjQ r^ *Aaumov] [9vyavQ6g\ • • 
*AxovaUaog (ti y^ev^ aitov Xiysi. Verbis ^Agyov xal 7a^qy7( rijc 
^Aaomov inepte repetitii ceteraqnoqne in labem^iite^iftielrMMitiir. 

^^ X- 

^lamQUu scholiis Homericis inaertae partim e Tetnctiore Iliaatj 
et Odyniae commentario excerptae partim ez /abalarom oompendio 
bibliothocae Apollodoreae nmillimo deicriptae innt. . 



,M, .. 



. ^ 




■ - .. ..••••••«■-r-.jE»» •••••■IITCIi 

.:..:•.-■.:. r..»":;:;!;?*!""»^"» 




..-.:;:;:■•':::: :SSSIH»::;s! 



t;-;-:i::S!:fif;£|?S2!|;-i!n!J?": 

Fii-:;H- -;i;:::ijil3i:^85"««i'5' 




-- :;;.:.:i;-:?;n--'s::J:|J;::5Uj 

,;i":^::;ii=;:n:;::s?«U» ;♦!•;•:=; 



r.l:;: ;i:?;iSsti,»w|yiL 
.;:;;fn:il!!in^H:|tiK2!S? IJ 

i-:!!ii^isiiiissj;?l||!|ill 

~ •■•:•::. v;:::"::,.:-uMsi»<>ifi£«| 




n;:HI:Hi:;:lulisiili^pl|H 

-::•:■: ::.;r!;:.lc:::}S;u*i;.2« 

^:!ni:'ii:;=;in;!ii'iiii?jssisl3 

•i';i:^=i;|;;:'ii;!l!i"fiiB|HKiP! 

-::•:::■:;?: .;:;:.;rajJJ};?:it;:-: 

::: ::;-;;fj:::i::;l:i?«ha|!it||a 

;.:■-■: •■'2S;;:;!S!»Sl«W*'«|:'':* 
' :•:•"■.• :":Si:K:r!'3:'" :•:;: 

i .';=:;;i;;iiiiii^iii=isSK«;t;ii| 
r:i:i:^s;iii55nii-iii:s2s:iS:«i» 




'•":!:'■ 

:-•:-■;• 
iui;:::. 
r;:!.S;: 
-:i::::: 



!■■;:::;;:•:;: iiiniiiiillsi?:!;^!: 
iiiiiliiiiiiji^niiii'?-^ 

''■''V'','':'i\!^'^'*^"''i'',': 

■ :i:;i;^;^!?liiiiii!i:i:| 
iini-iiiiiiHniiiiiijUHi 

:'-^i:;i:iiii!;ii!i;-iiiiii 

.. ;^i;;i!;iiiili:i;i:::i:ii:^ 
:-::;:;i;:::v-H5::':;::;;=!::: 
r . ilv:;ii:::i:i-Hiiii:;::;w;j|' 
;;;;i:;;;ii';;i;ii:!:55!aii|i||i!*! 

-::.::-si::;:;:::::Hi:i!JitTi!::j;; 

!i:'iii-:-':;i:;-:!/5!i:i?i:n:S^': 

;vr::;:;::-;':rl::;?iHl:;-H?S 
:::;::;';:•: :::::::::ii:":::; 
•.:.:;:;i::-;;::inii:«!ii»tf.g!: 
!:T:^:!::"'::.t:;;;;:;:;;;:s:: 
::;:::•:■;.:.•:!&;::::•.:;::•: 
.:::.:::::-::;.-::;!!::;<:!:S.. 
::;:.•;:••;■:;•:•;::::;!:::•..;, 
;.:;::;.;i:";::.-;:n«:;jis:ni: 

:i':i:"'::!i;i:::li:::S5Hj:5; 
:::;..::^;;:::;;;:«5ti!«=i!«!! 



iniiiililiiiiiiiililJilifilHii 
p: ■:::;!;:':::i:iii|;::?!: •iii';i:ll 

ti; ^f^i^i-iii^ii^^iiiiiiiili^iiliiiiii 

■^!-i -•■■-:•:•. ■'.■■?!S;?3fHr:i 
r'''-'- !;;:;:;:*:i;:-i;«i*iiUsi:i;;: 

'■■• •-• •!!:!: fj«?«Ilrni»Ki; 



■ ■ ■-;:;:::;;:::::•::'?•!? :^K!i;S?i 

;;;;•::.;:;;; ;;;;:;^:j]^;:nj^r:: 
■■-;.. ^:^:::;:;::-:^::::-::.-:; 

i:-!:=i-;i!:!:iliiiiiiiiiSi;i!;;Hiii- 

'■;;;■ • ■ •-••;.;;;:!;!:•• 3. ;...•;•;: 
i..»-. ;• ;i;[;: . ....... ..*;:;•:;::. -• 

:.":':-i:'nniii:':: ::":":':';■;::::■ 
:::: ::ii •;:;-; ^«'iiSisMiiii;!:'":?: 

'•'■'■ ■S:-':''r':U:'::ii'-r:'i':'il':'- ■■■'■•'■ 
-f':::::-::::-™;::-:»:":»»! ;::: 

;:-::!:;;;;:::i!!^::ssyi:j::;::2:;: 
!;•::■;;. ::;;;::;:::-ji:^.v;.:.-:::; 

!• ■:;i:;:;i:;:;ii»«"i';-!!!l:*ii:i: 
j; '•;•'••:•::::;::;;: iiiiiiii-i:;;::': 

::::;:; r.:::i::.:|H:5l::iiaS!':*|i 

:i ■■ii;-:i;;!;iiii;iiiiiiii!ii'i!-^-'i 

^- '■''■"'.*-'•■■ ;■* ■"..:'.'>l^-'-'*'"'i 
'_-.,,. ... '.;;;:";..:*:::."•-•••*"* 



:iii:;!i!;':i::i:iii;;ii;i:'iiiiiai 




iiiaJiiinU 



:::-y.;j:i;;:;iijjtijj:i:ii||||«jI»J 



THE BORROWER WILL BE CHARGED 
THE.COST OF OVERDUE NOTIFICATION 
IF THIS^ BOOK IS NOT RETURNED TO 
THE LIBRARY ON OR BEFORE THE LAST 
DATE S:riiblPED BELOW. 

y 







;»: